Everyone who has recently visited a city centre in Europe, North-America or Asia (and probably other parts of the world as well) will have noticed that vaping – smoking e-cigarettes – is an omnipresent phenomenon. E-cigarette shops emerge everywhere and clouds of strawberry (or worse) scented steam are wafting through the air. The fact that the regulation of e-cigarettes is a timely and contested topic is exemplified also by the citizens’ initiative “Let’s demand smarter vaping regulation!” that is currently ongoing in the EU.Footnote 1 The opinions of citizens, and also of regulators and scientists, are very divided concerning the risks and benefits of this disruptive innovation.Footnote 2 Are e-cigarettes the silver bullet for tobacco addiction? Are they the next coup of “big tobacco”? Are they the bait to hook a new generation of young consumers on nicotine, providing a “gateway” to cigarette smoking?
This book will not answer these questions, and that is actually its strength. It is the kaleidoscope of perspectives provided and stances taken by the contributors that makes this book a significant contribution to the ongoing debate surrounding the regulation of e-cigarettes. This edited volume explicitly refuses to discuss all issues surrounding the regulation of e-cigarettes, but aims to provide a multilevel, interdisciplinary analysis that also leaves the authors room for disagreement. This aim is certainly achieved, as the perspectives presented are well-balanced and inclusive. It is a skilfully curated selection of contributors ranging from scholars with an expertise in the history of science over psychologists to legal scholars, as well as experts working as consultants or practising lawyers. Moreover, it provides insights into various international and supranational regulatory frameworks and analyses regulatory choices of various national systems.
In his introductory chapter, the editor Lukasz Gruszczynski not only familiarises his readers with the world of e-cigarettes and their technical development, but also portrays the public and scientific controversy surrounding these products, which leads to highly heterogenous approaches by regulators all over the world. As the other chapters of this book also show, just as e-cigarette liquids are sold in an endless variety of flavours, their regulation is equally diverse: some countries apply their existing framework for either tobacco products, medicinal or pharmaceutical products, medical devices, consumer products or even poisons; while other countries treat them as sui generis products with new legal frameworks. Others do not regulate e-cigarettes at all.
Part I “Science, regulation and e-cigarettes” sets the background for the following parts, analysing the international, supranational or national regulatory approaches. Chapter 2 by Zatoński and Brandt not only introduces the history of e-cigarettes, but also points the reader to the past (failed) attempts of the tobacco industry to present “safer” smoking innovations, for example though the introduction of cigarette filters. It discusses how e-cigarettes might lead to a “relegitimization of Big Tobacco” and how the industry now is presenting e-cigarettes as a solution to the problems it has itself created. Chapter 3, written by the psychologists Smith, Herbeć and Shahab, contains an analysis of the current scientific status quo concerning the risks of the chemical substances that vapers and bystanders are exposed to, the harm reduction claims as well as the question whether e-cigarettes constitute a “gateway” leading to smoking. The authors come to a relatively positive conclusion on the benefit/risk balance of e-cigarettes. In this regard, the choice to leave the contributors to the volume a right to express their own stance has a drawback, as the following chapters do not necessarily use Chapter 3 as the base level of consensus that it could have provided, but present their own view on scientific evidence.
Part II contains the “International and European Law perspectives”, presenting how e-cigarette regulation is influenced by the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) adopted under the auspices of World Health Organization (Chapter 4 by Gruszczynski); human rights such as the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (Chapter 5 by Gispen and Veraldi); the World Trade Organization (Chapter 6 by Foltea and Mercurio); the sui generis approach to e-cigarettes taken under the EU Tobacco Products Directive (Chapter 7 by Pudło and Gruszczynski); as well as the application by the precautionary principle under EU law (Chapter 8 by Ferro and Nicolosi). To a certain degree all of these presented international and supranational frameworks struggle with the question of how far e-cigarettes as products are comparable to normal cigarettes and the scientific uncertainty surrounding the risk/benefit balance of e-cigarettes. Therefore, especially the concrete recommendations for a strategy to regulate e-cigarettes under the FCTC and also the guidance that the human rights chapter provides for national regulatory approaches are extremely useful. In the WTO chapter it was chosen to analyse a ban of e-cigarettes under the GATT and TBT agreement, focusing on non-discrimination, while in my view it would have been interesting to go into even more detail in the analysis of the General Exceptions and specifically Art. XX(b) of GATT 1994. Overall, however, each of these chapters is very informative and topical, providing important puzzle pieces which together show a picture of quite substantive freedom of choice for the national legislators. Some might criticise that the chapters sometimes contradict each other, for example when it comes to the question of likeness of e-cigarettes and traditional cigarettes. However, I would disagree with such criticism, as not editing and deleting these controversies actually makes the reader even more aware of the difficult position regulators are finding themselves in where they have to regulate in highly controversial areas and in the absence of scientific certainty.
Whereas Part II presents the international framework for the regulatory choices open to the national legislators, Part III presents how these are concretely used by a selection of national laws: Chapter 9, a contribution from Wu, Lin, and Lo, presents the quite opposing regulatory approaches taken in Taiwan and China. On the one hand, Taiwan applies a strict regulatory framework resorting to subjecting e-cigarettes using nicotine to the regulation of pharmaceutical products. The manufacture, sale and import of non-nicotine delivering e-cigarettes is prohibited where they physically resemble actual cigarettes. China, on the other hand, does not regulate tobacco products or e-cigarettes, which might be unsurprising given China’s role as the largest manufacturer but also a big consumer market. Kovacevic in Chapter 10 examines and criticises the very strict legislative framework for electronic nicotine delivery systems in the US. And Chapter 11 by Gartner and Bromberg, shows the complexity of the piecemeal approach to e-cigarette regulation in Australia, with its different jurisdictions. In the national chapters, not only are the different legal choices and underlying convictions notable, but also the discussion of jurisprudence and enforcement measures provides for valuable insights.
What becomes clear from the contributions is the important role that the precautionary principle plays in this regulatory debate. Like its diverse definitions on various levels, the analysis of the authors of the principle and its application in the case of e-cigarettes is also diverse. Some authors apply it as a benchmark, but conclude that the national measure is inconsistent with it (Chapter 11). In other chapters, it seems to be equated with a specific regulatory choice, such as subjecting e-cigarettes to the same regulatory conditions as traditional cigarettes (Chapter 2). In other chapters, the authors criticise its vague nature and conclude that in the EU it is (mis-)used as a harmonisation tool fuelled more by politics than law (or science) (Chapter 8). Although I do not agree with each analytical stance taken, this aspect of the book is an important contribution to raising questions concerning the conceptual clarity of the principle.
The editor notes in the introduction that the book does not answer one of its research questions, namely the search for an optimal model of e-cigarette regulation. I hope this means that the contributors’ search for such an optimal model continues, as I am looking forward to further publications on the topic. Two potential future research routes are alluded to in the book: (i) how national regulators are influenced by and learning from other national frameworks; and (ii) the analysis of e-cigarette regulation in developing countries.
I would highly recommend this book not only to academics, practitioners, officials and students interested in this very specific regulatory case of e-cigarettes or in the broader area of health regulation, but to anyone interested in the regulation of disruptive technologies and regulation in the face of scientific uncertainty. It is an excellent illustration of the struggles of the regulators when applying the precautionary principle or a precautionary approach.
