Is suicide a disease or a social problem? This is a much-debated question in both sociology and psychiatry. Dabbagh's Suicide in Palestine: Narratives of Despair is a valuable contribution to this debate. The book is based on the doctoral thesis of Dabbagh, a British–Palestinian psychiatrist. In its nine chapters, it covers a broad range of topics, ranging from Muslim attitudes toward suicide, suicide trends in Palestine, and the social construction of suicide rates in Palestine to gender differences in causes of suicide and suicide rates. Each topic is discussed authoritatively, but it is the rich ethnographic accounts of different topics that set this book apart from the very few other books on suicide in Muslim societies. It is based on extensive fieldwork in Palestine, mainly in Ramallah.
Whereas the author does not directly engage in the question of whether suicide is a disease or a social problem, her rich ethnographic accounts and statistical evidence clearly suggest that suicidal behaviors in Palestinian society are caused by social, cultural, economic, and psychological malaise and are exacerbated by the daily humiliation and oppression of Palestinians under Israeli military occupation. According to the author, the “book is about those people who at some point have not been able to cope with the situation they have found themselves in due to social, economic, or political forces or, more often, a mixture of them all” (p. 2).
The first three chapters examine two main sociocultural categories used in the public discourse on self-killing in Arab society, namely suicide and martyrdom. Suicide is a private act condemned by Islam and Arabic tradition, whereas martyrdom is the exalted act of self-empowerment for the sake of “greater good.” The next two chapters deal with the methodological issues of data collection and social construction of suicide rates in Palestinian society. The discussion about the social organization and construction of suicide rates is most insightful and shows that the relatively low suicide rate in Palestinian society may be due to the concealment of suicide resulting from bureaucratic procedures, inefficiencies, and sociocultural stigma. It is argued that suicide is a form of “moral panic” arising from the accelerated rate of modernization of Palestinian society after the establishment of the Palestinian National Authority and the social dislocation caused by the 1993 intifada. The second part of the book offers analyses of case studies of male and female suicides.
The evidence shows that suicidal behavior in Palestinian society, like suicide in other societies, is caused by the relative degree of social integration, regulation, and isolation, as well as social and cultural control and oppression of individuals in society. The concept of honor and shame are used as instruments of social and cultural oppression, mainly of women by men. However, the suicide bombings by organizations like Hezbollah and Hamas are targeted acts of resistance and weapons of the weak against an unjust and hated occupier of the homeland. In this context, suicide attacks are a means of achieving multiple ends, including self-empowerment in the face of powerlessness, redemption in the face of damnation, and honor in the face of humiliation. Thus, the acts of suicide and suicide attacks are “caused” by different types of social reality.
As shown in the book, suicide rates in Palestinian society are relatively low. The reason offered for this finding is that “suicide is about despair, about giving up. Losing hope, which goes against everything that it means, at least in the popular psyche, to be Palestinian” (p. 81). An alternative explanation for the low rates, however, may be the pervasiveness of external violence resulting from Israeli occupation. They may also be due to suicide's stigma, which results in concealment by family and friends. This factor is also acknowledged by the author.
Chapters 6, 7, and 8 provide case studies of male and female suicides and are rich in primary material dealing with the probable causes or triggers of suicidal behavior among Palestinian men and women. The evidence shows that female suicides are mainly related to oppressive patriarchal attitudes and practices, such as domestic and sexual abuse. One can argue that through the act of suicide, Palestinian women empower themselves to shame their oppressors. The other side of this explanation is that, in a patriarchal society, failure to fulfill the male roles of providers and protectors due to high unemployment and the violence inflicted on the society by the Israeli military occupation brings shame and psychosocial stressors for men. Dabbagh argues that, for men who had “failed as men,” the intifada provided an important outlet for feelings of frustrations and unhappiness. It thus acted as a potential source of regaining lost honor.
The material in the book could have been better organized and the argument better grounded through the use of existing international studies dealing with issues such as the social construction of suicide. However, this finding does not detract from the fact that this book is an important and valuable contribution to the field of suicidology. It is one of the very few studies of suicide in Muslim society. The evidence reported, reviewed, and discussed in the book clearly shows that suicide is by and large not a disease but a malaise. Any prevention program would be effective only when these factors are properly recognized. The book would be of interest to anyone interested in Palestinian society and the comparative study of suicide. In particular, it should be of interest to students and scholars of social sciences, medicine, social work, and public health.
