The old continental and disciplinary demarcations of area studies have faded so much that an Africanist history journal can ask a Latin Americanist geographer to review a book about the emergence of global networks related to a crop mainly associated with Asia. The volume certainly counts as a multidisciplinary effort, the product of a 2011 workshop on ‘New Histories of Rice’ that involved historians, plant geneticists, anthropologists, and linguists who variously specialize in Africa, Asia, Europe, and the Americas. Those authors situate their research within diverse literatures: economic history, the history of science and technology, historical linguistics, development studies, crop biology, cultural geography and anthropology, area studies, and others. Some authors therefore focus on documentary sources but others on genes, languages, material culture items, and landscapes. Even a first scan through the resulting 15 chapters reveals one result: an eclectic mix of historic illustrations from archives interspersed with diagrams of phylogenetic relationships, choropleth maps, and graphs of rice production.
The editors somewhat limit the diversity of approaches by concentrating on the last five centuries, even though people domesticated rice some 10,000 years ago, because only during the colonial period did global networks become established through that link, for example, West Africa and the Americas. Moreover, although the chapters range across Asia, Africa, and the Americas, they mainly focus on West Africa, East Asia, Southeast Asia, and the US South. Transoceanic connections also feature prominently in some chapters, especially between the Rice Coast of West Africa and North America.
To further tame the diversity of the contributions, the editors organize the 15 substantive chapters into 3 sections. The first treats the tension between homogeneity and heterogeneity, whether the relationship between the global hybrid varieties of the Green Revolution and thousands of local landraces, capital-intensive versus labor-intensive agriculture, or interactions between the standardization of production technologies and diverse consumer preferences. The second section emphasizes the environmental dimensions of rice cropping such as its role in mitigating the impact of drought on subsistence, methods of water control, diffusion of rice varieties, and diseases that afflict farming communities. The final section deals with social relations from slavery to households.
The result is an impressive collection of varied perspectives on the way we understand the emergence of rice as a global agricultural commodity, the staple for billions of people, and central to the identity of many cultures. Many of the chapters report fascinating new findings. For example, Hayden Smith provides a much-needed history of the establishment of inland rice plantations in colonial South Carolina, complementing the more thoroughly studied history of tidewater plantations. Walter Hawthorne stresses just how different the cultural meaning of work would have been in the eighteenth century among free laborers in the rice fields of Guinea-Bissau versus enslaved laborers on Brazilian rice plantations. And Edda Fields-Black explicates the use of historical linguistics in the reconstruction of geographic patterns of precolonial rice cropping across part of West Africa.
Combining such diverse chapters into something more than the sum of the parts remains somewhat beyond the scope of the volume. Francesca Bray provides a partial sketch of the global history of rice in the introduction, ‘Global Networks and New Histories of Rice’, which precedes the 15 chapters. Yet no conclusion follows those contributions to draw them together and demonstrate how each fits into shared ‘global networks’ or how the ‘new histories’ fit into a revisionary global narrative. Instead, each chapter remains an impressive, significant contribution to a regional literature, some even to a transregional, Atlantic history. Yet they do not merge into a global history of how rice, its producers, and its consumers were involved in the emergence of colonial and (post)colonial networks that span the world.
The volume nonetheless provides a solid foundation for such a project, theoretically, as well as substantively and methodologically. As Bray suggests, seemingly disparate ideas that have been central to particular regional and disciplinary literatures might provide the basis for a more global understanding of rice. For example, research that critiques the use of the model of agricultural involution to explain the contrast between the histories of Asian and European industrialization aligns with a broad intellectual movement to revise Eurocentric history. Similarly, research that demonstrates the creative involvement of West Africans in establishing rice plantations in the Americas similarly counters Eurocentric history. One object of global research that can bridge regional literatures, therefore, might be the Eurocentric history that became such a prominent cultural feature of the global social/natural networks that emerged to connect colonial Balinese farmsteads, Senegalese villages, and South Carolina slave plantations. Each place and its peoples engaged those networks through quite different means and modes of rice production, but only addressing all of them together, in relation to one another, will result in a more complete, less biased global history. And, as this volume makes clear, Africans will attain a prominent place in that history.
