In 1749 the French experimenter, royal tutor and instrument-maker Jean-Antoine Nollet spent seven months in Italy on a carefully selected itinerary between Turin and Naples. Already a celebrated electrical experimenter and public lecturer, Nollet ostensibly travelled south to see for himself the miraculous medicated tubes which the Venetian physician Gianfrancesco Pivati had made famous in 1747 as a new form of electrical therapy. In Paris Nollet had failed to replicate their highly publicized effects in curing a variety of ailments by electrifying medicines such as Peruvian balsam. He went to Italy to see if medicine truly became more efficacious when charged with electrical current.
This at least was the public purpose of Nollet's celebrated scientific voyage during the decade in which electricity became the science of the moment. Visiting natural philosophers, physicians and experimenters in every major Italian city, Nollet witnessed their electrical experiments, inspected their machines and critiqued the results. He returned to Paris convinced of what he had already known: Pivati's electrical therapy cured nothing except boredom from the usual therapies.
Paola Bertucci's lively and insightful study of Nollet's trip to Italy seeks to do much more than simply confirm this result. Her goal is to explore the significance of Nollet's voyage as a case study in the scientific traveller in the age of the Grand Tour. Rightfully observing that the scientific traveller did not tour Italy primarily for its art or even its antiquities, she instead seeks to recapture what kind of natural knowledge and scientific experience Italy offered travellers in the eighteenth century. If Nollet did not learn anything new about electricity in his seven months in Italy, what then did he accomplish? Why was it worth reporting at length in multiple sessions of the Paris Academy, and publishing in the Philosophical Transactions (1750) and Paris Academy Mémoires (1753–4)?
Bertucci's answer to this question has multiple dimensions. With a detective's eye, she uncovers the real reason for the French government's financing of his trip: their interest in silk manufacturing in Piedmont and its comparative standing relative to the silk industry in such cities as Bologna, Florence and Naples. Nollet, in other words, was engaged in an early example of industrial espionage; his reputation as an instrument-maker and his experimental acumen provided the perfect combination of technical know-how and scientific savoir faire. In Bertucci's account, Nollet exploited his standing in the republic of letters and the controversies surrounding electrical therapies to pursue projects of national interest.
At the same time, Nollet's interactions with the Italian scientific community were not simply window dressing for his secret mission. While accumulating information about new forms of automated silk weaving, Nollet was also engaged in a kind of academic progress. Starting in Turin, where he had been a royal tutor, a lecturer and the creator of the university physics cabinet in 1739, he capitalized on his connections there to lay the groundwork for the rest of his voyage. Each city yielded unique opportunities through specific patrons, academies, salons and, of course, experimental and philosophical communities. Letters of introduction written in one city paved the way for certain kinds of conversation in another. As Bertucci argues, Nollet lingered in Italy because there was a great deal to see and absorb. He built up a fine-grained portrait of the Italian experimental community which assisted him in determining how to present Italian science to his French audience upon his return.
Bertucci recounts each stage of Nollet's trip as a progression in his understanding of the nature of Italian science. She uses Nollet's unpublished diary as well as his published accounts, official reports, and correspondence to reconstruct the scientific world he encountered. Her explicit purpose is to see Nollet's trip as a two-way encounter between French and Italian science in the age of electricity as mediated by one of the most celebrated experimenters of the age. Her book is about not only what Nollet hoped to find in Italy but also what Italian philosophers and experimenters wanted from him. By presenting us with both sides of the story, meticulously reconstructed through archival documentation in many Italian cities as well as in Paris, she offers a nuanced account of the relationship between science and travel in eighteenth-century Europe.
A final dimension of Bertucci's study concerns the status of wonder in the age of Enlightenment. Taking issue with recent arguments about the decline of wonder in eighteenth-century science, she seeks to reorient the discussion around the kinds of scientific subject which most inspired this sentiment in the age of Enlightenment. Electricity was indeed a science of marvels, natural and artificial, but Italy too was a land of wonders for many eighteenth-century travellers. Bertucci explores the evolution of Nollet's vision of Italy as a region populated by electrical experiments, female prodigies-turned-philosophers, erupting volcanoes and other curious natural phenomena which needed to be observed and explained. No wonder that Nollet considered his stay in Naples, including a hike to the top of Vesuvius's fallen crater, to be the culmination of his voyage. While I am not sure that Nollet was the first to understand the lure of southern Italy as a unique natural landscape, I can certainly agree that he connected the wonder of Italian science to its natural marvels better than almost any early modern witness to this world.
Viaggio nel paese delle meraviglie offers its readers a new way of thinking about the history of electricity as shaped between the academy and the lecture circuit, between the salon and the boudoir, between instruments and imagination. Bertucci presents it both as an arena of conflicted and lively experimentation, and as a cultural conversation in the republic of letters (amply reconstructing the important relations between German and Italian experimenters in developing certain theories of electricity). Both dimensions provided Nollet with a calling card which allowed him to embark on his unique version of the Grand Tour. Readers interested in this excellent and engaging book but unable to peruse the Italian original should know that a revised English version is now in preparation.
