Challenges to academic freedom have been much in the news of late, with coverage and interest extending well beyond college newspapers and the publications of our profession.
In the United States, there is no question that members of the Middle East studies community have been disproportionately targeted. A number of our colleagues have been victims of ugly smear campaigns regarding their scholarship; several tenure cases have triggered vicious, high-profile “extramural” attacks against junior faculty; and, in a handful of cases, our colleagues have been barred from giving talks or participating in educational events, owing to their political positions on Middle East-related issues. Others from outside this community who have also ventured to engage key regional issues in critical ways have had their invitations to give presentations in policy or academic forums rescinded.
Our field puts many of us at the intersection of perhaps the two most prominent issues on which those assailing the academy have focused: the Arab--Israeli conflict and U.S. foreign policy. As a result, those of us in Middle East studies may be tempted to see these two areas as the only ones that elicit attacks on academic freedom. However, we must not overlook other disciplines that have also been lambasted of late, in many cases just as viciously if perhaps not as relentlessly. Those who are familiar with the websites and publications of those most actively engaged in slandering members of the professorate know that scholars prominent in peace studies, gender studies, critical theory, race, and ethnicity have also been targeted. When we add this constellation of (inter)disciplines to the triggers of attacks against Middle East scholars, what is at stake becomes quite clear. Each field in its own way lays bare and critiques existing power relations and hegemonic paradigms. The potential for subverting the political, social, or economic order is apparently too threatening for those benefiting from or heavily invested in the existing power hierarchies to tolerate.
We must also bear in mind that beyond the academy the integrity of scientific investigation has also been under siege. Experts in the sciences---particularly those studying global warming, promoting reproductive health, or teaching evolution---have found their work attacked, suppressed, or ridiculed by powerful economic and/or ideological allies of the current political power elites.
These varied attacks on free intellectual inquiry and expression should be seen as manifestations not only of the anti-intellectualism that plagues the United States but also of the desire to silence critical voices from universities, which, given the ongoing emasculation of the fourth estate, remain one of the few sites of wide-ranging public exchange. It has been from within the academy that myriad critical voices have challenged not only the war in Iraq but also the entire complex of post-9/11 measures that have undermined civil rights in the United States. That scholars should therefore be the target of particular ire from those invested in the national-security state should not be surprising.
The ugly situation in the United States over the past few years must be confronted clearly and with integrity. Most academics do not have the financial resources available to our most vocal and vicious critics. Our best defense is to continue to produce honest and serious scholarship and to train our students in the best tradition of nuanced and critical inquiry. Those of us who have the privilege of tenure have a particularly important, additional responsibility: we must be prepared to defend not only our own work but also that of our pretenure or untenured colleagues, who are especially vulnerable.
In considering our professional and moral responsibilities to fellow educators and students, we must never forget that those in the Middle East face the greatest risks. In Iraq, war, sanctions, more war, occupation, and now sectarian violence have destroyed libraries, archives, and the physical plant of many universities; driven thousands of educators and students into exile; killed many others; and forced families to withdraw children from school out of fear for their lives. In the West Bank and Gaza, the long, debilitating, and violent years of Israeli occupation, the construction of the wall, and, most recently, inter-Palestinian fighting have severely compromised educational development, access, and possibilities for hundreds of thousands of Palestinians. Beyond these two cases, for which the United States bears special responsibility, Iran and Egypt currently stand at the forefront of violators of academic freedom in a region plagued by repression of free expression. There, faculty have been arrested and dismissed for political reasons, students have been prevented from exercising their right to peaceful expression of academic demands, and various security forces have attacked and sought to intimidate teachers and pupils alike.
A survey of the current state of academic freedom makes clear that in order to overcome the forces that would silence those of us working on the Middle East, we must avoid a tunnel vision that would limit our concerns to our own intellectual community and to the confines of our home countries. Like other civil and human rights, academic freedom must be understood as indivisible. As scholars, we must be prepared to stand up for these rights regardless of the source or trigger of the attack.
Laurie Brand chairs the MESA Committee on Academic Freedom. This statement, however, does not necessarily reflect the views of the committee.
