Like activist, the word avant-garde often carries with it a whiff of endorsement for theatre historians. Would I personally leap to join dada cabarets, futurist serate, or Situationist détournements? Maybe, maybe not. But in my history classes I frame such movements as admirable. Avant-garde movements, I tell my undergraduates, push the boundaries of the state of our art; they shake loose possibilities for culture and politics. We benefit from artists who so sharpen performance's cutting edge. My students often conclude (rightfully) that their professor would be pleased if they devised their own vanguard movement to combat today's forces of conformity and constraint.
Kimberly Jannarone's anthology Vanguard Performance beyond Left and Right effectively makes the long-overdue case for checking such encomium. As she writes in her introduction, “innovative performances designed to challenge established power structures can be deployed in deliberate, passionate support of established and even oppressive power structures” (1). Artistic innovation and revolutionary intention do not automatically lead to art that champions equality, liberty, and justice for all. Manifestos that enflame the spirit when read can spill blood when realized; totalitarians may mount stunning productions; and hegemonic regimes routinely assimilate the artistic weapons deployed to resist them. The case studies Jannarone has gathered thoughtfully probe these less comfortable potentials for vanguard performance.
Jannarone organizes her book into three parts. The first, “Heroic Vanguards and Radical Reactionaries,” features essays that grapple with the grimmer resonances between vanguard art and world-changing political visions. Works here include studies on the spectacle of the 9/11 attacks (Richard Schechner), Mussolini's patronage of Luigi Pirandello (Patricia Gaborik), proto-Fascist currents in certain German expressionist plays (Monica Achen), unrealized plans to use T. E. Lawrence in quasi-Fascist propaganda (Graham White), and the failed coup d’état and seppuku suicide of author Yukio Mishima (Kara Reilly). The book's second part, “Exalted and En Masse,” focuses on performance forms that can straitjacket participants into authoritarian-friendly conformity. Essays investigate Mussolini's attraction to and appropriation of choral dances inspired by ancient Greece (Odai Johnson), the immersive power of Evangelical Hell Houses (Ann Pellegrini), the awe-inspiring yet disturbing mass performance of the Beijing Olympics opening ceremony (Katherine Profeta), and the totalitarian twists that Slovenian rock band Laibach imposes on others’ anthems (Eric Butler). The essays in the final part, “Research Wings for the Right,” address artistic, critical, and commercial maneuvers that produce effects contrary to the makers’ antioppressive intentions. Authors examine the coded (and confusing) messages in Allied war drama broadcasts (James Harding), the complicated sexual politics of Cheek by Jowl's 2006 staging of The Changeling (Kim Solga), the commodification of emergent avant-garde theatre in the UK (Liz Tomlin), and the neoliberal tendencies in avant-garde performance historiography and criticism (Mike Sell).
The volume is a gold mine of fascinating work and an invigorating addition to the recent wave of avant-garde scholarship. I learned much, for instance, about Mishima's homoerotic samurai imperialism (Reilly), Pirandello's embrace of Mussolini's patronage (Gaborik), and the commercializing selection processes for new theatre works in present-day London (Tomlin). Ann Pellegrini's pathbreaking piece on Hell Houses (originally published in 2007) remains one of the best treatments of that phenomenon. Several chapters share priceless, you-can't-make-this-stuff-up anecdotes, such as James Harding's account of Allied headquarters replying to their double agents’ transmitted code for “We've been compromised!” with a tut-tut refresher about secret security protocols. I anticipate using many chapters in future seminars for graduates and upper-level undergrads. The volume's relatively limited geographic scope (Europe and the United States, with two chapters focused on Japan and China, respectively) invites future studies.
The anthology's best contributions locate and lean into an energized tension between admiration for vanguard innovation and unease with anti- or not-quite-progressive politics. Kim Solga revisits her prior work on The Changeling (in her 2009 Violence against Women in Early Modern Performance). Originally, she had praised Cheek by Jowl's vanguard portrayal of Beatrice Joanna as victim, a departure from the character's all-too-common interpretation as harlot. Solga determines that her prior reading flatters her feminist sympathies but flattens the character's irreducible complexity. Cheek by Jowl's Beatrice Joanna is virtuosic and troubling at once. Solga models the value of looking again (re-vising), even when (as is the case here) the second look leads to unsettling, less satisfying conclusions.
Katherine Profeta offers a similarly uncomfortable yet engaging reading of the 2008 Beijing Olympics opening ceremony. Directed by acclaimed filmmaker Zhang Yimou, the performance showcased China's ability to discipline thousands of bodies into an intimidating spectacle of simultaneous movement against a backdrop rich with culturally resonant imagery. Profeta interweaves a reading of Zhang's 2002 high-flying fantasy martial arts (wuxia) hit Hero, explicating the nationalist visions of a unified China present in both the cinematic and ceremonial texts. Caught up in the production's virtuosity but disturbed by its more propagandistic, totalitarian overtones, Profeta deftly preserves the complexity of attending to a performance beyond left and right.
Most haunting, however, is Richard Schechner's “9/11 as Avant-Garde Art?” He begins by relating conductor Karlheinz Stockhausen's scandalous declaration that the attacks were “‘the greatest work of art imaginable’” (28). Schechner pushes past the visceral revulsion that such a notion inspires. Calls for violent revolution and the destruction of the present order, he reminds us, are hardly unknown in vanguard art. We do no favors by excusing such rhetoric as metaphorical. He then reads the 9/11 attacks dramaturgically, noting that the attacks’ timing (at the start of the news cycle) and pacing (far enough apart to ensure that the second plane hit was filmed) bespeak a brutally effective production craft. Schechner ends by sharing his own numb shock at seeing the attacks from his own apartment. To pursue vanguard-level revolutions, he reminds us, is to inaugurate a world where, in Artaud's words, “‘the sky can still fall on our heads’” (35).
I find myself sharing bits of Schechner's argument with students and colleagues often. It, along with the rest of this valuable anthology, has changed how I teach Artaud, Marinetti, and other revolutionary artists. Vanguard art does not equal progressive politics. Cutting edges wound, and the blade can easily turn to slice its wielder. The reminder is sobering and timely.
