In the title essay from Choreographing History, Susan Leigh Foster interrogates the belief that the body serves as a site for dance to be enacted upon and through. She, along with several others in this edited volume, sought to reposition and consequently enhance the contribution of dancers' bodies by not limiting the essays within to observational accounts or choreographic reviews. Instead Foster and her colleagues query “the possibility of a body that is written upon but that also writes” as means of urging dance scholars to “move critical studies of the body in new directions.”Footnote 1 I take this position as an entry point and use it to contemplate the process of making and writing about contemporary ballet history using Alonzo King LINES Ballet, a San Francisco–based troupe, as a case study. In this essay, I describe the challenges I and others have faced in our efforts to collect and interpret a visual and verbal archive for this dance troupe, which has been performing for more than a quarter of a century. This process highlights a larger issue for dance historians, namely, how to create a critically sensitive archive for a company when the most reliable (and oftentimes the only available) source is the personal memory of its choreographer. I anchor this analysis to the different models of critical writing about bodies offered by Michel Foucault, Roland Barthes, Jacqueline Shea Murphy, and Hayden White and suggest that companies such as LINES offer challenges to those engaged in the archival process and in the practice of writing history.
Alonzo King LINES Ballet celebrated its twenty-fifth anniversary in November 2007. Though King's work is recognized on both national and international stages, his company remains somewhat marginalized, to the point that many professional dancers are unfamiliar with its work(s). This stems in part from the manner in which King asks hyperflexible dancers to use their skill sets as tools for deeper investigation rather than for performing well-known ballet tricks such as big jumps and multiple turns. Consequently, this group of dancers presents work that intersperses non-Western musical traditions with Western classical dance in what I have elsewhere termed a “global ballet aesthetic.”Footnote 2
King's approach is unique, but it is clearly becoming more and more identifiable. The company's past few seasons sold out, drawing wider crowds who come to see LINES because the repertory is unconventional. Their European shows were danced to sold-out houses, and in December 2009 LINES premiered King's latest commission: Scheherazade at the Monaco Dance Forum Festival's centennial celebration of the Ballets Russes. This endeavor for King and the company exemplifies one of the main reasons that other dancers admire his work: he has not abandoned classicism. Instead, as Barbara Caffi suggests, his is a “classic that transforms.”Footnote 3
In commemoration of the anniversary, LINES staged two world premieres: Irregular Pearl to baroque music and Rasa to a commissioned score by tabla master Zakir Hussain. Before and after the performance, the dance company hosted a dinner and gala reception, respectively. Because this ballet company had been the subject of my dissertation,Footnote 4 I had closely followed preparations for this event. I wanted to understand what the company deemed its most seminal moments and how such moments would be presented. I learned from company manager Selby Schwartz that she had repeatedly run into the same problem I had had when I was compiling my initial research; that is, the fact that the company archive—the material from which the gala program was being assembled—seemed, like the dancers themselves, to be in continual transition. In light of this, Schwartz had taken on the ambitious project of interviewing several current and former LINES dancers with the hope of creating a short film to show during the reception. She felt that this would be a way to preserve company memories. Although she completed her task, a loop of various dances rather than the footage Schwartz had shot was shown at the event, further emphasizing the lived moments of performance as paramount for this company.
As I wandered about the gala, an event dedicated to LINES' history, I realized that nowhere in this building were some of the physical bodies who had significantly contributed to the aesthetic and therefore were a great part of the organization's historical legacy. In a group such as King's, specific idiosyncrasies of dancers are built into the choreography that is presented, to the extent that creations often become more about the qualities a certain dancer conveys than about their “lines.” What happens to the historical record of companies and dance organizations who have a continually shifting administration and roster of dancers—people who, when they leave, take with them valuable information that is only registered through and within their bodies?
Recent efforts have been made by the LINES administration to establish a more concrete archive, and enough programs, clippings, and photographs exist to warrant careful organization of these valuable sources. When I began to research the company, much of the work lived solely on haphazardly marked videocassettes in a small corner closet found in one of the meeting rooms adjacent to the administration office. Thanks to the work of intern Molly Rogers in 2004–5, most of the choreography has now been transferred to labeled DVDs. Rogers told me that the primary sources she used to identify people on the footage were dancers who happened to be walking by when she was viewing the tapes and/or various staff members—much the same methodology I had used when I first viewed the tapes. The possible dangers inherent in this method notwithstanding, the fact remains that before the dance historian can theorize, investigate, refute, challenge, or contest current conceptions of dancing bodies and choreographers, there must be a record from which to work. For that reason, my primary research interest has always been to create a contemporary archive for LINES, one that would foster and allow critical discourse about the company and still maintain the fluidity and individuality that this company privileges. Throughout this process, my methodology has remained largely ethnographic. I have viewed the choreography and culled memories from the dancers, from staff, and (most often) from King himself. Yet in so doing I am forced to contemplate how to question his understanding of events years after the fact when his foremost concern is moving forward rather than looking back.
In the essays “What Is an Author?” and “The Death of the Author,” Foucault and Barthes, respectively, take the author down from the modern pedestal and give readers a choice about how to interpret a story. Although Foucault was not writing specifically about dance, he was always concerned with the dissemination, expansive reach, and structure of power. In “What Is an Author?” he repositions the role of the author as an “author-function” in order to highlight the complicated process of disseminating text into discourse. For Barthes, the author is no longer a necessary concept if the readers (or viewers of dance/performance) understand that they have the power to interpret the writing (or performance). By examining the codes of language, the readers can see that the author is merely there to present work that is to be interpreted by others. This relates to Derrida's intertextuality and the notion that texts do not have to read in only one specific way, a malleability that allocates greater power to the readers. Barthes calls attention to and asks us to question the fact that “the explanation of a work is always sought in the man or woman who produced it, as if it were always in the end, through the more or less transparent allegory of the fiction, the voice of a single person, the author ‘confiding’ in us.”Footnote 5 As he tries to add “multi-dimensional space” to the traditionally linear trajectory of understanding text (from the author to the reader),Footnote 6 Barthes arrives at the conclusion that the only way to impose limitations on the overarching power of the authorial presence is to remove the author-as-individual. If we equate the author with the choreographer (the writer of dances), this line of thinking suggests that the viewers of dance are the ones who are charged with determining the meaning of dance. However, dance is a unique art form in that another layer is added to the dyad of author–reader, or in this case choreographer–viewer. That is of course the dancing bodies themselves—bodies that arguably have the most important function in how the dance is portrayed and ultimately recorded.
In the case of Alonzo King LINES Ballet, the triangular relationship among King, the dancers, and the viewers is further complicated because the ballets he makes are not directly translated from his body to the dancers' bodies. Instead, he treats ballet vocabulary and movements as ideas and allows each dancer to find his or her own path of investigation through their own physical lines. This approach shifts King's role from that of an author to that of a guide, a shift that gives his dancers the chance to affect or rewrite how the choreography is perceived or read. Dancers who have worked for King all claim that they are “free” when they dance his works, and what they almost always mean is that he does not insist that their movements remain poselike or follow well-known balletic patterns. Instead, he allows dancers to move in ways that make them aware of their own influences on the choreography. Because King's dancers put so much of themselves into the choreography, they take the process and outcome of their collaborations with them when they leave the company. They take with them the histories of the dances they have performed because their bodies become the lived archives of those performances.
The idea that the body can be informed by and also create knowledge(s) is paramount in Jacqueline Shea Murphy's Native American modern dance histories, The People Have Never Stopped Dancing. She explains how she came to rely on an understanding of “blood memory” as means of uncovering specific stories held in the “indigenous dancers' bodies.”Footnote 7 Shea Murphy suggests that without these bodies, her work would be bifurcated in an unproductive way, one that would maintain dance and theory as disparate practices, leaving the bodies mute and their histories unmined. By acknowledging her presence as the nonneutral author of this study, Shea Murphy establishes her methodology as one that pays “attention to corporeality and the energies and agencies engaged by bodies moving, within particular frames and contexts, in time and space.”Footnote 8 She recognizes the value of the information both the dances and the dancers hold.
Entering a similar discussion from a different perspective, historian Hayden White's work engages the concept of memory as it relates to historical analysis. White brings us back once again to the author and the obvious difficulty that ensues when one centralizes memory as the guiding/selecting/editing voice of an organization's history. White follows Hegelian theory to remind us that “every narrative, however seemingly ‘full,’ is constructed on the basis of a set of events which might have been included but were left out.”Footnote 9 White's commentary about the way history is written reminds us that repeated choices historians make about what sources they will use, as much as the historical events themselves, affect how we understand history.
The work of these scholars and the questions they raise about authors and sources sharpen my questions about the fact that the most significant remaining historical records of the Alonzo King LINES Ballet are King's personal memories of the aesthetic he has guided particular bodies to create. When those bodies leave LINES, they take some of its embodied legacy with them. This means that King's accounts, as the only accounts, acquire greater importance in the historical record; King has become the author, choreographer, and editor of the history of LINES. Because King always chooses to make the choreography central in his accounts, even in interviews about his background, he has weighed the archive heavily toward his dances. Although he functions as an author, he is an author who feels, to borrow Susan Foster's construction, that dances do “describe themselves.” Creating a contemporary archive for LINES has meant paying special attention to the author-choreographer as he tries to write himself out of the discourse while at the same time remaining omniscient. One of the ways this can be done is to balance King's accounts with the embodied memories of dancers, seeking what they can share about the moments when the works were created in the effort to historicize this contemporary company.
Performance studies scholars have the unique challenge of writing and recording onto paper moments that are meant to be lived. Whether we are writing about a play, a concert, a symphony, or a ballet, we must critically and sensitively interrogate the players who present us with our means of study. The process of historicizing a dance company's repertory, and in this case a choreographer's legacy, is a performance in and of itself. My experience with working to construct a repository out of moving bodies that function as primary sources is not unlike what many other theorists go through as they seek to gather resources and establish archives. The fact that these efforts might differ significantly from those of scholars working in other disciplines does not diminish the need for such investigation. It does, however, provide an alternative.
