Based on the events surrounding Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans and the riots in Paris in 2005, Juliet Hooker problematises the racial boundaries of political solidarity. Her insightful contribution to the literature of multiculturalist theory argues that the main obstacle to racial justice lies in overcoming diverging ethical–historical perspectives of the members of dominant and subordinate racial groups, and that this can only be achieved by making race visible, rather than ignoring it as often suggested in extant literature. She illustrates her argument with examples of multiculturalist practice in Latin America, a region usually ignored in discussions of multiculturalism.
Integrating insights from literature on the political philosophy of race and political theory of solidarity as well as multiculturalism, Hooker begins with a discussion of political solidarity. She claims that the concept is best conceived, firstly, as having both an affective and a normative dimension, entailing ‘a commitment to act on behalf of others’ (p. 30). Secondly, solidarity may encompass various groups of people, and may not be mutually exclusive. Thirdly, and in contrast to much work on political solidarity, it should not be conceived as based on common identities or interests such as a shared nationality. Rather, it should be seen as the product of such structural conditions through which the ‘fates’ of individuals are ‘inextricably linked’ (p. 38). This brings Hooker to her fourth and most important dimension: to date, the boundaries of political solidarity are not equivalent to those of the political community, but are shaped by racial thinking. While race is recognised in much of the literature as problematic for political solidarity, it is seen to be a part of a broader problem of establishing solidarity in heterogeneous societies. Paralleling the insights of social psychological literature on collective identities, Hooker adds an important cognitive dimension. Racial thinking lets solidarity stop at racial boundaries as ‘dominant and subordinated groups … develop different ethical–political perspectives’ (p. 44), which result in differential sympathy towards members of different racial groups. Racialised solidarity and thus racial injustice can only be overcome if the different social ontologies are recognised and challenged: if whiteness is made visible to whites.
To this aim, Hooker claims, it is necessary to reconceptualise the dominant, bifurcated perspectives of multicultural theory. To date, one strand of the literature focuses on questions of race and on minority group rights as temporal remedies for past racial injustices. The second branch is chiefly concerned with cultural differences and advocates permanent minority group rights as a means to preserve culture and therefore individual autonomy. Through this bifurcation, Hooker argues, instances of racial and cultural overlap and their impact on political solidarity have not been sufficiently considered. She illustrates this with examples from Latin America, where both Afro-descendant and indigenous inhabitants claim to be culturally distinct from the dominant mestizo population and are, at the same time, subject to racial discrimination. Policies grounded in the bifurcated literature, relating to either temporal or permanent group rights, are insufficient in such situations.
Hooker goes on to discuss how and why both branches have failed to address issues of racial solidarity. The cultural branch focuses on the idea of preserving culture as an end in itself, rather than as a remedy for past injustices resulting from the non-recognition of cultural differences. The racial branch, on the other hand, is marked by a fundamental ‘misunderstanding about the nature of racism’ (p. 98) as a simple non-recognition of collective identity. Hence, the harm emanating from racism, the social ontology of race, is not recognised. Extant literature arguing for the abolition of the concept of ‘race’ as a solution to racist thinking fails to understand that this will not lead to the repudiation of white supremacy. Hooker convincingly claims that it is necessary, instead, to recognise the role of public memory as shaping racial thinking and that, therefore, remembering past injustices is central to resolving present ones. Multiculturalist literature should thus be reintegrated by focusing on the ‘shared need to reverse disadvantages rooted in both racialized oppression and cultural differences’ (p. 116). This would also mean that whiteness is made visible, since the focus is not on cultural or racial differences per se but on collective injustices.
In an insightful empirical addition to her discussion of political theory, Hooker presents an example of multiculturalist practices in a case of overlapping cultural and racial differences in order to examine how they have an impact on political solidarity. She finds that the institutional design in Nicaragua – equal rights for Afro-descendant and indigenous costeños, weak self-government and group representation mechanisms, and a lack of remedies for racial discrimination – has failed to reveal the underlying dynamics of racial hierarchy and only led to a limited transformation of the ethical–political perspective of the mestizo population. From an analysis of patterns of political cooperation between groups, as well as survey results, she concludes that this multiculturalist model did further solidarity among the subordinated groups, but not between those groups and the mestizo population.
With this empirical examination, in addition to her discussion and integration of diverse strands of literature in political theory, Hooker covers substantial ground in her analysis of race and political solidarity. Yet an additional, explicit consideration of the role and nature of group preferences or interests would have been desirable, as they already feature implicitly in much of her discussion. For example, she argues that in multicultural or multiracial societies political solidarity cannot arise through the ‘expression of agreement on shared political principles’, since individuals ‘cannot be presumed to have common or identical interests’. Instead, common spaces ‘force individuals to see their fates as inextricably linked’ (p. 38), which, to me, implies a common interest. The starting point for any discussion of political community and solidarity would therefore be the question of how or why racial or cultural, as opposed to political, boundaries shape political solidarity rather than the assumption that ‘modern political communities have been organized on the basis of racial hierarchy since their inception’ (p. 98). Nevertheless, Hooker provides an important first step into not only considering the symptoms of racial injustice but also trying to address its causes.
