The Dissemination of Economic Ideas offers a selection of papers presented at the 2009 joint meeting of the Japanese and European societies for the history of economic thought. The book answers an old call in the historiography of economics: more than forty years ago, Joseph J. Spengler (1970, p. 133) noted that “Historians of ideas have devoted little attention to the social processes underlying the transmission of ideas from culture to culture and from nation to nation. This is as true of economists as it is of other practitioners of other realms of science and the humanities.” While, since then, scholars have actively engaged with the spread and dissemination of economic theories (for example, Coats and Colander Reference Coats and Colander1989), there is no doubt that this topic still deserves to be further explored, and that this collection of papers edited by Heinz D. Kurz, Tamotsu Nishizawa, and Keith Tribe is a valuable contribution in this respect. The volume, composed of an introductory chapter and thirteen essays written by European, American, and Japanese scholars, is divided into four parts, devoted to ‘systems of political economy,’ ‘European and American interactions,’ ‘the diffusion of economic ideas in South-Eastern Europe and beyond,’ and ‘the exchange of economic ideas between Japan and the rest of the world.’ The time span and the geographical diversity covered are extremely wide, ranging from seventeenth-century Spain to twentieth-century Japan, from the Ottoman Empire to Imperial Germany. The variety of economic ideas dealt with in the volume is also striking, including discussions of traditions as different as Cameralism, Marxism, Institutionalism, Austrian economics, Keynesian macroeconomics, and general equilibrium theory.
The book provides several valuable contributions to the literature. First, it sheds new light on classic debates in the history of economics. For example, the essay by Bradley W. Bateman, “German Influences in the Making of American Economics, 1885–1935,” offers a reassessment of the relationship between the German historical school and American Institutionalism, by showing that the picture presented so far is “distorted” (p. 118), and that to understand the making of American economics at the end of the nineteenth century as a Methodenstreit between marginalists and German-trained historical economists is misleading. Indeed, the dispute was political rather than methodological in nature, and the inductive–historical methods of American institutionalists had little to do with the training undertaken by American economists in Germany under members of the historical school.
Second, the book fosters our understanding of national economic traditions, either by treating regions about which very little was previously known, or by offering new perspectives on an already existing literature. An example of the former is the chapter written by Michalis M. Psalidopoulos and Nicholas J. Theocarakis, “The Dissemination of Economic Thought in South-Eastern Europe in the Nineteenth Century.” It would have been ideal if the authors had been given further room to give the reader a more comprehensive view of the diffusion of Western European doctrines in Greece, Rumania, Bulgaria, and Serbia after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, for they raised interesting points on the role of economic discourse in nation building at the European periphery. An example of the latter is the extensive treatment of Japan in the last section of the volume. Although Japanese economic thought, both early modern and contemporary, has been explored by historians (see, for example Najita Reference Najita1987, and Ikeo Reference Ikeo2000), this volume complements the existing literature with detailed case studies of specific institutions or economists. For example, Robert W. Dimand and Masazumi Wakatabe’s notable analysis of the Kyoto University Economic Review explains the review’s role in “bringing Lausanne, Cambridge, Vienna and Marx to Japan” (p. 260) between the 1920s and the 1940s.
Third, the book contributes to the already rich historiography on distinguished economic theorists, such as Alfred Marshall and Lionel Robbins, by focusing explicitly on the reception of their ideas. Katia Caldari and Tamotsu Nishizawa’s treatment of the diffusion of Marshall’s notion of economic and social progress provides an example of the former, and allows a further understanding of the relationship between some of Marshall’s writings that, so far, have been neglected and the thought and action of trade unionists, Christian socialists, and other social reformers. Atsushi Komine and Fabio Masini’s contribution on the dissemination of Lionel Robbins’ ideas in Italy and Japan shows the potential scope for comparative studies in the history of economics. Alternatively, leading theorists are, in turn, analyzed as catalysts of economic ideas. This is the approach chosen by Kurz in his assessment of Michio Morishima and Takashi Negishi, who “saw their own analytical work as firmly embedded in the flow of economic ideas of the past three centuries” (p. 337), and, by bringing into their analysis classical and marginalist theories, belonged “to a small group of truly remarkable economists who combined an interest … in the yet unexploited potential of elaborating on and judiciously combining new and received ideas” (p. 360). Eyüp Özveren’s treatment of the dissemination of Joseph A. Schumpeter, Karl Polanyi, and Friedrich A. von Hayek’s ideas in twentieth-century Turkey is possibly one of the best contributions to the volume, as it summarizes several of the contributions listed so far: it discusses the way in which the ideas of some notable theorists were disseminated in a foreign context; provides a synthetic view of the main trends in twentieth-century Turkish economic thought (about which very little is known); and attempts an interesting comparison between Turkey and Japan.
Certainly, the volume offers a fascinating tale of complexity and pluralism through a rich collection of case studies, raising important questions as to why and how certain economic ideas arise in a given context, and how easily they travel and settle in places different from the ones in which they were generated. However, this sense of complexity, which is consistent with the editors’ claim in the introduction that “the history of the dissemination of economic ideas becomes a history of the flux of economic ideas, rendering an easy generalization difficult, even impossible” (p. 3), might not fully satisfy those readers who are looking for a more general answer to the question as to what makes the dissemination of certain economic ideas successful, or who are eager to use the tools of sociological analysis to label different models and patterns of dissemination. While the careful analysis of the primary sources presented in this volume makes oversimplistic interpretations unsustainable, the volume would have benefitted from a conclusive chapter in which a more explicit and systematic discussion of the relation between patterns of dissemination of economic ideas and key elements, such as religious and political ideologies, which are prominent in some of the essays, was attempted. This would have been particularly useful in avoiding the sense of dispersion that, almost inevitably, follows the reading of such a rich and varied collection of case studies. Also, the introduction fails to place the volume into the context of the existing historiography, and does not identify the contribution of the volume in relation to themes such as national traditions in economic thought, the relationship between economics and the economy, and cultural influences on economic discourse.
However, in spite of these minor criticisms, the book is highly recommended for the richness and novelty of its case studies. Leaving aside the positive contribution made in enhancing our understanding of Japanese economic thought, by giving voice to economic traditions that had been previously neglected, and by showing the complexity of the interaction between the ‘centers’ of economic theorizing and the ‘periphery,’ the book has a great capacity to raise deep questions on the ways in which economic ideas originate, travel, adapt, and eventually become institutionalized.
