In the 2014 movie The Interview, Dave Skylark (played by James Franco) states: “It’s the first rule of journalism. You give the people what they want!” Unfortunately, as those who study the role of the news media in the political process know, this quote from an otherwise forgettable movie is all too accurate about today’s political news. In his book, Joseph E. Uscinski focuses on understanding the role of the capitalist market on the American news media’s coverage of policy issues and how this ultimately detracts from the public’s ability to learn about these issues. Through statistical and case study analysis, he shows that while the news media have the potential to impact great learning and deliberation regarding politics, due to market forces and the public’s choices they fall short of their lofty potential. In short, The People’s News provides a necessary explanation of just how thoroughly the free market impacts the type of news that we get, and how this harms us, even as Americans increasingly distrust the media for giving them what they want.
The main scholarly addition of this book is to disentangle the problem of supply and demand in political news. In other words, a primary question is whether scholars ought to blame the news media for the dearth of policy coverage, or if this blame should rest more on the shoulders of the American public. The answer according to Uscinski, is that even among the broadcast networks of ABC, CBS, and NBC, it is the audience’s impact on news that drives it away from politically informative content.
The book begins with a discussion of the main theories regarding the news media in American politics. The first chapter looks at how structural market forces permeate how one covers politics, regardless of the journalist's awareness of market incentives. Yet the news media are given greater constitutional freedom and power, which should lead them to be above a pure-market based model. Hence, the media have an opportunity, and some would say an obligation, to provide more than just what the public wants to hear, but subsequent chapters of the book show this does not take place.
The second chapter begins with a summary of the history of media-effects research and moves into a broader discussion of agenda setting and its role in the literature. The most important component of this chapter is the attempt to disentangle the causal mechanism of agenda-setting research in American politics. Simply put, a correlation between what the public deems as being salient and what the news media put on television could be the result of either the public’s interest in issues or the stations’ privileging of some issues over others.
Using data from the Vanderbilt Media Archive, Uscinski looks at the coverage of the three main broadcast channels over the span of 1968–2010 to determine what type of issue coverage is driven by the public and what type of coverage is driven by the networks themselves. He finds that, over time, the audience is more likely to drive the content of news than the broadcast networks are to drive issue salience among the public. Yet there are instances in which the news media can drive what the public thinks is important.
Thus, the third chapter is dedicated to explaining this civic-minded journalism that can impact what the public thinks about. Although there is growing evidence that cable news networks provide ideological content to appeal to a niche audience, Uscinski uses Chapter 3 to look at the ways in which broadcast networks have changed over time. The main conclusion of this chapter is that changes in mass partisanship do influence news coverage for the next three quarters of a year. In short, it is not only cable networks that respond to the partisan inclinations of the American public.
The biggest strength of this book lies in the fourth chapter, however. Usinski moves from looking purely at broadcast networks and instead does case-study analysis of the influence of audiences on cable networks’ coverage. First, he looks at how cable networks use unscientific polls as a way of gauging what audiences want to hear about specific issues. For instance, Fox News’s Bill O’Reilly used online polls to help him stay on the same side as his audience over the shooting of Trayvon Martin by George Zimmerman. Yet social media now also provide the opportunity for cable networks to learn about audience views and change how issues are covered. The example provided to make this case is the 2010 Delaware Republican Senate primary victory of Christine O'Donnell over Rep. Mike Castle. Shortly after this upset by the Tea Party—backed candidate, Fox News contributors Charles Krauthammer and Karl Rove called the general election a lost seat. Quickly, the audience started denouncing this tone of coverage by emailing and tweeting the network. Not longer afterward, the two contributors started to backtrack and become more positive toward O'Donnell. This chapter, more than any other in this book, proves the real impact of the audience on news in America today.
Usinkski concludes with a discussion of what the news should look like by offering seven changes to the media landscape: 1) Limit sensationalism in coverage; 2) provide more substantive and policy-oriented coverage; 3) provide higher-quality commentators rather than purely entertaining journalists; 4) displace the horse-race coverage with discussions of policy; 5) ensure that journalists are less focused on public interaction, as discussed in Chapter 4; 6) draw a brighter line between commentary and news; and 7) provide ideological parity in coverage.
The author makes many interesting arguments, and his book is one of the few works to seriously try to explain the causal flow between news coverage and what the public thinks is salient. These suggestions are not surprising, yet they appear to forget what the entirety of the book is about. Its very core is about understanding the impact of the capitalist consumer-driven market on news coverage, but all of the solutions are aimed at what the news ought to change about itself in order to provide better coverage for the public. These suggestions cannot solve the problem as long as one network remains interested in capitalism. Looking simply at the success of the Fox News Channel as consistently being the second-highest-rated cable network (only ESPN beats it), one can surmise that the solutions proffered by Usinski are not what the public wants. It certainly makes sense to try and fix problems with the way that the news is done, but with the focus of the book on market forces, these solutions are less than satisfactory.
While the solutions to the problems of journalism are lacking, Usinski nicely highlights what the problems are. This book would fit very nicely into discussions of agenda setting, the economic incentive to present polarized news, and how the public impacts news coverage. In all, The People’s News is a solid contribution to our understanding of the news media, the public, and how we discuss politics in the United States.
