Promoting Democracy in the Americas begins where Tom Farer's formative book, Beyond Sovereignty: Collectively Defending Democracy in the Americas (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press), left off in 1996. Where the latter established the growing role of international organisations in democratisation, Promoting Democracy reveals how these organisations are now integral to understanding this process. Along with the Organization of American States (OAS), the United Nations, the United States and other major powers, non-governmental organisations and the spread of norms all play a part in shaping the very nature of democratic institutions.
The first section of the book considers the role of the OAS and three major powers, the United States, Canada and Brazil. For Darren Hawkins and Carolyn Shaw, low fears of US intervention together with ‘robust norms of democracy’ are critical to the consolidation of democracy in the transitional state. Dexter Boniface follows up by showing the increasing independence of the OAS in promoting democracy since the end of the Cold War. Even so, he concludes, the organisation remains a disappointment in practice.
In a separate chapter, Shaw describes how the United States' support for democracy has been outweighed by its other interests, especially Cold War anti-communism; Sharon Lean is more pointed later in stating that bilateral electoral intervention by the United States has subverted Latin American democracy. Shaw is optimistic, however, that with the Cold War over, vocal support on the part of the United States can now truly enable the democratic process.
Writing on Canada, Flavie Major finds this country's ‘federalist, multicultural and bilingual’ heritage a true foundation for the support of democracy elsewhere. While Canada proves to be a leader in supporting democracy at the institutional level of the OAS, however, specific actions in Cuba, Haiti and Peru have been less impressive. Only in Peru, where circumstances allowed for a strong and decisive role on the part of Canadian representatives, were the results significant for democratisation. Burges and Daudelin show a similar pattern in Brazil: a strong role in promoting democracy at the institutional level, with a favouring of national interests over any democratising ideal in specific cases.
In a constructivist perspective on electoral monitoring, Arturo Santa-Cruz begins with the ‘real gap between lofty statements’ about democracy coming from the United States and the destructive reality of US intervention. Yet, he points out, we should not ‘dismiss such normative components as trivial’ (p. 143). By tracing the long history of official US support for democracy, Santa-Cruz shows how ‘the western idea’ has, in fact, diffused throughout the hemisphere. So, while the OAS may have been founded by the United States for its own purposes, the organisation's stated commitment to democracy has gained real weight and meaning over time. Sharon Lean supports this perspective by examining the growing institutional framework for elections monitoring. Where the United States had been able to manipulate it in the 1960s, the process has since developed into an ‘effective external validation’ through the involvement of a broad network of committed international organisations.
The final portion of the book includes test cases for the regime approach. In the case of Haiti, David Goldberg considers whether a small sub-regional regime, the Caribbean Community (CARICOM), can be more effective in promoting democracy than larger ones. After tracing the evolution of CARICOM from economic community to political entity, complete with a regional court system and coherent foreign policy, he finds that CARICOM has, in fact, been truer to the cause of democratisation than either the United Nations or the OAS. This is largely due to the organisation's composition – the relatively democratic nature of most member states and the absence of a hegemon among them. Still, in Haiti, CARICOM was marginalised by two powerful players, the United States and France, leaving the question open as to whether smaller, more localised regimes can gain influence in the future.
In other cases – Venezuela, Ecuador, Guatemala – a clear theme emerges: despite its increased role as defender of democracy, the OAS is falling short in its achievements. With limited ability to anticipate or intervene in a crisis, the organisation's involvement has been mainly in the post-crisis phase. In Venezuela this meant facilitating a referendum on Chávez's rule after the attempted coup in 2002. Ironically, Chávez was able to parley his newly found legitimacy associated with the referendum into the passage of new authoritarian measures. In the case of Ecuador in 2005, the OAS declined the monitoring role altogether.
Towards the end of the book we arrive at a penetrating analysis of the limitations of democratic intervention in Yasmine Shamsie's study of Haiti and Guatemala. Shamsie shows how broad-based social groups have been marginalised and ‘social mandates’ have been ignored as a result of the introduction of the pressures of the International Monetary Fund and transnational capital in order to open markets and pay off debt. In fact, ‘the requirements of economic liberalization’, she argues, ‘favor a particular variant of democracy’ known as ‘low-intensity democracy’ (p. 266). As such, ‘democracy’ in these cases is a structurally limited contest among elites and organisations favoured by powerful international economic interests. In her conclusion, Jennifer McCoy underscores the problem of ‘limited or illiberal’ democracy and calls for a ‘reformulation of the democratic social contract’ to allow for ‘fuller citizenship’ rights (p. 284).
While the book purports to do away with the division between international relations and comparative politics, many of the assumptions of comparative politics prevail. The studies are carried out, for instance, on a country-by-country basis, with only fleeting references to the dynamics of power at the international level. While the OAS is certainly affected by the work of NGOs and the diffusion of US norms, it should also be seen as a product of the changing dynamics of power in the region. With this, one might argue that the more cooperative stance taken by the United States within the organisation has occurred only as other members have gained strength and influence in the hemisphere.
Otherwise, the collection is outstanding in providing a comprehensive and detailed analysis of the interplay of international and domestic interests during this transitional era. Each of these painstaking studies reveals a unique and important part of the behemoth that is the process of democratisation in the Americas. The book is truly a landmark in our understanding of this process.
