Theology of Money by Philip Goodchild is a densely argued and multilayered treatise that excavates the theological power incarnated in the global monetary system. Make no mistake, however. This book is not about theology as usually understood. Nor does it apply, in any traditional fashion, theological ethics to a critique of global capitalism. Instead, it concentrates on an analysis of the monetary institutions and the meaning of money in modernity and the consequences for social and political life and the environment. Theologically, Goodchild's thesis is that the God of free sovereign will has been replaced by money as the source of all power, because it is money that is used as “the supreme value that all other values are measured by” (14) and it is money that has become “the means of access to all other values” (12). Money gives human beings the illusion of sovereignty and freedom “to be self-sufficient unconstrained by God or nature” (54), and so has seduced us into denying the relationality and interdependence inherent in life.
In the course of unpacking this embedded theology in the monetary system, Goodchild sees credit as central. His argument is that the institutions of credit developed at the beginning of the modern era have enabled rapid economic growth, but the cost has been the reorganization of social and political life to serve the necessity of forever growing to pay the debt incurred. This necessity in turn forces nations to act to preserve the monetary system at all costs, has led to the degeneration of democracy into a “struggle of interests” (52), drives the colonization of human and natural resources to feed the rapacious drive to keep ahead of ever-growing debt, and is inevitably unsustainable and, indeed, faces “imminent collapse” (20).
There is a lot to learn from in this book. Goodchild draws on a Marxian analysis of capitalism for a great deal of his critique, but it is heartening to see an ecological dimension incorporated into Marxian thinking. In the past Marxian analysis has been far too captive to Marx's narrowly understood labor theory of value and Goodchild does a good job of critiquing Marx even as he utilizes his analysis. Goodchild's critique of modernity is more influenced by theology and by such ecologically informed work as that of Herman E. Daly and John B. Cobb Jr. This is all to the good, and Goodchild does a fine job of linking the theological desire in modernity for individual sovereignty and mastery of the world to the consequent global monetary system. He also rightly (though only in passing) notes the similarity of this image of individuality to the image of God as sovereign will (220).
If only the book were written more clearly! It requires a solid grounding in academic theology, Marxian economics, and political and social theory to follow the argument. It is assumed that the reader already knows a great deal, and Goodchild has a habit of dropping in unscholarly pronouncements that distract from an otherwise careful argument. For example, when he describes the market as a system that has reorganized societies globally, he concludes with “The market is a despotic social institution founded on violence” (128). This may be so, and if you already agree with his line of reasoning, you will agree, but this kind of comment is apt to lose many who otherwise would find his analysis compelling. This is unfortunate, because there is a real need for this kind of careful social/political/economic/theological analysis in public discourse about our common future, and if extreme claims are going to be made, it is essential that they be argued much more carefully, with evidence given that has a greater chance of convincing doubters.
That said, Goodchild's methodology in this work makes an important and all-too-rare contribution. As he puts it, “Theological notions can become truly embodied and meaningful only when nature, society, and God are thought together” (258). Goodchild is quite right to insist that theology needs to include rigorous thinking about the ordering of God's world, and that such theological reflection (whether by theologians or not) gives hope of providing real and sustainable alternatives to the disastrous course the world is on. He is also quite right to insist that the solution to the problems created by the monetary system and capitalism cannot be solved by some kind of “overthrow,” but only by the transformation of these social/economic institutions: “True revolution occurs through institutional innovation” (239). There is a theological insight here: God does not simply destroy evil and start over, but instead “creates good out of evil.” Similarly, credit and debt will not be eliminated from the world, but instead must be changed to create a “new basis of cooperation” (259).
Goodchild's recommendation is to invent institutions that effectively shift the way the economy directs the use of “time, attention, and devotion” (6), which is the heart of the connection between theology and economy: the way life is lived. Most urgent is the need for a way to distribute credit that includes “evaluation” that is sensitive to the common good and not just to profit (249).
Goodchild advocates local initiatives to build alternatives that are locally effective for sustainability and health, work on finding principles “for a healthy economic order” that look to ecological and physiological patterns instead of imposing a “representation” that has little to do with reality, and sketches some proposals for alternative institutions of “evaluative credit” that would shift economic activity in these healthier directions (249). Instead of profit being the sole goal of economic activity, the focus should be shifted to the development of capital—of all the kinds of capital that life depends on, including natural, human, and social: “It is a matter of assessing, recognizing, and acknowledging the value of potential wherever it may be found … [including] the intrinsic value of all things” (259). Finally, Goodchild suggests that theology has been as guilty as capitalism of substituting the human drive for autonomy for right relationship with God and others. Modernism has encouraged individuals to ask “How can nature and society serve me?” (258). He might have added here that they also ask “How can God serve me?” instead of “How can I serve God?”
