Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-15T13:22:44.970Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Stability of liquid-metal mixed convection in a horizontal pipe under a strong magnetic field and the effects of wall conductivity

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 June 2026

Ruiwei Xing
Affiliation:
School of Mathematics, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300353, PR China
Guangkun Chu
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory for Turbulence and Complex Systems and HEDPS, Center for Applied Physics and Technology, School of Mechanics and Engineering Science, Peking University, Beijing 100871, PR China
Yaohong Wang
Affiliation:
School of Mathematics, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300353, PR China
Baofang Song*
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory for Turbulence and Complex Systems and HEDPS, Center for Applied Physics and Technology, School of Mechanics and Engineering Science, Peking University, Beijing 100871, PR China
*
Corresponding author: Baofang Song, baofang.song@pku.edu.cn

Abstract

Liquid-metal flow in a horizontal pipe with an electrically insulating wall, subject to a transverse magnetic field and bottom heating, can undergo a buoyancy dominated instability in the turbulence-suppressing magnetic-field regime. In this paper, we explore whether this instability persists under a stronger magnetic field and study the effects of small thin-wall electric conductance on the instability as well. The unstable region in the Hartmann number (${\textit{Ha}}$)–Grashof number (${\textit{Gr}}$) plane is determined for Reynolds number ${\textit{Re}} =9046$ and Prandtl number $Pr=0.022$. First, we extended ${\textit{Ha}}=O(10^2)$ of former studies up to ${\textit{Ha}}=2\times 10^4$ and found that, in the ${\textit{Gr}}$ range investigated (up to $1\times 10^9$), there does exist a marginal stability boundary in the large-${\textit{Ha}}$ regime beyond which the linear instability will be fully suppressed so that the flow will be stabilised again by the magnetic field. Overall, the marginal stability boundary has a moderate-${\textit{Ha}}$ branch and a large-${\textit{Ha}}$ branch, between which the flow is linearly unstable. The results suggest a power-law scaling of ${\textit{Gr}}\propto {\textit{Ha}}^{4/3}$ as ${\textit{Ha}}$ increases on the large-${\textit{Ha}}$ branch. Second, as the wall conductivity increases, the unstable region shifts towards smaller ${\textit{Ha}}$ and ${\textit{Gr}}$, and shrinks in extent with respect to ${\textit{Ha}}$, exhibiting a destabilising effect at moderate ${\textit{Ha}}$ and a stabilising effect at large ${\textit{Ha}}$. In contrast to the insulating wall case where relatively short waves are always the leading mode on the marginal stability boundary, long waves can be destabilised and become the leading modes on both the moderate-${\textit{Ha}}$ and large-${\textit{Ha}}$ branches. The long waves are found to be of streamwise-elongated vortical characteristics that are distinct with the short waves in the insulating-wall case. Nonlinear simulations confirm the destabilising effect at moderate ${\textit{Ha}}$ and stabilising effect at large ${\textit{Ha}}$ on the nonlinear saturated flow. At ${\textit{Gr}}=1\times 10^9$, the saturated flow can exhibit spatial and temporal complexities in the conductive-wall cases in the moderate-${\textit{Ha}}$ regime, but is less complex and bears more similarities with the unstable linear modes, or is even fully stabilised in the large-${\textit{Ha}}$ regime. This stabilising effect may be used to suppress large-amplitude detrimental stress and temperature fluctuations at large ${\textit{Ha}}$.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Configuration of the flow system. The cross-sectional view of the pipe is shown, with the horizontal pipe axis pointing out of the paper (denoted as the $z$ axis), the gravity pointing vertically down and the horizontal magnetic field pointing to the left. The in-plane coordinate system is denoted as the $xOy$ system, where the $x$ axis points to the right horizontally, the $y$ axis points vertically up and the origin $O$ is placed at the pipe centre. The lower half of the pipe wall is heated with a uniform heat flux $\boldsymbol q$ (shown by the shades).

Figure 1

Figure 2.Calculation of the exponential growth rate by using the time series of modal kinetic energy ${\textit{KE}}$. The flow parameters are ${\textit{Re}} =9046$, $Pr=0.022$, ${\textit{Ha}}=306$, ${\textit{Gr}}=8.298\times 10^7$ and $c=0$. The streamwise wavenumber is $k=3.474$, which is the most unstable wavenumber at the selected parameters (Zikanov et al.2013; Hu et al.2022).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Convergence of the leading eigenvalue $\lambda$ for ${\textit{Ha}}=10\,000$ with increasing number of radial Chebyshev grid points. The mode selected for this test is $k=4.8$. (a) Linearly stable case at ${\textit{Gr}}=4.31\times 10^8$. (b) Linearly unstable case at ${\textit{Gr}}=4.5\times 10^8$. Black circles show the results using Chebyshev grid and red triangles show the results using the patched grid. The dashed blue line shows the value by using the patched grid with $N=384$.

Figure 3

Table 1.Grid resolution $N$ (with Chebyshev grid points) and time-step size $\Delta t$. Lower ${\textit{Ha}}$ values are not listed in the table, for which $N=192$ and 144 are used for the calculations. A patched grid is used for ${\textit{Ha}}=1.5\times 10^4$ and $2\times 10^4$, which is described in Appendix A and not listed in this table.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Marginal stability boundary for (a) the insulating-wall case, (b) the corresponding critical streamwise wavenumber $k_c$ and (c) the critical phase speed. The results of Hu et al. (2022) are plotted as bold red curves. The dashed line in panel (a) shows a relationship of ${\textit{Gr}}=2100{\textit{Ha}}^{4/3}$. The black arrows help to illustrate the change of $k_c$ along the boundary.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Base flow at a few locations on the marginal stability boundary (specified in panels a–e). Panels (a–e) show the contours of the streamwise velocity $u_z$. The base flow is not purely diffusive and exhibits two counter-rotating rolls in the circular cross-section due to the baroclinic effect (Kumar & Pothérat 2020), shown by the velocity vectors (arrows) in the circular cross-section. Although the structure of the inplane velocity of the base flow looks similar in panels (a–e), the relative amplitude of the inplane velocity compared with the streamwise velocity (quantified by the ratio between the maximum of the two) is 0.191, 0.0693, 0.0035, $1.098\times 10^{-4}$ and $9.604\times 10^{-5}$ for the five cases, respectively. Therefore, the base flow becomes increasingly one-componented as ${\textit{Ha}}$ increases. Panels (f–j) show the corresponding $u_z$ profiles on the vertical (along the $y$-axis) and horizontal (along the $x$-axis) diameters. Panels (k–o) show the flow structure of the corresponding critical modes in the circular cross-section. Streamwise velocity perturbation, normalised by its maximum, and inplane velocity perturbation are shown as the contours and vectors, respectively. In panel (j), the magenta dashed line shows the asymptotic profile on the vertical diameter at large ${\textit{Ha}}$ in the absence of the bottom heating (Shercliff 1956; Vantieghem, Albets-Chico & Knaepen 2009). It can be expected that as ${\textit{Ha}}$ keeps increasing, the buoyancy force becomes increasingly weaker compared with the Lorentz force and, therefore, the base flow will become increasingly similar to the asymptotic state in the absence of the bottom heating, just as indicated by our results. A more direct comparison by dropping the buoyancy force in our calculation is given in Appendix A.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Base flow at ${\textit{Ha}}=300$ and ${\textit{Gr}}=1\times 10^9$ for $c= (a,d) \,0$, (b, e) 0.01 and (c, f) 0.05. Contours of the streamwise velocity $u_z$ and the in-plane velocity vectors are plotted in panels (a–c). The relative amplitude of the cross-flow component compared with the streamwise velocity component is 0.108, 0.126 and 0.142 for the three cases, respectively. The velocity profiles on the vertical diameter (along the $y$ axis, referred to as vertical in the legend) and on the horizontal diameter (along the $x$ axis, referred to as horizontal in the legend) are plotted in panel (d). Panels (e) and (f) are zoom-in views close to the pipe wall. Note that the horizontal profile for $c=0.01$ (bold blue) and $c=0.05$ (thin red) are nearly indistinguishable in panels (d–f).

Figure 7

Figure 7.Base flow at ${\textit{Ha}}=1\times 10^4$ and ${\textit{Gr}}=1\times 10^9$ for $c=(a,d)\,0$, (b, e) 0.01 and (c, f) 0.05. Contours of the streamwise velocity $u_z$ and the in-plane velocity vectors are plotted in panels (a–c). The relative amplitude of the cross-flow component compared with the streamwise velocity component is $1.034\times 10^{-4}$, $1.229\times 10^{-4}$ and $1.15\times 10^{-4}$ for the three cases, respectively. The velocity profiles on the vertical diameter (along the $y$ axis, referred to as vertical in the legend) and on the horizontal diameter (along the $x$ axis, referred to as horizontal in the legend) are plotted in panel (d). Panels (e) and (f) are zoom-in views close to the pipe wall. Note that the horizontal profile (dashed red) and vertical (solid red) for $c=0.05$ are nearly indistinguishable in panel (d).

Figure 8

Figure 8.Effects of the wall conductivity on temperature field of the base flow: (a–c) ${\textit{Ha}}=300$ cases and (d–f) ${\textit{Ha}}=1\times 10^4$ cases. The Grashof number is ${\textit{Gr}}=1\times 10^9$ for all the cases.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Marginal stability boundary in the ${\textit{Ha}}{-}Gr$ plane for (a) wall conductance ratios $c=0$, 0.01 and 0.05, and (b) the corresponding critical wavenumber $k_c$. The data of $c=0$ are the same as shown in figure 4. The curves of $c=0.01$ and 0.05 include two branches each, the short-wave branch (open symbols) and the other branch of moderate and long waves (filled symbols). The connecting lines are plotted only to guide the eyes. Black arrows in panels (a) and (b) are used to mark the variation of ${\textit{Ha}}$ and ${\textit{Gr}}$ along the marginal stability boundary, and they help illustrate the corresponding variation of $k_c$.

Figure 10

Table 2.Leading eigenvalue, $\lambda$, and corresponding phase speeds, $-\lambda _i/k_c$, of (nearly) neutrally stable modes at the four selected parameter groups on the marginal stability boundary. The last column is the ratio between the maximum transverse perturbation $u_{{tra,max}}=\mathrm{max}(\sqrt {u_x^2+u_y^2})$ and the maximum streamwise perturbation $u_{{z,max}}=\mathrm{max}(u_z)$ in the flow field.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Neutrally stable modes at ${\textit{Gr}}=5\times 10^8$ for wall conductance ratios $c=(a{-}c)\,0$, (d–f) 0.01 and (g–i) 0.05. The corresponding ${\textit{Ha}}_c=135$, 130 and 120, respectively. Contours of $u_z$ perturbation in the vertical $zOy$ plane, horizontal $zOx$ plane and the $xOy$ circular cross-section are shown. Arrows are the in-plane velocity vectors. Velocity is normalised by the maximum magnitude of $u_z$ perturbation in the field. Panels (a, c, d, f, g, i) share the same colourbar. Panels (b, e, h) share a colourbar with a much smaller range to visualise the much smaller velocity perturbations in the $xOz$ plane.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Neutrally stable modes at ${\textit{Gr}}=2.03\times 10^8$ for wall conductance ratios $c=(a{-}c)\,0$, (d–f) 0.01 and (g–i) 0.05. The corresponding ${\textit{Ha}}_c=200$, 147 and 126, respectively. For each value of $c$, from top to bottom, $u_z$ perturbation in the $zOy$ plane, $zOx$ plane and the $xOy$ circular cross-section. All velocity components are normalised by the maximum magnitude of $u_z$ perturbation in the field. Arrows are the in-plane velocity vectors. Each row shares the colourmap as indicated on the right end of the row, except for panel (b) which shares the colourmap with panels (a) and (c). Note that the vectors in panels (d) and (g) are stretched in the vertical direction according to the stretching of the vertical length scale. In fact, the streamwise velocity component is much larger than the vertical component.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Neutrally stable modes at ${\textit{Ha}}=300$ for wall conductance ratios $c=(a{-}c)\,0$, (d–f) 0.01 and (g–i) 0.05. The corresponding ${\textit{Gr}}_c=3.15\times 10^7$, $1.6\times 10^7$ and $1.9\times 10^7$, respectively. For each value of $c$, from top to bottom, $u_z$ perturbation in the $zOy$ plane, $zOx$ plane and the $xOy$ circular cross-section. Arrows are the in-plane velocity vectors. All velocity components are normalised by the maximum magnitude of $u_z$ perturbation in the field. Each row shares the colourmap as indicated on the right end of the row.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Neutrally stable modes at ${\textit{Ha}}=3000$ for wall conductance ratios $c=(a{-}c)\,0$, (d–f) 0.01 and (g–i) 0.05. The corresponding ${\textit{Gr}}_c=9.62\times 10^7$, $2\times 10^8$ and $5.2\times 10^8$, respectively. For each value of $c$, from top to bottom, $u_z$ perturbation in the $zOy$ plane, $zOx$ plane and the $xOy$ circular cross-section. Arrows are the in-plane velocity vectors. All velocity components are normalised by the maximum magnitude of $u_z$ perturbation in the field. Each row shares the colourmap as indicated on the right end of the row. Note that the vectors in panels (d) and (g) are stretched in the vertical direction according to the stretching of the vertical length scale. In fact, the streamwise velocity component is much larger than the vertical component.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Velocity field of the nonlinear saturated flow at $(Ha,Gr)=(300, 1\times 10^9)$. Contours of $u_z$ perturbation in the $xOy$ circular cross-section, $zOx$ plane and $zOy$ plane are shown from top to bottom. The perturbation here is defined as the deviation from the streamwise mean, i.e. $u_z-\langle u_z \rangle _z$. Arrows are the in-plane velocity vectors. (a–c) For $c=0$, (d–f) for $c=0.01$ and (g–i) for $c=0.05$. Panels in each column share the same colour scale except for panel (b). The axial location of panels (a, d, g) corresponds to the location of the maximum $u_z$ perturbation.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Temperature field of the nonlinear saturated flow at $(Ha,Gr)=(300, 1\times 10^9)$. Contours of $\theta$ perturbation in the $xOy$ circular cross-section, $zOx$ horizontal plane and $zOy$ vertical plane are shown from top to bottom. The perturbation here is defined as the deviation from the streamwise mean, i.e. $\theta -\langle \theta \rangle _z$. Arrows are the in-plane velocity vectors. (a–c) For $c=0$, (d–f) for $c=0.01$ and (g–i) for $c=0.05$. Panels in each column share the same colour scale except for panel (b). The axial location of panels (a, d, g) corresponds to the location of the maximum $\theta$ perturbation.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Streamwise and azimuthally averaged wall shear stress $\tau _w$ of the nonlinear saturated flows. Panel (a) shows the time series of $\tau _w$ (solid) and the corresponding value of the basic laminar flow (dashed). The nonlinear and laminar values are nearly the same and cannot be distinguished for $c=0$. Panel (b) shows the relative deviation of $\tau$ compared with the insulating case ($c=0$).

Figure 18

Figure 17.Four snapshots for the saturated nonlinear state at ${\textit{Ha}}=300$, ${\textit{Gr}}=1\times 10^9$ and $c=0$. Contours of the streamwise velocity perturbation $u_z-\langle u_z\rangle _z$, where $\langle \boldsymbol{\cdot }\rangle$ denotes the average along the axial direction, are plotted in the $zOy$ cross-section. The time increment between two consecutive snapshots from panels (a) to (d) is 0.4 time units ($d/U_m$). The black horizontal bar on top of the contour line (close to the left-top corner in panel a) follows a structure and serves to visualise a slight variation of the flow structure over time, indicated by the slight changes in the distance of this bar to the top wall.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Velocity field of the nonlinear saturated flow at $(Ha,Gr)=(1000, 1\times 10^9)$. Contours of $u_z$ perturbation in the $xOy$ circular cross-section, $zOx$ plane and $zOy$ plane are shown from top to bottom. The perturbation here is defined as the deviation from the streamwise mean, i.e. $u_z-\langle u_z \rangle _z$. Arrows are the in-plane velocity vectors. Panels in each column share the same colour scale. (a–c) For $c=0$, (d–f) for $c=0.01$ and (g–i) for $c=0.05$. The axial location of panels (a, d, g) corresponds to the location of the maximum $u_z$ perturbation.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Temperature field of the nonlinear saturated flow at $(Ha,Gr)=(1000, 1\times 10^9)$. Contours of temperature perturbation in the $xOy$ circular cross-section, $zOx$ horizontal plane and $zOy$ vertical plane are shown from top to bottom. The perturbation here is defined as the deviation from the streamwise mean, i.e. $\theta -\langle \theta \rangle _z$. Arrows are the in-plane velocity vectors. Panels in each column share the same colour scale. The axial positions of panels (a, d, g) are taken at the respective positions of the maximum $\theta$ perturbation, i.e. the same as those of panels (a, d, g) in figure 18. (a–c) For $c=0$, (d–f) for $c=0.01$ and (g–i) for $c=0.05$.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Streamwise and azimuthally averaged wall shear stress $\tau _w$ of the nonlinear saturated flows at $(Ha, Gr)=(1000,1\times 10^9)$. Panel (a) shows the time series of $\tau _w$ (solid) and the corresponding value of the basic laminar flow (dashed). The nonlinear and laminar values are nearly the same and cannot be distinguished for $c=0.05$. Panel (b) shows the relative deviation of $\tau$ compared with the insulating case ($c=0$).

Figure 22

Figure 21.Nonlinear saturated states at $(Ha,Gr)=(10000, 1\times 10^9)$ in the insulating-wall case. (a–c) Contours of $u_z$ perturbation in the $xOy$ circular cross section, $zOx$ plane and $zOy$ plane, respectively. The perturbation here is defined as the deviation from the streamwise mean, i.e. $u_z-\langle u_z \rangle _z$. For comparison, panels (d–f) show the flow field of the leading linear eigenmode of the streamwise wavenumber $k=4.6$ (according to the dominant wavenumber as shown in panel b and c) at the same flow parameters. Arrows are the in-plane velocity vectors.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Sketch of the patched grid. Layer 1 is used to resolve the core region. Layer 2, with a thickness of $7{\textit{Ha}}^{-1/2}$, is used to resolve the Shercliff layer whose thickness is proportional to ${\textit{Ha}}^{-1/2}$. Layer 3, with a thickness of $40{\textit{Ha}}^{-1}$, is used to resolve the Hartmann layer whose thickness is proportional to ${\textit{Ha}}^{-1}$. The thickness is normalised by the pipe radius $R$.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Validation of the calculation of the streamwise velocity profiles for the non-heated flow at ${\textit{Ha}}=1\times 10^4$. (a, b) Electrically insulating pipe wall. (c, d) Conductive wall with $c=0.01$. (a, c) Profile on the upper half of the vertical diameter. The asymptotic approximation (A4) is shown as the red dashed curve. The inset in panel (c) shows a zoom-in view of the near-wall region. (b, d) Profile on the right half of the horizontal diameter. (A5) is plotted as the red dashed curve. Note that the horizontal axis in panels (b, d) shows the distance to the pipe wall, $0.5-x$, in log-scale. The patched grid described in Appendix A is used for the calculation.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Comparison between the magnitude of the different terms in the energy (B1). The amplitude of the Fourier coefficient of each term for the dominant azimuthal mode (with azimuthal wavenumber of $n=1$) is used as a measure. The thin red curve represents the Joule dissipation term (the third on the right-hand side), the bold blue one represents the convection term $-\boldsymbol {u}\boldsymbol{\cdot }\boldsymbol{\nabla }\theta -u_z( {\mathrm{d}T_m}/{\mathrm{d}z})$ and the dashed black one is the diffusion term (the first term on the right-hand side).

Figure 26

Figure 25.Comparison between the solution of the base temperature and the temperature perturbation for simulations with and without the Joule dissipation. (a) Base temperature profile on the horizontal and vertical diameters. (b) Temperature perturbation profile on the horizontal and vertical diameters. The data are taken at the same time instant.

Supplementary material: File

Xing et al. supplementary movie 1

Streamwise velocity perturbation in the vertical plane through the pipe axis for the nonlinear saturated flow at $Ha=300$ and $Gr=1 \times 109$. The insulating wall case, conductive wall cases with $c=0.01$ and $0.05$ are shown from top to bottom panels.
Download Xing et al. supplementary movie 1(File)
File 11.2 MB
Supplementary material: File

Xing et al. supplementary movie 2

Temperature perturbation in the vertical plane through the pipe axis for the nonlinear saturated flow at $Ha=300$ and $Gr=1 \times 109$. The insulating wall case, conductive wall cases with $c=0.01$ and $0.05$ are shown from top to bottom panels.
Download Xing et al. supplementary movie 2(File)
File 8.1 MB
Supplementary material: File

Xing et al. supplementary movie 3

Streamwise velocity perturbation in the vertical plane through the pipe axis for the nonlinear saturated flow at $Ha=1000$ and $Gr=1 \times 109$. The insulating wall case, conductive wall cases with $c=0.01$ and $0.05$ are shown from top to bottom panels.
Download Xing et al. supplementary movie 3(File)
File 12.7 MB
Supplementary material: File

Xing et al. supplementary movie 4

Temperature perturbation in the vertical plane through the pipe axis for the nonlinear saturated flow at $Ha=1000$ and $Gr=1 \times 109$. The insulating wall case, conductive wall cases with $c=0.01$ and $0.05$ are shown from top to bottom panels.
Download Xing et al. supplementary movie 4(File)
File 6.8 MB