Gavrilyuk's book provides a needed correction to a long-lived thesis of Adolf Harnack that has been taken up by contemporary exponents of the theology of the suffering God. This thesis is as follows: the Fathers poisoned the biblical message of an emotional and compassionate God by injecting the Greek philosophical notion of divine impassibility into Christian theology. Coining the phrase ‘The theory of theology's fall into Hellenistic philosophy’ to represent this thesis, Gavrilyuk argues in his book that the story of early Christianity is the struggle to define a qualified divine impassibility, an impassibility that would allow for God the Son incarnate to suffer.
The first two chapters of the book take up the question of theopaschism in Hellenistic philosophy, in the Bible, and in early Christian authors apart from references to Christology. Gavrilyuk emphasises in chapter 1 the insurmountable difficulties with a pseudo-dichotomy between the divine apatheia of Hellenism and the pathos of the God of the Bible. He continues this approach in chapter 2 by situating early Christian advocacy of divine impassibility in the context of the mythological passion of pagan deities. When early Christian theologians spoke of God as impassible they were using it as an ontological and apophatic term to distinguish God from creation rather than as a psychological term to deny God's emotional activity.
The final four chapters take the reader through the four ‘dialectical turns’ (p. 172) the church followed in order to invalidate four attempts to neutralise the paradoxical confession that the impassible God suffered: Docetism, Patripassianism, Arianism and Nestorianism.
Gavrilyuk rightly treats Docetism and Patripassianism as two sides of the same coin. The church rejected Docetism precisely because its exponents embraced absolute impassibility: the idea that God in Christ would suffer and above all would suffer on a cross was absurd to the Docetists. Among other sources, Gavrilyuk draws on the Acta Martyrum to demonstrate that the church acknowledged an impassible God who purposefully chose suffering and who could consequently take on and conquer the sufferings of the martyrs. Patripassianism, on the other hand, was a badly articulated and misunderstood theology that was remarkably similar to the Christology that Cyril of Alexandria would champion: God in Christ was involved ‘in suffering without being conquered by suffering’ (p. 99). Thus Gavrilyuk concludes that at the onset of the great debates of the fourth and fifth centuries, the church confessed God as impassible but at the same time that God in Christ suffered.
Students of fourth-century theology will find much of interest in Gavrilyuk's discussion of Arianism (although they will flinch at the equation of the homoian position with those who advocated homoiousios theology (p. 102). In dialogue with the important scholarship that has come forth in the past fifty years, Gavrilyuk focuses on a thesis that he attributes collectively to Maurice Wiles and Richard Hanson: the anti-Nicene theologians wanted a God who could suffer and the pro-Nicene forces were never able to articulate a theology of a suffering God. Standing with the pro-Nicene theologians, Gavrilyuk contests this thesis from two directions. First, following Gregory of Nyssa, he argues that what drove the Arians was their desire to protect the impassibility of the ‘High God’. Second, he defends the orthodox response to the anti-Nicene theologians. The orthodox understood the importance, however scandalous, of maintaining a direct connection between the impassibility of God the Father and the suffering of God in Christ.
In Gavrilyuk's scheme, the struggle to define divine impassibility and suffering culminates with the debate between Nestorius and Cyril. To his credit, he rightly recognises the limitations of relying on putative school traditions associated with Alexandria and Antioch to explain the origins of the disagreement. It is no surprise that Gavrilyuk isolates the key issue as a debate over impassibility. Nestorius, like the Arians before him, thought that the scandal of the incarnation, baldly understood, threatened too much the impassibility of God and thus required sharply dividing the person of Christ between the divinity and humanity. Cyril, on the other hand, held to a qualified view of divine impassibility that allowed for God to suffer as impassible divinity through the one person Christ, the incarnate Word.
Patrologists and students of historical theology at all levels should make themselves familiar with this volume. Upon reaching the book's conclusion, this reader was convinced that it is indeed time for the ‘theory’ to be ‘buried with honours as one of the most enduring and illuminating mistakes among the interpretations of early Christian doctrine’ (p. 46).
