Andrew Goble sets out to answer a standard two-part question for premodern Japanese history in terms of appropriated continental knowledge: What did medieval Japanese know? How did they use it? By examining Kajiwara Shōzen (1265–1337), a Buddhist monk and practicing physician, Goble shows that the importation of Song-era printed medical texts allowed medical men to update their archives with some of the latest ideas from the continent, revealing how medieval Japan appropriated Chinese knowledge and constructed new forms of medical practice. This is the first English book-length study of medieval medical history, and Goble places Confluences within the historiography that characterizes medieval Japan in terms of “[m]obility, fluidity, redefinition, violence, and experimentation” (Kenmu: Godaigo's Revolution [Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1996], 273.).
In thirteenth-century Kamakura, contact and trade with the continent through the Kyushu port of Hakata was a defining characteristic of the city. Buddhist priests established and extended religious and personal networks from Kamakura, through Hakata, and to the continent, opening the door for the acquisition of new medical knowledge. (These networks, Goble argues, have not received the scholarly attention that they deserve.) Kamakura was home to a growing number of Buddhist institutions like the Ritsu Precept Sect, to which Kajiwara belonged, that gave the needy, including those who suffered from Hansen's Disease, free medical treatment.
During the Song era, medical classics were reprinted, and privately practicing physicians compiled reference manuals that gave Japanese doctors access to the canon as well as a glimpse into the practice of contemporary Song doctors. A snapshot of what Kajiwara acquired from the continent is as follows: one of the first texts dedicated to the issue of women's health, an imperial pharmaceutical formula guide, and a reference manual based on the clinical records of a twelfth-century Chinese doctor. The content of such texts reinforced the notion that medicine was based equally if not more on clinical practice, trial, and adjustment than on the authority of classical texts. Also, Kajiwara learned that medical knowledge had to be routinely updated. Due to the variety of medical works he had, Kajiwara was able to compare older and newer versions of the same text and make informed adjustments to formulas based not only on his own practice but on the clinical manuals printed by Song-era doctors.
Goble uncovers the end of what he calls the silk road of pharmaceuticals through an exploration of Kajiwara's engagement with medical formulas coming from Islamic medicine. Formulas and medicinal materials reached Japan through a multistage network stretching from the Arabian Sea, the Persian Gulf, the Indian Ocean, and the South and East China Seas. Kajiwara faced several challenges in terms of adjusting dosage and measurement between Islamic, Chinese, and Japanese standards as well as finding acceptable substitutions when rarer items were not available.
Song medical knowledge was not limited to highly educated Buddhist clergy. Wound medicine texts, dating from the latter half of the fourteenth century, the first of their kind in Japan, were informed by both Chinese materia medica and wound conceptualizations. In the fourteenth century, the occasional skirmish for advantage practiced by ancient military men was replaced with war and attrition aimed at the complete destruction of enemy forces. Needless to say, things got bloody on the battlefield, creating the need for triage expertise like putting exposed entrails back in place, treating exposed brain, removing arrowheads, fighting pus and maggot-infested wounds, dealing with lacerated genitals, and stopping bleeding (pp. 97–98). Notions of bleeding, especially from Song-era medical texts dealing with women's health and childbirth, informed Japanese doctors’ understanding of the body, and the influx of Chinese and Islamic medicinal products gave these men a wider repertoire for treating wounds.
Goble concludes by reiterating the underlying theme of the book: Kajiwara marks a break from both the Buddhist institutions based in Kyoto and the medical traditions of elite families in the capital. “Like his sect, Shōzen represented a break with—or at least an orientation away from—past practices, rather than continuity with them” (p. 118).
While it is hard to find criticisms for such a highly innovative and impeccably researched volume, I would ask, drawing upon this last point, how this study fits within the new direction in the field of medieval Japanese history, one that Goble helped pioneer, that argues that the destruction of the Kamakura bakufu, not its founding, marked the beginning of the medieval era. Goble's main case study, Kajiwara and his activities in the mid-thirteenth century, all occurred before Emperor Go-Daigo's pivotal regency (the chapter on wound medicine is the only exception). Does Kajiwara prefigure the changes that occurred in the fourteenth century or do we need to push back the dates of Japan's medieval revolution?
