The career of Ira Aldridge, the nineteenth-century black American actor, is enjoying a resurgence of scholarly attention in two new books: Hazel Waters's Racism on the Victorian Stage: Representation of Slavery and the Black Character and Bernth Lindfors's Ira Aldridge: The African Roscius. Now, some fifty years after the publication of Marshall and Stock's biography Ira Aldridge: The Negro Tragedian, these two new books by Waters and Lindfors signal a renewed interest in the significance of Aldridge's career, and both books are destined to become required reading for scholars of African American theatre history, nineteenth-century theatre history, and the broader history of racism in the nineteenth century.
Hazel Waters's Racism on the Victorian Stage examines plays featuring black characters defined by slavery, from Oroonoko through the rise of minstrelsy and dramatizations of Uncle Tom's Cabin. Waters traces the increasing degradation in depictions of black characters, from a noble black avenger who evoked fear and pathos to the degraded “nigger minstrel,” and examines how these shifts in the depiction of black characters were tied to the material social, economic, and political changes in Britain's involvement with slavery and colonialism.
Racism on the Victorian Stage is organized chronologically, with each chapter covering roughly a decade of the nineteenth century, although the first chapter reaches further back to the first dramatization of Oroonoko in the late seventeenth century and to other popular but largely forgotten plays from the eighteenth century. For Waters, these pre-nineteenth-century plays represent the high point in depictions of black characters on the English stage before a precipitous decline. Waters begins with Thomas Southerne's 1695 Oroonoko as the first important play where blackness is defined by the experience of slavery. The titular character, a noble black man unjustly enslaved and primarily motivated by vengeance, became the model for other popular avenging black characters, including Zanga from Edward Young's play The Revenge (1721), Hassan in Matthew “Monk” Lewis's play The Castle Spectre (1797), and Karfa/Three-finger'd Jack in John Fawcett's Obi (1800). Waters also identifies two other popular black character types from this period: the comic servant and the sentimental slave. The depiction of the comic black servant is traced from the character of Mungo in Isaac Bickerstaffe's The Padlock (1768), through Henry Bate's The Blackamoor Wash'd White (1776) and Frederick Reynolds's Laugh When You Can (1798). George Colman's comic opera Inkle and Yarico (1787) was a popular yet singular example of the relatively more nuanced sentimental slave character.
In the subsequent chapters, Waters tracks the steps in the increasingly degraded depiction of black characters that reached its nadir in the grotesque blackface minstrel. Yet even before this stereotype crystallized in the 1830s–1840s, Waters uncovers evidence of a growing cultural discomfort with representations of serious black characters, starting with Edmund Kean's use of “tawny” (44) makeup to perform Othello and later by the shift toward depicting mulatto and white characters as the victims of slavery. Waters traces the beginning of this shift in a second dramatization of the Oroonoko story, Thomas Morton's 1816 play The Slave; or, The Mother and Her Child (also subtitled The Revolt of Surinam) and Douglas Jerrold's Descart, the French Buccaneer (1828). The representation of black dignity became further degraded in C. P. Thompson's Jack Robinson and His Monkey (1829) and My Poll and My Partner Joe (1835).
Waters's third chapter, “Ira Aldridge and the Battlefield of Race” (an earlier version of which also appears in Lindfors's collection as “Ira Aldridge's Fight For Equality”) shifts focus from the way black characters were written to the actors who performed them, with particular attention paid to the black American actor Ira Aldridge. Waters argues it is significant that most of Aldridge's major roles predate the nineteenth century and that Aldridge's career should be read as “an increasingly overt claim for black liberty and equality … [in] sharp relief [to] the more degraded images of the black that were gaining currency” (59). Waters pays particular attention to plays written specifically for Aldridge, including a dialogue version of Obi; or, Three-fingered Jack (the previous version was a pantomime), The Black Doctor, and an adaptation of Titus Andronicus that transformed Aaron into the play's hero. In these plays as well as in Othello, Waters argues that Aldridge “gave the lie to the racist assumptions of English society …, giving vent to the injustices of slavery while he attempted to extend the emotional repertoire of the black character to include tenderness and gentleness as well as passion…” (87).
Ultimately, however, Aldridge was incapable of stemming the downward spiral in popular depictions of black characters in Britain, especially after T. D. Rice introduced his blackface Jim Crow in 1836. In the fourth chapter, “The Comic and the Grotesque: The American Influence,” Waters argues that reception of the Jim Crow character was fundamentally different in England than in America. Waters believes that the sympathetic identification with Jim Crow–type characters that W. T. Lhamon and Eric Lott have argued existed for some white audiences was not possible for English audiences, who for the most part lacked firsthand experience with slaves and slavery. The effect of the British mania for the grotesque Jim Crow stereotype, Waters argues, was the final nail in the coffin for serious black protagonists.
After the virtual disappearance of the serious black protagonist, Waters observes that British audiences still apparently craved plays treating the subject of slavery and celebrated the superior British understanding of liberty. Thus, in the 1840s and 1850s plays featuring white male protagonists in naval dramas or mulatto females in domestic melodramas as the victims of slavery rose to fill this void. As examples of the former, Waters examines B. N. Webster's The Quadroon Slave, Edward Stirling's The Cabin Boy, and Captain Colin Hazlewood's The Staff of Diamonds. Captain Williams's The Woman of Colour, Shirley Brook's The Creole; or, Love's Fetters, Charles O'Bryan's Lugarto the Mulatto, Tom Robertson's The Half Caste, and Dion Boucicault's The Octoroon serve as representative plays featuring a female mulatto protagonist. Dramatizations of Uncle Tom's Cabin, Waters argues, could have reversed the trend of distancing the critique of slavery from black characters, but unfortunately did not. Waters also examines dramatizations of Stowe's next novel, Dred, which emphasized a theme of black resistance much more than Uncle Tom's Cabin; however, she finds that the overall effect was the same.
Bernth Lindfors's Ira Aldridge: The African Roscius is a collection of eighteen articles on the life and career of this famous black nineteenth-century actor. Many of these articles were not readily available previously due to their age and rarity, or publication in a foreign-language journal. Lindfors's introduction provides a brief historiography of Aldridge scholarship and explains that the goals of this collection are to fill in some of the gaps in the previously published biographies as well as to reconsider the impact and influence of Aldridge's career both in Britain and on the Continent. The essays are then divided into two sections: “The Life” and “The Career.”
The first section begins with three nineteenth-century biographies of Aldridge. The collection opens with “Memoir and Theatrical Career of Ira Aldridge, the African Roscius,” published in London circa 1848, which was possibly authored by Aldridge himself. The second and third entries were written by Aldridge's contemporaries and former schoolmates in New York City's African Free School: James McCune Smith's “Ira Aldridge” (1860), and Philip A. Bell's obituary for Aldridge titled “Men We Have Known: Ira Aldridge” (1867). Rounding out this section are four more articles concerning Aldridge's marriages, children, and correspondence with admirers and possible lovers.
The second section, “The Career,” features two never-before-published essays: Keith Byerman's “Creating the Black Hero: Ira Aldridge's The Black Doctor” and Ann Marie Koller's “Ira Aldridge's Performances in Meiningen.” Byerman's article examines the differences between the version of The Black Doctor that Aldridge performed and two other English adaptations of this originally French play to argue that the Aldridge version focuses far more on issues of race and class and creates a more Romantic leading character, and that the play also served as a critique of the metropolitan racism that excluded Aldridge from London theatres for the majority of his career. Koller's article examines Aldridge's performances in Germany, first in Potsdam in 1853 and five years later at Duke Georg II of Saxe-Meiningen's theatre. Aldridge so impressed the Duke that he elevated Aldridge to the level of nobility and presented him with a gold medal, an unprecedented distinction for any actor, either native or foreign-born.
Koller argues that Aldridge's performances of Othello, Shylock, Macbeth, and the comic character Mungo from The Padlock were influential to the Duke's developing theories of theatrical realism. Other articles examining Aldridge's influence on the Continent include Nikola Batušić‘s “The First American on the Zagreb Stage,” Joost Groeneboer's “A Heartwarming, Radiant Othello in the Netherlands, 1855,” and Krzysztof Sawala's “‘Othello's Occupation's Gone!’: The African Roscius in Poland, 1853–67.” The significance of Aldridge's performances of nonblack characters is also explored in Bernth Lindfors's article “‘Mislike me not for my complexion…’: Ira Aldridge in Whiteface” and Herbert Marshall's “Ira Aldridge as Macbeth and King Lear.” Two more articles focus on the relationship between Aldridge's career and the rise of blackface minstrelsy: Joyce Green MacDonald's “Acting Black: Othello, Othello Burlesques, and the Performance of Blackness,” and Nicholas M. Evans's “Ira Aldridge: Shakespeare and Minstrelsy.” This section also includes Ruth M. Cowhig's article “Ira Aldridge in Manchester,” and the previously mentioned article by Hazel Waters.
Waters and Lindfors bring new sources and perspectives to their incisive and timely examinations of Ira Aldridge's career as well as the larger cultural and political issues surrounding the textual and physical representations of blackness in the nineteenth century. Both books would make excellent additions to undergraduate and graduate courses in both theatre studies and black studies.
