Cultivating the Nile is a stand out text in many respects, as it is a much needed addition to the field of critical environmental studies and political ecologies of the Middle East and North Africa. It is well written and artfully pulls together analyses of diverse elements and scales crucial for the consideration of water issues in contemporary Egypt. In addition it refuses common binaries that remain all too prevalent in the literature, whether addressing productive water–wastewater, land–water, or scarcity–abundance. Jessica Barnes provides a rich analysis to weave these elements together; all of these themes receive deserving treatment in the quick-turning pages of this brief, but content-rich, monograph.
In Barnes's own words, the core argument of the book is to avoid taking the water of the Nile as a given. Instead, the aim is to consider diverse scales, actors, and decisions which are crucial to producing Nile waters—with particular interest devoted to what “makes” quality and quantity issues, and who receives Egypt's waters for irrigation purposes or other uses. The book accomplishes this by moving back and forth between the everyday spaces of irrigated agriculture in the Fayoum province, the decisions made in the halls of the Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, and the broad discourses related to water scarcity. Barnes terms this focus the “making of Egypt's water.” Informed by political ecology, science and technology studies, critical geographic analysis, and ethnographic work in Anthropology and allied fields, the book treats this question with a welcome mix of textured narratives, detailing everyday interactions and spaces, in conversation with the type of treatment of water politics more common across a range of social science disciplines.
As a useful device to organize the book, the chapters follow “the flow” of the river waters, from the building of the dams where water is captured and stored; to Ministry decisions determining how much water will be diverted for agricultural use; to the water user association that manages day-to-day interactions regarding the water's flow; to the movement of water to the margins of productive arable lands associated with land reclamation efforts; and finally, “after it has moved across the surface, from canal to field, tracking it as it moves down through the soil” as drainage water (138). Each of the chapters is well written, and could serve as standalone readings, while also coming together nicely as a whole in a way that will also serve classroom teaching purposes.
On the plus side, Cultivating the Nile is a comprehensive and ambitious volume, and as noted, it goes a long way towards providing an analysis that brings in diverse elements of water decisions, uses, and flows, serving to counter the binaries that have characterized the literature for too long. As well, the book is a strong response to the frequent calls for more work on critical environmental studies and political ecological analysis for the Middle East and North Africa—calls from the small but growing number of voices in this subfield (e.g., M. Arsel, 2012, “Environmental Studies in Turkey: Critical Perspectives in a Time of Neo-liberal Developmentalism,” Arab World Geographer 15(1): 72–81; A. Mikhail, 2011, Nature and Empire in Ottoman Egypt: An Environmental History, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press). Perhaps as a drawback, this ambitious agenda also means that elements and scales of the analysis may not get the in-depth treatment for which one might hope. For instance, the volume does not deal at length with the international transboundary political issues so crucial to production of the Nile water and its quality/uses, nor does the attention Barnes provides to a range of decision spaces include a careful institutional ethnography of the Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation. It is likely that achieving both breadth and depth in a multi-scalar analysis of this type is too much to expect. A longer wish list of questions opened up by the analysis, but only covered summarily in the work, includes issues related to the imprint of colonial legacies on current water uses, distribution, technologies, and flows, and the related issues concerning Cold war geopolitics, and the influence of international financial institutions and foreign intervention, which only enjoy brief mention. That said, particularly given the rich ethnographic approach that also includes attention to diverse scales and concerns in which those interactions are embedded, I can highly recommend the book for scholars, students, and practitioners interested in water issues or the Middle East generally, or issues of water politics and irrigation specifically. Courses on qualitative methods, ethnography, and environmental politics would also find clear value in its pages.
I must admit, I have always been impressed with the work of Jessica Barnes. This book is a clear example of what her scholarship brings to a range of diverse debates and research fields. Knowing the broader scope of her work, I can also confidently say that the book is not duplicative of contributions made elsewhere—it merits a read even if you are familiar with her other published contributions. One is left with a sense of how well Barnes’ study was designed, how well her contribution has been crafted, and a sense of anticipation of what the volume will generate in terms of future work on these themes in the years to come.
