The advent of Iran's women's right movement is usually traced to the Constitutional Revolution, and in the 115 years since, women and women's rights activists have found themselves caught in the midst of varying power struggles over the future of Iran and the region. In the literature on Iran, this is often addressed in domestic terms: for example, there is a fair amount of scholarship on how women and their bodies were at the center of Pahlavi programs of “modernizing” Iran; another body of work focuses on similar processes in the post-Revolutionary project of “Islamization.” Less attention has been paid to how international politics and external dynamics have impacted movements for women's rights in Iran. Catherine Sameh's Axis of Hope is keenly aware of the dual pressures contemporary Iranian women's rights activists face. Sameh provides a sketch of Iranian feminist activism that is optimitistic without downplaying either the domestic or international complexities. In this alone, her work makes an important contribution to the literature on the Iranian women's rights movement and to discussions of Iranian social movements more broadly.
In providing a framework that is attuned to both national and international factors and yet hopeful, Sameh's work is theoretically robust and engages a wide range of scholarly and mainstream discussions on contemporary Iran. Acknowledging feminist critiques of human rights discourses as well as the neoliberal and neocolonial projects they enable, Sameh sets out to argue that “the bottom-up practices of Iranian women's rights activists, as well as the affects and effects of their campaigns, projects, and networks, have political and epistemic significance despite (or perhaps beyond) the thorny entanglement of women's human rights praxis within structures of colonial modernity” (p.12). Sameh notes that while decolonial theory has taken past and present colonial structures to task for their gendered and racialized exercise of power, it has not been sensitive to similar exercises of hierarchical power in postcolonial settings. Sameh locates her work in this gap, downplaying neither the state and societal discrimination against women in Iran nor the neoliberal and neocolonial systems which try to instrumentalize women's movements for their own agendas. Sameh is also careful to point out that she does not intend to “stabilize the category of ‘Iranian women's rights activist’ by presenting the subjects of [her] book as singular or unified, without class, ethnic, political, and other kinds of differences, or as an exhaustive representation of the many Iranian women's rights activists organizing today” (p. 18).
After laying out this careful and nuanced groundwork in the introduction, the book proceeds in four chapters, with the first two covering the One Million Signatures Campaign to End Discriminatory Laws (OMSC) and the following two chapters covering individual women's rights activists Shirin Ebadi and Mahboubeh Abbasgholizadeh. For many of the reasons that Sameh herself notes such as its creation of a transnational network, its “bottom-up, consensus building strategy” (p. 40), and its ability to mobilize “support among different sectors of the Iranian population for women's equality” (p. 43), the OMSC stands out as one of the most noteworthy Iranian women's rights campaigns of the last two decades. Sameh is also correct in crediting the OMSC for its successes in “putting a feminist version of women's undifferentiated legal equality on the national agenda.” (p. 52) As such, Sameh's accounting of the features and accomplishments of the campaign, her analysis of the campaign's website, and her interviews with campaign activists are important in capturing these important years in the women's rights movement. The two chapters on the OMSC are at their strongest when the application of the author's nuanced theoretical framework is most evident such as when it considers the complex factors such as Iranian state repression, decades of pressures from US sanctions, and ideological divisions among Iranian feminists as hindering the full success of the OMSC (p. 49).
Striking a balance among the range of considerations outlined above is not an easy task and perhaps explains why some more straightforward questions are not clarified. For example, the author identifies the OMSC website as an important tool for the campaign to lay out its approach to women's rights and for transnational outreach. Yet the campaign's English and Persian pages were quite different in content and strategy in these regards, and the author does not specify whether the object of her analysis was the Persian or English pages. As the website is now defunct and the reader has no outside reference to check, this clarification would have been important. Addressing the specificities of the English and Persian outreach would have also strengthened the book's argument about the nuances in the campaign's strategies. Another somewhat open question concerns the range of voices chosen for inclusion in telling the story of the OMSC. The author explains that she focused on interlocutors outside of Iran because of the potential dangers of Iran-based research to herself and to her subjects. This is a reasonable and sadly relatable consideration for many Iran scholars. However, one wonders why voices from inside Iran could not have been included using modes of digital communication, though perhaps this can be attributed to an abundance of caution. Less clear is why a broader range of views about the OMSC were not included in the interviews with activists outside Iran. This is especially surprising given that the author notes the diversity of opinions and even ideologies within the campaign. Overall, however, the chapters on the OMSC provide a solid account of the most salient features of the ampaign while providing the reader with a detailed sense of the political and social contexts in which activists carried out their work.
The last two chapters of the book depart from the first two in both focus and methodology. Dedicated to Shirin Ebadi and Mahboubeh Abbasgholizadeh respectively, the third chapter is largely based on a close reading of Ebadi's memoirs while the last chapter is mostly based on interviews with Abbasgholizadeh. While the first two chapters covered much ground in addition to the specifics of the campaign, the OMSC still functioned as a thread of continuity within and between Chapters 1 and 2. As a reader, it is harder to locate a similar thread with the last two chapters beyond the fact that they are focused on women's rights activists. The chapter on Ebadi is the only one in the book that does not incorporate any interviews by the author and so stands out methodologically. In keeping with the framework introduced early in the work, Sameh cautions that “reading Ebadi only within discourses of democracy and democratization emanating from neoliberals and neoconservatives in the West who support dangerous interventions in Iran elides the complex and painstaking ways in which Ebadi has struggled to elaborate discourses of feminism and democracy internal to Iran” (p. 110). This is a fair point, and the chapter provides a detailed account of how Ebadi worked at “reforming Islamic law in favor of gender justice perspective” (p. 111) as she contended with the increasing pressures from the Iranian state that eventually drove her to exile. At the same time, Ebadi has in recent years called for forms of intervention in Iran by voicing support for various sanctions regimes. It would have been fruitful for a theoretically rich work such as Sameh's to consider this shift, which is no longer about placing Ebadi within interventionist discourses so much as it is about Ebadi locating herself within them.
While not an international name like the Nobel laureate Ebadi, Abbasgholizadeh is a recognized figure in the Iranian women's rights movement. The last chapter mostly proceeds as a story of Abbasgholizadeh's development as an activist, the many turns of which make for an interesting biographical read. Since a central focus of the book is on transnational networks of activism, however, it would have been helpful to know more about the content, distribution, and reception of Zanantv, which Abbasgholizadeh founded and which the author mentions throughout the chapter. The chapter does address the contentious funding and partners of Zanantv from Abbasgholizadeh's perspective and thus provides an opportunity to mention the impact of “donor-driven agendas” and the “entanglement of such putatively progressive funders with forces that seek more interventions in the Global South” (p. 138). Since Abbasgholizadeh was the Reagan-Fascell Democracy Fellow at the National Endowment for Democracy in 2011 (a fact not mentioned in the chapter), it would have been productive to further probe the pitfalls of “pro-democracy” funding. Overall, however, the chapter does reflect the funding and collaboration dilemmas Iranian activists face.
Given all the domestic and international pressures that Sameh outlines, researching and writing an account of Iranian women's rights activism is almost as fraught as participating in the activism itself. Sameh has managed to skillfully address these difficulties, while also providing a picture of the Iranian women's rights movements that remains hopeful about the future.
