No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2004
The metal-oxide-semiconductor (MOS) transistor wrought dramatic changes in the daily lives of consumers around the world. In this meticulously researched and richly informative book, Ross Knox Bassett reminds us that the MOS transistor—although initially slower and more difficult to fabricate than the famous bipolar transistor that preceded it—ultimately proved superior and made its way into an astounding array of everyday products.
MOS technology could be “scaled” to make possible circuitry and microprocessors that are small, powerful and economical. Ultimately, the MOS transistor trounced its forbearer as the basis of digital electronics. In doing so, it permitted substitutes that eclipsed the mainframe computer and realigned power in the computer industry.
Bassett tells a fascinating story, and one that succeeds on various levels. In recounting of the myriad challenges that were met in making this transistor practical, To the Digital Age stands as the authoritative treatment of the development of a most important—if understudied—technology. As business history, Bassett examines the practices of the succession of firms that tried, with mixed success, to master and commercialize MOS technology, and traces the ways in which firm structure influenced its development. Other historians may be intrigued by Bassett's account of the technological learning that occurred via the migration of intellectual laborers among firms and the widespread sharing of information between researchers and engineers in the semiconductor industry. His fifth chapter, “It Takes a Community,” centers on the various ways in which technological learning occurred. Conference papers, reverse engineering, employee mobility, licensing technology and other, less formal, methods all underscore the importance of reciprocity among the firms and people engaged in developing elements of the MOS transistor.
If Bassett's account is correct, it leaves one to wonder why firms did not aggressively seek to protect their technology through patent protection and contractual restrictions on employees. He does, however, briefly detail why Intel eschewed patent protection, favoring instead the use of trade secrets.
Despite the scientific progress that underpinned the transistor, the success of MOS technology depended on much more than advances in science. Bassett sees the development of the MOS transistor as akin to craftwork in that those who were empirically based and practically minded proved more effective than researchers and scientists in moving the new semiconductor to fruition. Various hurdles, including problems of fabrication, had to be surmounted to make the MOS transistor viable. Bassett contends that the large, vertically integrated firms, replete with well-funded labs—think IBM, Bell labs and RCA—proved less suitable to the tasks than Intel. The latter proceeded with less pure scientific inclination but possessed a much greater inclination to quickly find ways to make and market its MOS products.
Bassett reminds us that technical and commercial successes are elusive and fleeting. Fairchild Semiconductor, an early mover in MOS technology, employed many of those who later pushed the microprocessor to its position of dominance. But these men did so only after leaving the firm. Certainly Fairchild was a crucible for the development of the MOS transistor and, in effect, a center of learning. Its importance was realized, however, via the start-up firms that it spawned rather than from any commercial success of its own.
Personalities, corporate culture, firm structure and geographic location all matter in Bassett's account. Indeed, the mobility of men, ideas, and money were integral to the rise of Silicon Valley, and to its persistent position in the semiconductor industry. This was a business in which the requirements of finance were less important than those of the intellect. Start-up firms, such as Intel, pushed for incremental improvements and sought rapid practical applications for the technology. Basset is so focused on Intel's desire to make MOS practical and its concomitant unwillingness to establish a research lab that his chapter on the rise of the MOS at Intel is titled “The End of Research.”
The level of technical detail might frustrate some readers. Certainly those not readily familiar with the terminology of the digital electronics will find parts to be tough going; but the book amply rewards close reading. The narrative is, on the whole, quite compelling. The reader obviously knows the story's outcome but is still intrigued by its telling. The volume and quality of primary research are remarkable, and the endnotes and closing Essay on Sources will be very helpful to other historians.
Bassett's most compelling chapter is his last. The conclusion effectively captures the book's key themes and efficiently details how the rise of microprocessors from MOS technology made commodities of items such as calculators and watches before leading to the development of efficient, economical substitutes for the mainframe computer. The 1990s reversal of fortune at IBM rests largely on the transformative nature of MOS technology; contemporary consumer culture owes much to it as well.