Countries of the Arab Middle East have proven extremely impervious to democratic transformation. They have emerged from the wave of successful and unsuccessful democratizations that swept much of the world after the fall of the Soviet Union, with their political systems intact. It is not only that they did not become democratic—many other countries did not either. Rather, for the most part they did not even try. To be sure, most Arab governments now talk about democracy as their ultimate although very distant goal—each country at its own pace and in its own fashion. In the meantime, monarchs continue to govern as well as reign, and presidents remain unfettered by constitutional checks and balances. Blurring the line between monarchies and republics, furthermore, presidents seek to stay in power for life and even to anoint their sons to succeed them.
To analysts who reject, correctly, facile Western explanations about an eternal Arab culture of authoritarianism and equally facile Arab claims that link failure to reform to the impact of the Arab–Israeli conflict, the region's resistance to the inroads of democracy presents a serious challenge. What explains the persistence of authoritarianism in these societies?
Nicola Pratt seeks to answer this question in a book that shows greater familiarity with theories and scholarly sources than with the political reality of the Arab world. The book does a commendable job of summarizing, comparing, and integrating the work of scholars who have addressed the authoritarianism of Arab political systems. It unfortunately does not display the same degree of familiarity with, and firsthand knowledge of, the political process and political actors in Arab countries. Although the author draws in part on her own research among civil society actors in Egypt, most of the book's conclusions are reached deductively from theory rather than inductively from observation and analysis of what is actually happening.
What makes the book worth reading, as a result, is not what it tells us about authoritarianism and democracy in the Middle East—you should not turn to this book to learn about the political battles that are taking place and the political actors who are influencing them. Rather, the book's interest resides in what it tells us about the transformation in the thinking of what used to be a Third World-ist left influenced by dependency theory. Forced to abandon many of the old assumptions when history proved them wrong and political events made their defense unsustainable, this left had to develop a new political model for developing countries and a new vision of the role of external actors. This intellectual transformation parallels that of many Arab actors, namely, the old Arab nationalists who have converted from the glorification of the strong developmental state to that of an active, participatory civil society—for example, from Nasserism to the launch of the Kifaya movement in Egypt. Nicola Pratt is too young to have undergone that transformation in person. Her book, however, reflects the change.
True to the Third World-ist approach, Pratt feels the need to explain present-day problems in terms of the impact of the European penetration of the region and the subsequent integration in the international economic system, as if history began then. Like all new Third World-ists, she also recognizes that the remedy chosen by Arab nationalists in the past—the reliance on state power and intervention without the participation of citizens—“normalized” authoritarianism by fostering a culture that accepted it in the name of a project of national modernization. The project failed, but authoritarianism remained.
That authoritarianism is now being challenged by the rise of new civil society actors calling for political reforms, women's rights, and human rights, according to Pratt. Together with transnational actors who support them—Pratt goes to great lengths in trying to prove that transnational civil society organizations play an important and legitimate role in promoting reform—Arab civil society organizations have the potential for finally moving Arab countries from authoritarianism to democracy.
Here is where the weakness of the research becomes most evident. Pratt looks at civil society actors through the lens of theory, but she misses the reality of what these groups really are and whether they have the capacity to perform the historic role that she assigns to them. Yes, there are many new human rights and women's organizations in the Arab world, but how many people do they reach? How much support do they have? Who funds them? Which groups have a popular following, and which are elitist organizations that exist only because Western organizations fund them? How do Islamists and other civil society organizations relate to each other? Theory does not answer these questions. Serious empirical research would help, and this is where the book is weak.
