In her introduction to The Modernist Party, a recent collection of essays that aims to explore the idea of “the party as topos” (17) within the work of modernist writers, Kate McLoughlin describes the “party” as “an every day but not an everyday occurrence” (18). This succinct summing up of the idea of the party as something that most people have attended, but which still retains an air of excitement – facilitating as it does a coming-together of people that is far from “everyday” – complicates the more traditional diurnal focus of modernist criticism: so that, for example, we turn our gaze away from the circadian rhythms of Mrs. Dalloway to contemplate instead the party that marks the end of Clarissa's day.
In a similar fashion, Eric White's Transatlantic Avant-Gardes: Little Magazines and Localist Modernism moves away from the study of the little magazine as a churned-out, impersonal product to consider instead the contingent contexts of magazine publishing by focussing on the personalities behind the periodicals. Thus as White sets out from the beginning, one of his major aims is to show how, “In the pages of Others, The Little Review, Blast, Contact, Fire!!, Blues, Pagany, Secession and many other journals, modernists plotted, baited, feinted and counter-plotted with and against each other in debates that spanned continents” (1). Likewise, for McLoughlin the party is inherent with the potential for many kinds of behaviour to occur, some of them contradictory – as “the edifying gathering and the bacchanal are not necessarily separate events” (2).
In both texts, then, the aim to locate (or localize) modernist studies, to slow it down to a specific moment or affix it to a specific place in time, allows the reader or critic to breathe; by contemplating a specific party in a text, or a specific poem in a periodical, we are able to counter the notion that modernist literature is inherently sprawling, depersonalized, and decentred. But in so doing each text faces in turn the difficulty of selection: which “party” to focus on, which “plot” over a journal to describe, or which placing of which poem in which periodical to comment on. Though such decision-making is inherent to any critical work, it seems particularly pertinent to those studies which feature contingency itself as a motif.
Perhaps as a result, in The Modernist Party the idea of the “party” seems stretched in places, and arguably works more successfully where an actual party within a text is discussed – as in Angela Smith's discussion of Katherine Mansfield's “Party Stories” or through Bryony Randall's commentary on “Virginia Woolf's Idea of a Party” – than where individual writers try to apply the party as metaphor to an overall reading of a writer's work. For example, in an otherwise fascinating chapter that extends the idea of the “wake” as party throughout Joyce's works – and ingeniously sees the party of “The Dead” as a wake that foreshadows Finnegans Wake itself – Jean-Michel Rabaté's insistence on constructing a “‘party’ vector in Joyce's works” despite the “relative scarcity of party scenes in Ulysses” (65) seems unnecessarily forced. Odd, also, is a claim made in David R. Ellison's chapter “Proustian Peristalsis” that John Steinbeck's description of parties in Cannery Row (1945) “might have a certain strong, albeit covert” – and of course retrospective – “applicability to Proust's imaginary universe” (113). Here the attempt to theorize the party through unrelated and seemingly disparate texts risks distracting the reader from the very valuable work that is being carried out on the significance of party scenes and “human social intercourse” (113) in Proust's work.
In Transatlantic Avant-Gardes, too, the need to redirect the critical gaze by focussing on the contingent – considering, for example, “what happens … when the poem itself, implicitly or explicitly, is called upon to reflect a magazine's editorial policy, or configure an incipient avant-garde” (18) – leads to interpretive declarations which seem hastily made, or convenient: as when, for example, the river motifs in William Carlos Williams's poem “The Wanderer” are seen as forming a “transatlantic conduit” which renders its first publication in the British organ The Egoist “especially appropriate” (64). But perhaps such observations are unfair. In both The Modernist Party and Transatlantic Avant-Gardes the conceptual background is complicated and unforgiving. In the first, the desire to concretize a shifting trope will always result in some inconsistencies (the title itself, in its use of the definite article, points to a similar desire to stabilize a malleable motif); and in the second, the difficulty of pinning down a periodical ontologically, in the sense that a critic can never “prove” without doubt how a poem came to end up in a particular magazine, will always remain. A certain amount of informed guesswork is therefore inevitable in both projects.
Perhaps most usefully, what both texts do offer is a fresh and welcome recalibration of modernist criticism. At several moments in his study, White offers various and convincing responses to “modernism” as a critical mode within American and transatlantic studies – which are no less convincing for their variety. As one example, we might turn to the moment at which White discusses how, “For Williams and his milieu, the modernist problem of place demanded intimate, even messy creative contact with specific localities in order for anything like a ‘national’ literature to emerge” (68); or where he suggests that Wyndham Lewis saw “the voice and national character of the United States a key site of modernist conflict” (78). Useful, too, is the author's keenness to reiterate literary America's rather delayed response to modernism – its coming to the party late – seeing “the lateness of its articulation in relation to other modernisms” (9) as a crucial factor in our understanding of how American modernism plays out in periodical culture and beyond. In each case White's analysis allows for the dizzying contradictions of modernism to be given credence by their very “messiness.”
Welcome, too, in Transatlantic Avant-Gardes is White's determination to take on and confront some of the clichéd binaries of modernist debate, such as cosmopolitan/localist, regional/transatlantic, or global/local (the list goes on). Instead White argues convincingly, through careful readings of a variety of “little magazines,” that one magazine might contain all of these desires, and aim in all of these directions, sometimes all at the same time. Similarly, the different modes through which the idea of the party is made manifest within The Modernist Party sketch out an impression of a modernist motif which is no less startling for its lack of fixity or stability within modernist narratives. Both texts, then, regard modernism not as a critical monolith, but instead as a set of patterns and frameworks that are constantly being disposed of and dismantled in order to be reimagined and redefined.
Both texts, too, are beautifully written – this is particularly surprising in The Modernist Party, where careful editing has allowed individual contributors to retain their critical voices despite a clearly defined overall style and approach (though the challenging critical lexicon means that readers might do well to keep a dictionary close to hand). It is possible, though, that each text suffers a little from covering too much ground. In The Modernist Party, for example, we move from Conrad to Stein to Ford Madox Ford, from Edwardian London to 1920s Paris to the Harlem Renaissance and back again, encountering parties and performances and skits and shows as we go. Similarly, Transatlantic Avant-Gardes is nearly overburdened by its own variety, with new characters appearing on every page. It is inevitable that such abundance will point also to what might be missing: for example there are surprisingly few references in The Modernist Party to that great party-giver, and partaker, F. Scott Fitzgerald, while there are no mentions of Henry Green's 1939 novel Party Going.
But it is the dizzying variety of accumulated detail, the impressive rostrum of participants, in both The Modernist Party and Transatlantic Avant-Gardes that propel us forward. We read each text with the conviction that the writer or editor has a tale to tell, and a reason to tell this tale, which lends each text in turn a zestiness and a reason to read on. And in a critical space that is already crowded with texts tussling for our attention, this is a welcome surprise.
