This work collects fifteen studies on early Islamic history and religious thought by the late Suliman Bashear, a Druze Arab scholar from the village of Mghar in northern Israel who studied at Hebrew University and the University of London and then taught at Birzeit University, al-Najah University in Nablus, and, finally, Hebrew University in Jerusalem until he died of a heart attack in 1991 at the age of 44. The collection includes thirteen previously published articles and two articles published here for the first time. The volume is introduced by a biography of Bashear by Lawrence Conrad. The volume is a fitting tribute to the genius of an insightful scholar whose works show a rare combination of painstaking dedication to the topic and a fresh originality. The influence of Bashear's primary professor, Kister, is evident in his focus on the first two centuries of Islamic history and his intensive and meticulous use of hadith reports as source material. Bashear was also influenced by Hobsbawm's work on the invention of tradition and by the revisionist scholarship of Wansbrough and others, although he used their work critically.
The studies included in the collection are the following thirteen published articles: “Yemen in Early Islam: An Examination of Non-tribal Traditions,” Arabica 36 (1989): 327–61; “Qurʾan 2:114 and Jerusalem,” Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies 52 (1989): 215–38; “Abraham's Sacrifice of his Son and Related Issues,” Der Islam 67 (1990): 243–77; “The Title ‘Faruq’ and Its Association with ʿUmar II,” Studia Islamica 72 (1990): 47–70; “Riding Beasts on Divine Missions: An Examination of the Ass and Camel Traditions,” Journal of Semitic Studies 46 (1991): 37–75; “Qibla Musharriqa and Early Muslim Prayer in Churches,” The Muslim World 81 (1991): 267–82; “‘ʿAshuraʾ: An Early Muslim Fast,” Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft 141 (1991): 281–316; “The Mission of Ḍiḥya al-Kalbi and the Situation in Syria,” Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam 14 (1991): 84–114; “Apocalyptic and Other Materials on Early Muslim–Byzantine Wars: A Review,” Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society (1991): 173–207; “The Images of Mecca: A Case Study in Muslim Iconography,” Le Muséon 105 (1992): 361–77; “On the Origin and Development of Zakat in Early Islam,” Arabica 40 (1993): 84–113; “Muslim Apocalypses and the Hour: A Case Study in Traditional Interpretation,” Institute for Objectivist Studies 13 (1993): 75–79; “Qunut in Tafsir and Ḥadith Literatures,” Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam 19 (1995): 36–65. The two new studies are “Ḥanifiyya and the Ḥajj” and “Jesus in an Early Muslim Shahada and Related Issues: A New Perspective.”
Bashear draws on hadith reports recorded in an extremely wide variety of sources in order to investigate the early history of Islamic doctrine and practice. Most of his conclusions focus on the second Islamic century in particular, and most have to do with the Jewish and Christian background of Islamic belief and ritual. Unlike earlier scholars who focused on either Jewish or Christian influence to the exclusion of the other, Bashear focuses on both Jewish and Christian elements in connection with early Islam. Although he is certainly revisionist, he is not a radical skeptic; he discounts many reports as later forgeries or interpolations but does not throw out evidence without specific grounds, insisting that it must be shown why the material in question is not authentic. It is evident from many of his studies that, in his view, one can reliably extract historically valid information about the second Islamic century from the hadith reports that have been preserved, thus retrieving material that was lost, glossed over, modified, or suppressed in the later tradition. In a number of cases, Bashear has taken up statements of earlier Western scholars that identify a preclassical layer to Islamic theories and practices closely tied to Jewish and Christian material and characterize them as cases of borrowing. Bashear in most instances vindicates these claims but provides much additional evidence, giving a fuller and more precise picture of the early, now lost stage, as well as describing and analyzing more precisely the history of the ideological change that occurred afterward to supplant or otherwise obscure the original layer.
Thus, for example, he looks at the fast of ʿAshuraʾ, long recognized as similar to Yom Kippur, and the practice of adopting Jerusalem as the direction of prayer, both of which have been recognized as Jewish elements in the early mission of the Prophet. Similar features are the title Faruq given to ʿUmar, which has been recognized as a Jewish messianic term; his discussion of tafsir concerning the Qurʾanic references to places of prayer in Jerusalem; and his discussion showing that early Muslims, as Goldziher notes, believed that Isaac was the son Abraham was ordered to sacrifice, and not Ishmael, as later Islamic doctrine would have it. He also sees in apocalyptical material fundamental connections with Jewish and Christian traditions. Bashear has unearthed significant material of which many are not aware, such as accounts of early Muslims praying in churches and a version of the shahada, probably from Palestine, which includes a declaration of faith in Jesus, in addition to Muhammad, as a prophet.
On the whole, Bashear agrees that an earlier, more ecumenical Islamic movement, perhaps tied to a form of Judeo-Christianity, was modified more or less radically in an effort to distinguish Islam more clearly from Judaism and Christianity and to emphasize their differences. Elements of this thesis had been suggested by others, including Goldziher, Wansbrough, Crone, and Cook, and so forth, but Bashear's work goes beyond theirs. His main contribution is to have backed up claims based on limited evidence with substantially more material than others had mustered before him and, through insightful source criticism, to suggest more precise dates both for the early doctrinal stages and the later modifications and interpolations. His knowledge of hadith transmitters, textual criticism of hadith reports, and arguments for and against their authenticity are impressive.
The fifteen studies included in this volume represent a major contribution to our understanding of Islam in the 2nd century, and Bashear's work, together with that of Kister and his other students, should inspire further critical work using hadith material in the future. The fact that these articles were produced in only six years, between 1985 and 1991, suggests the tragedy of the untimely loss of this brilliant young scholar who was extremely energetic, persevering, original, and unflinching in his pursuit of knowledge.
