The number of publications focusing on the enhancement of musical performance has increased significantly in recent years, covering a wide range of subjects, from the understanding of performance in its most fundamental psychological and physical dimensions (Chaffin et al., Reference CHAFFIN, IMREH and CRAWFORD2002; Rink, Reference RINK2002), to documenting results of scientific research leading to practical suggestions for performing musicians (Parncutt & McPherson, Reference PARNCUTT and MCPHERSON2002; Williamon, Reference WILLIAMON2004). Surely, this is related to the highly competitive nature of performing careers and the need to unpack the complex psychological, emotional and physiological issues that form part of performance.
The book Mastering the Art of Performance is written by an experienced performer and teacher, who provides relevant considerations and a concise list of practical exercises. In the author's words, it presents ‘thought-provoking exercises for those who strive to perfect the art of musical performance’ (p. 3). This is not an evidence-based book but an experience-based publication that documents knowledge of philosophical, psychological and practical issues that permeate performance. It is a useful, in-depth guide for musicians, beautifully presented in both hardback and paperback, that deserves space on the book shelves of all those involved in instrumental teaching and learning. The chapters are clearly divided into sections, and the practical exercises are lucidly presented.
The book comprises a prelude, 16 consecutive chapters and a postlude. The chapters, although not published in this way, can be grouped into three parts: (i) preparation for performance, (ii) the time of performance and (iii) after-thoughts (i.e. in terms of evaluation, career considerations, and even spiritual dimensions).
The Prelude starts with general views on performance as an integral part of human activity before focusing more specifically on music-making. Beginning with a broad definition of performance, Gordon suggests that, although music and performance are intertwined, the act of performing is often viewed as distinct and set apart by the nature of some ‘external formality’, as in competition or audition situations. A further distinction is proposed between music performance and the more general ‘performance’ that is part of every human being's life. This implies that the content of the book is, therefore, applicable to a wide range of performance-related activities (e.g. presentations, playing games, social events). Music performance is placed in the context of activities that must be considered within a time frame, involving difficulties imposed by both the musical work and the performer's potential and history in performing. The author's philosophical view, which permeates the whole book, is that the development of performance techniques can impact on our inner beings and that ‘performance properly used can become a way of life that is personally illuminating as well as fulfilling’ (p. 11).
The first eight chapters form the first part of the book. Chapters 1 and 2 set the scene for discussing aspects of performance preparation. These chapters focus on self-perception and assessment as a performer (e.g. traumatic and positive experiences, and negative and positive psychological states of mind) and explore the reasons why human beings perform. The first offers practical exercises to assess levels of optimism and to substitute negative thoughts by positive thinking. The second raises issues of motivation, such as response to challenge, desire for reward, love for the activity in hand and devotion for a greater cause, which are undoubtedly all relevant considerations in identifying motivation to perform.
The following six chapters discuss a set of topics of a more pragmatic nature: the preparation of performances. They start by considering physical support for performance in Chapter 3, focusing on health habits to improve physical well-being. Gordon does not offer diets or physical exercises, nor does he point the reader towards publications that address such issues. Although this would have been relevant, this chapter nonetheless provides suggestions that may help in creating a healthier lifestyle, such as ‘during TV commercials stand and do stretching exercises’ or ‘park your car further away so that you can walk more’. Chapter 4 discusses many central considerations for performers: setting up goals and planning the path, structuring time of practice and preparation towards achieving such goals. At times, some of the points made here are rather far-fetched; for example, in order to explain the concept of long-term goals, the author suggests a technique of thinking what one would ‘hope to be doing on a Monday morning in ten years from now’ (p. 42). Still, this chapter provides a very useful section for the serious musician, offering practical suggestions for planning a timetable of work towards achieving set goals with a couple of very useful examples (e.g. a singer preparing for a new challenge and a pianist preparing for a competition).
Chapters 5 and 6 focus on practice, clearly a crucial part of skill development. The extant research in music performance has focused on the importance of time spent practising. Results of studies have shown, for example, that a minimum of 10 000 hours of goal-directed, deliberate practice is necessary to achieve a high level of skill (Ericsson et al., Reference ERICSSON, KRAMPE and TESCH-RÖMER1993). However, while practice may lead to expertise, it can also be extremely tedious. These chapters offer useful suggestions for ‘keeping preparation fresh and focused’ and for ‘dealing with repetition and drill’. Pertinent points for the young and committed musician are addressed, along with a comprehensive discussion on topics imperative to any performer, such as maintaining concentration and assessing security. Practice strategies are also suggested: for example, practice of scales in legato one day, focusing on precision the next day, on dynamic control on the next, and so on.
Two other key issues are examined in Chapters 7 and 8 before concluding this part of the book: memory and ensuring quality. Playing from memory has become part of the tradition in music performance since Clara Schumann and Franz Liszt started performing in the salons and concert halls of Europe without a score. Although liberation from the score may mean greater freedom of expression, it can also lead to anxiety, and nearly every musician has experienced the fear of memory lapse at some stage in their careers. Thus, memory in music has received considerable attention from research in psychology of music (Chaffin et al., Reference CHAFFIN, IMREH and CRAWFORD2002). Although some reference to such studies would have been instructive, Chapter 7 functions as a guide towards raising awareness of the difficulties and the areas of concern when memorising for a performance, including useful strategies for memorising effectively. Finally, the discussion on quality in Chapter 8 presents a fine distinction between quality control and honest error. This is an excellent chapter, which clearly discusses the relationship between quality and various stages of the preparation for performances (i.e. rate of work, stepping back from time to time in order to evaluate objectively, overview of progress, etc.). The issues raised are crucial for the final phases of preparation for performance, and the author's expertise is clearly and concisely exposed.
The subsequent three chapters (9, 10 and 11) deal with the time of performance itself, and expert musicians will recognise most of the situations detailed here. For the less experienced performer, these chapters offer valuable considerations of psychological and practical concerns, such as dealing with career challenges, coping with stage fright and dealing with mental and physical states during performance. In Chapter 9, the discourse on self-assessment and dealing with performance anxiety develops into very useful techniques to handle low self-esteem and replace unwelcome thoughts with positive thinking. Exercises on the use of mental imagery are also presented. The examples point at real concerns of all those involved in performing and are coupled with suggestions for coping with inhibitions through believing in oneself. This addresses only part of the complex set of issues involved in developing self-confidence, but it nonetheless raises awareness of the real possibilities for overcoming potential difficulties. In discussing how to manage stage fright in Chapter 10, the author focuses on traumas and nervous states, presenting tangible strategies to be considered in practising the actual performance (e.g. dress rehearsals, simulating performance, etc.). This is followed by a discussion on dynamics during performance in Chapter 11, addressing subjects related to nerves and self-consciousness, presenting techniques for pacing oneself, refreshing physical state during performance, being creative under pressure, etc. Gordon draws on concrete examples of performance situations which he has experienced himself.
The last part of the book consists of a set of five chapters addressing evaluation after performance, performance and human interactions, and various topics related to a performance career (physical challenges, the career in retrospect, and performance and spiritual life). The discourse on evaluation of performance in Chapter 12 again reflects the experience of the author through detailed descriptions of what musicians can/will experience after giving a performance. This chapter is particularly well structured, encouraging the reader to reflect upon their performances, plan the preparation of future performances and the tough experiences of been submitted to external evaluations. The following chapter is also thoughtfully presented. For instance, Gordon writes about the need for reflecting upon the meaning of performance in our lives and in relation to society and human interactions (e.g. being sensitive to audiences, teaching). Chapter 14 deals with career challenges, addressing the fast changes in lifestyle of the modern world and suggesting that traditional musicians are often faced with the crude reality of having to deal with other aspects of their profession besides music making. Gordon highlights issues related to the professional expectations, making sensible suggestions for dealing with changes (e.g. broadening one's skills, projecting image, using technology). This chapter also presents a list of activities in which performers may consider becoming involved – teaching, writing, and various types of gigs – with practical points useful for the performer starting a professional career. Chapter 15 briefly highlights the need to consider sickness, disabilities and aging as factors that might affect a performance career. Although practical suggestions are made in a slightly superficial manner (e.g. ‘if you can no longer perform, set aside disappointment and teach or coach’, p. 182), Gordon writes positively that ‘everyone of us who has lived the adventure of performance can, indeed, establish a claim to stardom’ (p. 183). The final chapter examines the career in retrospect and this is divided into three sections: plateaus, burnout and changing self-image. Again, useful exercises are presented, most of which are in the section entitled ‘burnout’ phase (i.e. ‘a conviction that creativity is waning as a result of deeply rooted boredom’, p. 186).
The book closes with a Postlude on performance and your spiritual life. Gordon sees this as ‘going beyond technical, intellectual, or emotional excellence’ and the spiritual life can be responsible for having a ‘sense of unity with the performance itself’ creating an identity closer to the ‘heart of your spiritual being’. Discussions on how to sustain some form of spiritual life in the context of the development as a performer, commitment to the work and inner values are presented. Exercise routines for both ‘beginners and those who are out of shape spiritually’ are outlined. Although the author makes a strong point about the connections between performing lives and spirituality, some readers may find this chapter more related to individual beliefs. Surely each person will find his/her own meaning for their differing levels of commitment to performing and although spiritual beliefs will play a part, discussions of this kind would need longer and deeper approaches in order to make a bigger impact.
In summary, the publication traces the path for performers as they ‘conceptualize, prepare, give and evaluate performance’ (p. 185). The issues and considerations presented are extremely useful for those teaching music performance and preparing students for the career, as well as for the young aspiring performer. Professional performers will identify with most issues raised, complementing their knowledge and experience already gleaned from the profession. This is a clearly written book, and it reflects the author's experience throughout. The extensive lists of practical exercises form a useful guide to all those aiming to improve their performance and this simply cannot be missed by students and music educators.
