Pan-Africanism has gained renewed attention among historians of Africa in recent years. By moving beyond the borders of the nation-state as the unit of analysis for postcolonial Africa, these studies have begun to examine the transnational dimensions of this period in Africa's history. Tanzania's specific and undeniable contributions to the history of pan-Africanism call for such an approach, and Seth Markle has taken up the task with A Motorcycle on Hell Run: Tanzania, Black Power, and the Uncertain Future of Pan-Africanism, 1964–1974. This topic demands familiarity with both the global imaginaries and the local particularities that constituted the transnational black freedom struggle. In this regard, Markle does not disappoint. His facility with both the historiographies of Tanzania and the diaspora-based Black Power movement allows him to bring an impressive array of sources and contexts together in one monograph.
Markle offers a wonderfully textured history of the relationship between Tanzanian nation building and pan-Africanism. In large measure, the ‘uncertain future of pan-Africanism’ in this period hinged on the rise of the independent African nation-state and its impact on the transnational pursuit of freedom across Africa and its diaspora. As Markle shows with unflinching candor, ‘the state managed to open up avenues for pan-African alliance building while closing off access to others’ (178). Far more than just a story of how proponents of Black Power imagined Tanzania as an impetus for pan-African mobilization, Markle offers a history of the role that Tanzanians played in defining the parameters of pan-African ideas and praxis. In addition to the pan-African activity of Tanzania's first and most influential leader, Julius Nyerere, others such as Abdulrahman Mohamed Babu, Walter Bgoya, and the students of the University Students African Revolutionary Front (USARF) emerge as important figures in this history.
The book is divided into three sections that foreshadow the trajectory mapped by Markle: ‘Encounters’, ‘Doings’, and ‘Undoing’. Markle opens with Malcolm X's call to other diasporic Africans to ‘psychologically “return to Africa”, to travel to Africa and broaden their thinking, and to find ways to collaborate with like-minded Africans around issues of mutual concern’ (42). Markle's main focus is Malcolm X's visit to Tanzania and his generative political friendship with Babu. This relationship, Markle argues, set the stage for collaboration between the Tanzanian government and the United States-based Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC). The Afro-American Skills Bank, which worked to send skilled African Americans to assist in Tanzanian nation-building efforts, did not meet its potential. But Markle sees it as having played an important role in building on Malcolm X's vision.
As the section called ‘Doings’ shows, Nyerere and Black Power advocates connected around the idea that ‘literacy was a key vehicle to self-determination’ (105). Markle's engagement with how Nyerere's commitment to African-centered knowledge production overlapped with the goals of the United States-based Drum and Spear Press shows the extent to which pan-Africanists in Africa and its diaspora shared an understanding of the politics of book publishing. But at the heart of this section is the rich chapter on Guyanese scholar and activist, Walter Rodney. Markle focuses on the period between 1968 and 1974 when Rodney worked as a historian at the University of Dar es Salaam. Based on primary sources from Tanzania and the diaspora, Markle offers a very thoughtful and textured assessment of Rodney's experience in Tanzania. Rodney taught Tanzanians about the African diaspora while learning from and theorizing about Tanzania's project of African socialism (ujamaa). But, as Markle shows, Rodney became a target of state repression when the government took offense at his biting critique of African socialist projects. The Tanzanian state's response to Rodney and to the radical students of USARF with whom he associated revealed the contradictory role the Tanzanian state played in this period.
Markle ends with the Sixth Pan African Congress (6PAC), chronicling how and why the planning and execution of the congress marked a definitive moment for pan-Africanism: pan-Africanism's ‘undoing’. When the Tanzanian government, in keeping with the ethos of the Organization of African Unity, decided not to allow nongovernmental delegations from the Caribbean to attend the congress, many pan-Africanists concluded that statist aims would indeed hinder an expansive pan-African agenda. Along with an explanation of how the congress revealed tensions between cultural nationalists and Marxists, Markle also offers a lesser known and very informative consideration of how continental Africans thought about the congress. Importantly, Markle does not ignore the voices of those who saw the congress as a positive experience. But, in the final analysis, he argues that the congress marked ‘an end to an evolving black transnational relationship that lasted for a decade’ (176).
Throughout the book Markle acknowledges the role of Black Power advocates in helping to create the challenges that arose within pan-African practice. But, the contradictions of the Tanzanian state take center stage. The book would have been better served by an introduction that explained its complex arguments in a more pointed way. But, as a multi-layered, truly transnational history of the global black liberation struggle, A Motorcycle on Hell Run is a remarkable achievement for which Markle deserves high praise.
