Salafism, a controversial school of literalist interpretation within Sunni Islam, is the object of a growing number of scholarly works. Although Salafis today often claim to represent a ‘pure’, seventh-century Islam down to its most minute details, several recent works depict Salafism as a phenomenon that took its definitive shape in the twentieth century. Chanfi Ahmed's book joins this literature, but with a welcome addition: he shows that while Salafism's formation may have occurred in the Middle East and particularly in Saudi Arabia, West Africans made major contributions to the endeavor. Ahmed's book challenges depictions of Africa as a mere recipient of Middle Eastern influences. His findings are important not just for understanding Salafism in both Africa and the Middle East today, but also for better understanding the long history of interactions between these two regions.
With its emphasis on translocal interactions, Ahmed's book complements Stéphane Lacroix's examination of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood's impact on religion and politics in Saudi Arabia, as well as Henri Lauzière's ‘conceptual history’ of twentieth-century Salafism.Footnote 1 Like Lacroix and Lauzière, Ahmed demonstrates that non-Saudis could have a major impact on religious thought, scholarly networks, and educational institutions in Saudi Arabia, a country often depicted as the ultimate closed society. West Africans in Saudi Arabia, in turn, influenced how that country's religious elites sought to reach out to Africans through institutions such as the Islamic University of Medina, where several West African scholars taught and wrote.
Ahmed's core method is reconstructing intellectual biographies. He organizes six major West African scholars into two intellectual lineages and three generations, focusing on the twentieth century. Their biographies offer insight into several interrelated phenomena: how European colonialism affected West African Muslims; how encounters among various movements contributed to the formation of Salafism; and, how Saudi Arabia's educational institutions, especially the Islamic University of Medina, absorbed translocal influences.
Ahmed's use of individual biographies shows that for West African scholars navigating various translocal encounters, coping strategies were essential: one West African scholar, Alfa Hashim (c. 1866–1931), displayed a ‘genius for survival’ (24–7). Alfa Hashim fled the French colonial conquest of present-day Mali and then fought against the British colonial conquest of present-day northern Nigeria, only to spend the last decades of his life negotiating religious and political change in Medina first under the reign of Sharif Husayn of Mecca and then under the early Saudi state. Such episodes help the reader situate influential Muslim scholars amid state-building projects occurring in both colonial West Africa and the Middle East. These episodes also help the reader to examine interactions between intellectual, religious, and political life in this period.
Readers looking for a theory-building project in Ahmed's book will come away disappointed. Aside from some brief methodological comments about how to understand the Islamic tradition of biography writing and how to interpret disciples’ biographies of their shaykhs (11–12 and 186–8), Ahmed devotes little time to discussions theory or methodology. But for me this does not detract from the book's quality, nor is theory-building Ahmed's purpose: instead, he uses scholars’ biographies to show that the study of Islamic thought in and out of West Africa is valuable for understanding broader trends in the Muslim world as a whole.
There is at least one missed opportunity in the book, however: Ahmed could have engaged more substantively with the growing Western academic literature on Salafism, as well as with Western scholarship on the history of Saudi Arabia. Where Ahmed engages this work, he does so to correct minor errors of fact or interpretation, an endeavor related to his overall objective to rectify the marginalization of Africans and Indians in the history of Salafism (for example, 86–7). But Ahmed only briefly engages the bigger questions that other works have agonized over: What is Salafism, really? How do we situate it historically? What, if anything, distinguishes Salafism from Wahhabism? How do expressions of Salafism vary from one locality to another? It would have been fruitful to hear Ahmed's perspective on the core arguments and ideas advanced in David Commins's The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia, the edited collection Global Salafism, Terje Østebø’s Localising Salafism, Laurent Bonnefoy's Salafism in Yemen, and Richard Gauvain's Salafi Ritual Purity, among others. Such engagement would have increased the ratio of analysis to description in the book. Nevertheless, Ahmed's rich materials make this book an essential addition to multiple fields, including African and Middle Eastern history.
