The current impasse of the Palestinian struggle for justice and the general pessimism over the future of the Israeli–Palestinian relationship further propel scholars to innovate their vocabulary and analytic categories, hoping to carve out a new discursive horizon. Jaffa: Shared and Shattered questions the common categories used for understanding the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. In particular, it reconsiders the popular imagination of two separate national communities, or two mutually exclusive categories of colonized and colonizers, whose interactions toward conflict resolution follow a zero sum logic. Daniel Monterescu provides a rich and sensitive ethnography of Jaffa, a previously thriving Palestinian city shared today by both Arab and Jewish citizens of Israel. He follows the encounters between three collective agents: the Palestinian population (mostly a remnant of pre-Nakba residents), lower class Jews, and a relatively recent population of Jewish gentrifiers. A closer look reveals that each of these groups has multiple subdivisions, and that political reality frequently forces or enables collaborations that cross and intersect these broad categories.
This complexity leads the author to question the usefulness of the three dominant paradigms for analyzing mixed towns in Middle Eastern urbanism—the colonial city, the dual city, and the divided city—which underestimate social networking across ethnic divides. To be sure, Monterescu does not underestimate the power of hegemonic national discourses in shaping the mundane behavior of individuals, nor does he deny the relevance of a colonial paradigm for interpreting political dynamics in Jaffa and more broadly in Israel/Palestine. He convincingly illustrates, though, the limits of relying too much on these interpretive lenses without taking into consideration that the actual encounters constantly produce new potential perspectives. Especially important is the adoption of a relational perspective that sees unfolding processes between actors rather than static exchanges among inert objects.
Monterescu employs a combination of classical participant observation ethnography, analysis of cultural products in Hebrew and Arabic, and an analysis of life stories based on in-depth interviews. The result is a multi-faceted description of both the structural forces that shape life in Jaffa and the agency of multiple actors. This close examination reveals frequent contradictions between the subjective intentions of actors and the actual political implications of their actions. A major example of such a contradiction lies in what Monterescu calls the process of “ethnogentrification” that has shaped social life in Jaffa over the past three decades (135–38). The term captures the way neo-liberal ideology has become a tool for implementing Zionist aspirations to Judaize the space. Monterescu argues that all Jewish gentrifiers take part in the transformation of Jaffa into a bourgeois space of consumption, but at the same time he illustrates their diverse spectrum of political and cultural visions for the city—from the Judaizing real estate approach of the gated community in Andromeda Hill, to the egalitarian vision of “radical gentrifiers” who see in Jaffa a space of engagement and political activism (158–68).
The book contrasts the place of Jaffa in the canonical Palestinian narrative (“a lost paradise”) and Israeli imagination (an Orientalist fantasy of desire and threat) with the mundane local experience of Palestinian and Jewish residents of Jaffa. Mundane considerations create unpredictable collaborations and ad-hoc alliances which defy the logic of national boundaries. For example, activists of al-Rabita, a civic association promoting an identity politics of Palestinian rootedness, attempt to solicit support among Jewish gentrifiers in municipal elections. The most intense and far-reaching attempt to engage wide social circles in Palestinian–Jewish coresistance took place during the country wide social protest in summer 2011. One of the book chapters follows the hesitant collaboration between activists from Hatikva, a Mizrahi lower class neighborhood in southern Tel Aviv (and a traditional bastion of the ruling Likud party), and Palestinian activists from Jaffa (accompanied by some left-leaning Jewish gentrifiers). The tension between the desire of Palestinian activists to find strong allies among Jewish Israelis and their aspirations to reassert Palestinianness and avoid legitimizing the status quo of national oppression was not solved. Similarly, mainstream Jewish protesters (as opposed to the radical left) found it hard to accommodate Palestinian national symbolism, and this unprecedented alliance was short lived.
Nevertheless, the effect of the political mobilization of summer 2011 did leave some traces in the form of an “alternative cultural scene” (273–80). Jaffa witnessed the budding of cafes, clubs, and other cultural projects that bring together Palestinian activists with left-leaning Jewish gentrifiers who are disillusioned with mass-mobilization and looking for new modes of political action. Extrapolating from the particular case of Jaffa, Monterescu attempts to draw broader lessons and concludes that when actors step out of exclusionary nationalist frames of reference, Jaffa becomes a potentially enabling environment—“cosmopolitan and post-Orientalist for many, and radically post-national for some” (299).
The book engages with, and borrows analytical tools from theorists of diverse orientations, including, among many others, David Harvey, Zygmunt Bauman, and Edward Said. It will be of interest to scholars of the modern Middle East, as well as experts of urban anthropology and ethnic relations. Undergraduate students and the general educated audience might find challenging the frequent reliance on the particular vocabulary of urban anthropology and post-modernist scholarship. However, those familiar with the relevant theoretical discussions will find the arguments both compelling and refreshing. Much of the book is written in a clear, straightforward narrative form, and the important insights of the more abstract discussions make the efforts of decoding them worthwhile.
