Robert M. La Follette Sr. is a fabled character in the state of Wisconsin, and his name adorns streets and schools across the Dairy State. In the U.S. Senate, a bust of La Follette rests in the Rotunda, and La Follette is credited, by historians and senators alike, as being one of the greatest and most effective members who ever served in that body.
The La Follette I want to focus on, however, is the one who charted a noble course for the American left. I contend that he is very much a contemporary leftist, whose political philosophy could fit comfortably alongside that of Noam Chomsky or Naomi Klein. Or Howard Zinn, who died a few weeks before I gave the original version of this essay in spring 2010.
La Follette embodies a kind of progressive who is quite distinct from many of the received notions or preconceived characterizations of progressives in the early part of the twentieth century.
Senator La Follette captivates a crowd. Date unknown. Courtesy of Nancy C. Unger.
Let me describe, in short hand, a typology of these notions, characterizations, and caricatures:
1. Progressives are “good government” types, who believe by simply putting the best people in office or in the bureaucracy, everything will turn out fine.
2. Progressives are reformists, who shy away from facing the fundamental issues.
3. Progressives are elitists, who disdain mass participation in politics. (See Walter Lippmann or even Frances Perkins, at least as depicted by Kirstin Downey in The Woman Behind the New Deal.)Footnote 1
4. Progressives believe the United States should run the world, either via wars, as Theodore Roosevelt did, or via wars and diplomacy, a là Woodrow Wilson.
Fighting Bob La Follette cannot be stuffed into any of those categories. He was a different kind of progressive. He was a left-wing progressive, a radically democratic progressive, an anti-imperialist progressive, an antiracist and antisexist progressive, and a progressive who believed in mass movements and direct empowerment.
First and foremost, La Follette focused on the crucial problem of corporate power. In the very first issue of La Follette's Weekly Magazine, January 9, 1909, he railed against “the special interests”:
In the course of every attempt to establish or develop free government, a struggle between Special Privilege and Equal Rights is inevitable. An acute phase of this struggle has come upon us suddenly. … Our great industrial organizations [are] in control of politics, government, and natural resources. They manage conventions, make platforms, dictate legislation. They rule through the very men elected to represent the people.
The fight against corporate power was the essential struggle of his life. Time after time, on the Senate floor, in campaign speeches, and in the pages of his magazine, he raised that issue.
In an editorial in La Follette's Weekly Magazine entitled “The Great Issue,” on February 17, 1912, he wrote:
The great issue before the American people today is the control of their own government. … It represents a conflict as old as the history of man—the fight to maintain human liberty, the rights of all of the people against the encroachment of a powerful few. A tremendous power has grown up in the country in recent years. Again and again it has proven strong enough to nominate the candidates of both political parties. It rules in the organization of legislative bodies, state and national. Its influence is felt in cabinets and in the policies of administrations. Its influence is seen in the appointment of prosecuting officers and the selection of judges upon the bench. In business it has crippled or destroyed competition. It has stifled individual initiative. It has fixed limitations in the field of production. It makes prices and imposes its burdens upon the consuming public at will. In finance its power is unlimited. In large affairs it gives or withholds credit, and from time to time contracts or inflates the volume of the money required for the transaction of the business of the country, regardless of everything excepting its own profits. It has acquired large control of the public domain, monopolized the natural resources, timber, iron, coal, and oil. And this mighty power has grown up in a country where, under the Constitution and the law, the citizen is sovereign! (Italics in original.)
When he announced his candidacy for president the last time, in July 1924, he said:
To break the combined power of the private monopoly system over the political and economic life of the American people is the one paramount issue of the 1924 campaign. … . Democracy cannot lie side by side in any country with the present system of control of government by private monopoly. We must choose, on the one hand, between representative government, with its guarantee of peace, liberty, and economic freedom and prosperity for all the people, and on the other, war, tyranny, and the impoverishment of the many for the enrichment of the favored few.
La Follette's steady glare on “the power of the monopoly system” led him to be suspicious of U.S. interventions abroad. When the United States was considering war against Mexico during its revolution, La Follette wrote in July 1916: “The gentlemen who want war with Mexico are a very powerful lot. They own most of the United States and a good slice of Mexico. They are our Captains of Industry, our Masters of Finance.”
His understanding of what Dwight Eisenhower would later dub the military-industrial complex undergirded his opposition to World War I. “Back of every big army and navy appropriation bill is the organized power of private interest, pressing for more battleships, more armor plate, more powder, more rifles, more machine guns, a large standing army, a bigger navy,” he wrote in an editorial entitled, “Take the Profit out of War,” February 1915. “Over and over again, we have heard the special interests making their hypocritical appeals on the ground of patriotism, urging that thorough preparation for war is always a sure guarantee of peace. It has but one purpose, and that is to sacrifice human life for private gain.” Thus, he favored nationalizing the armaments industry.
In an editorial bluntly entitled “Defense or Imperialism” in February 1921, he wrote, “Conceding the right of the owner of capital to invest his money where he pleases, the people must force Congress to declare against the policy of using the State Department and the military arm of the Government for collecting private claims for those seeking large profits in foreign lands.”
In his 1924 declaration for the presidency, he took his analysis even further: “The ill-gotten surplus capital acquired by exploiting the resources and the people of our country begets the imperialism which hunts down and exploits the natural resources and the people of foreign countries, erects huge armaments for the protection of its investments, breeds international strife in the markets of the world, and inevitably leads to war.”
As he saw corporate power dominating foreign and military policy, so, too, he saw it corrupting the media. “The people know the press is owned or controlled,” he wrote in November 1920. “They know that it is the servant of the combined groups which control Big Business, and through Big Business is rapidly acquiring the control of little business, line after line.”
In 1924, he wrote an editorial entitled “Shall Monopoly Rule the Air?” He said, “The appetite of the Monopoly System grows by what it feeds on. Having gained dominion over the natural wealth above and below the land, it now aspires to a monopoly of the air. Enriched in its control of the necessaries of life, the System is now reaching out to control the instruments by which the people amuse and educate themselves and by which they communicate with one another.”
In addition to his critique of corporate power, imperialism, and the media, La Follette was a modern democratic leftist in his championing of individual rights: women's liberation, workers' rights, black civil rights, and Native American rights.
The first eleven years of La Follette's Weekly Magazine spotlighted the women's suffrage movement. Belle Case La Follette, the wife of Fighting Bob and the first woman to graduate from the University of Wisconsin law school, was an active suffragist and wrote about the cause from the very beginning. On February 10, 1912, the magazine published a poignant and prescient piece by Carl Sandburg entitled “My Baby Girl,” which talked about the “prejudices and dispreferences” that females face from the day they are born. On April 6, 1912, the magazine ran a report of a delicious send-off by Jane Addams, who mocked the reasons men gave for denying women the right to vote. The article, entitled “If Things Were Reversed,” noted how Addams conjured up “a hypothetical society in which enfranchised women gave their reasons why the ballot should be denied to men.” Addams listed them:
First: Men would find politics corrupting.
Second: They would vote as their wives and mothers did.
Third: Men's suffrage would only double the vote without changing results.
Fourth: Men's suffrage would diminish the respect for men.
Fifth: Most men do not want to vote.
Sixth: The best men would not vote.
The La Follettes also courageously campaigned for the rights of African Americans. Belle Case La Follette carried on this effort when she came to the defense of three African American women in the Bureau of Engraving and Printing who were fired for failing to sit in the segregated section of the government lunchroom, as Nancy C. Unger has noted in “The Two Worlds of Belle Case La Follette.”
Fighting Bob La Follette himself wrote editorials demanding the end to lynching and denouncing white mob violence. In August 1919, he wrote an editorial entitled “Murdering Negroes”:
The mobbing of harmless, helpless Negroes in the capital of this country is the nation's everlasting shame. The responsibility for starting the riots, which ruled Washington for days, rests upon disorderly lawless whites. Peaceable, unoffending colored men and boys were beaten up and murdered by brutes who boast of our white civilization.… There were colored soldiers among them who had served with distinction in France, some of whom had been wounded “fighting to make the world safe for democracy.” While the United States Senate is debating the League of Nations, which would make us the custodians of peace and the instructors in democratic ideals to less enlightened peoples, we were murdering innocent, intelligent, God-fearing, law-abiding colored citizens at the back door of the White House.
La Follette was an egalitarian. In his 1924 presidential announcement, he harkened back to Jefferson:
We start this campaign with the tremendous advantage of an old American tradition, deeply fixed in the hearts of the people, derived from the Declaration of Independence, that the great masses of men and women are entitled to an equal chance and they possess the right to demand equality at the hands of the government under which they live. Every great political advance in America has come from the efforts of the common people of this country.
La Follette was also a civil libertarian, standing up against abuses by law enforcement. For instance, in his famous Senate floor speech in 1917 entitled, “The Right of the Citizen to Oppose War and the Right of Congress to Shape the War Policy,” La Follette wrote:
Today, Secret Service men, United States District Attorneys, United States Marshals, United States Court Commissioners, and other federal officials are rankly abusing their authority on every hand. People are being unlawfully arrested, thrown into jail, denied the right to employ counsel, or to communicate with their friends, or even to inform their families of their whereabouts, subjected to unlawful search, threatened, intimidated, examined, and cross-examined. The most sacred constitutional rights guaranteed to every American citizen are violated in the name of democracy.
And lastly, La Follette, like Howard Zinn, believed in mass struggle. As La Follette wrote in the preface to his autobiography:
We are slow to realize that democracy is a life; and involves continual struggle. It is only as those of every generation who love democracy resist with all their might the encroachments of its enemies that the ideals of representative government can even be nearly approximated. The essence of the Progressive Movement, as I see it, lies in its purpose to uphold the fundamental principles of representative government. It expresses the hopes and desires of millions of common men and women who are willing to fight for their ideals, to take defeat if necessary, and still go on fighting.
Today, as corporate power maintains its stranglehold, as militarism and empire continue to dominate our foreign policy, as the media falls into fewer and fewer private hands, as our civil liberties are trampled once again, we would do well to remember Fighting Bob La Follette for what he was: a visionary American leftist, dedicated to true democracy.
As he put it back in 1912, “The real cure for the ills of democracy is more democracy.”
