In their original and compelling ethnography, Daniel Monterescu, an urban anthropologist and native of Jaffa, and Haim Hazan, a sociologist and a leading scholar of aging and old age, challenge received wisdom about the roles of elderly Palestinians and Israelis as national signifiers (e.g., Rabinowitz & Abu Baker, Swedenburg). In a culture dominated by the voices and presence of youth, those in their twilight years are often stereotyped and confined to the niche of “national keepers of memory” (235). Monterescu and Hazan take issue with these stereotypes. Invoking Emile Habibi's figure of the “pessoptimist,” they argue that elderly Jewish and Palestinian “Jaffaites” represent the generation which most radically shatters the Manichean pictures of clear national identification with or against the state.
As its title indicates, questions about nationalism, state, and national community dominate this book. But it is “the politics of existence,” rather than state politics, that form its analytical crux. The authors argue that their informants are “immersed in the business of living, which involves ongoing and spontaneous production of discourse rather than pilgrimage to public sites of memory” (13). The daily work of survival for the elderly in Jaffa is notable not necessarily because of the declining health that attends old age, but because of the ongoing disintegration of both local communities, Jewish and Arab. Against this sense of loss, the protagonists of Twilight Nationalism invent and reinvent their life stories in a manner that subverts both Zionist and Palestinian national narratives that would relegate the importance of their roles only to the past.
Originally published in Hebrew in 2011, Twilight Nationalism is comprised of semi-structured interviews with twelve city residents of varying socioeconomic, ethnic, gender, and religious backgrounds. Collected over more than a decade with the help of local interlocutors and mediators, the interviews reveal a multiplicity of autobiographical narrative techniques. The result is a collection of voices that sheds light on the inner-workings of identity and self-reasoning. In Chapter 6, we meet Subhiya, an Arab Palestinian woman and internal refugee who in 1948 was forced to flee from her village of Tel al-Rish in the midst of of Haganah shelling. In her rebellion against the Arab patriarchy which she believes has failed her and led to her marginalization, she blames fellow Palestinians for her plight, asserts her identification as an Israeli, and rejects the right of return of refugees in the Occupied Territories and the Diaspora. Many scholars would label Subhiya a traitor to her national community. Instead, Monterescu and Hazan contextualize her positions within her old age and life experiences vis-à-vis the state, thus clarifying the “particular conditions of possibility of the social fields in Jaffa that are producing such counterintuitive and often paradoxical discourses” (138).
One of the strengths of this ethnography is the intimate humanity of the individuals who appear in it. Four of the ten interviews in the book are with women (one of whom is Monterescu's mother), but nearly all of the interviews foreground questions of gender, family dynamics, and other aspects of personal life. This orientation stands in sharp contrast to both Zionist and Palestinian nationalist narratives, which tend to marginalize both women's voices and the so-called private sphere. And unlike other histories of the city, which begin with the British or Israeli periods, the authors include Jaffa's Ottoman past in their account. Together, the historical breadth and personal depth of the life histories narrated in this book could offer rich teaching material for students interested in old age, memory, the intersection of identity, politics, and gender, the false dichotomy of cooperation versus collaboration, and mixed cities in Israel/Palestine. More specifically, readers interested in the day-to-day relations between Palestinian citizens of Israel and Jewish Israelis will find a small treasure here.
Unfortunately, while the book shines in its transmission of individual experiences over Jaffa's last century, it falls short in helping the reader draw meaningful conclusions from those experiences. First, the authors provide insufficient historical context to understand the interviews, particularly for non-specialists. While the Hebrew edition clearly situates the interviews in the post-Second Intifada political climate, the English edition disposes of most of this much-needed context. Second, the authors fail to flesh out the political dynamics of language choices and code-switching in Israel, particularly for Palestinian citizens and Arabic-speaking Jews. They also offer little discussion of why they decided to interview all Arabs in Arabic and all Jews in Hebrew, regardless of their native tongue or personal preference. Finally, there are instances where the book would have benefited from a unifying analytical framework like that of settler colonialism, instead of merely considering its individual symptoms as discrete and unrelated phenomena: Jewish immigration, land confiscation, and the segregation of Palestinians in Israel post-1948 (for example in chapter 2, where Rabbi Bachar explains the reason behind the animosity of Jaffa's Arabs). All of these processes could be illuminated by describing the nature and objectives of Zionist settlement in Jaffa. Unfortunately, the book's singular focus on Jaffa risks portraying the city as somehow unique in its segregationist logic, compared to the rest of Israel.
I have been living in Jaffa intermittently for the last six years. I must admit how few real conversations I have had with my older neighbors, perhaps reflecting the broader generational rift that has widened with the aid of technology and the fast pace of life. Apart from its reflections on the complexity of life in the city, this book has reminded me that older people aren't only harbingers of wisdom about the development of the binational reality in which we live. They are equally part of its future.
