The twenty-first century has seen an upsurge in interest in Antioch. Alongside the numerous written sources, scholars have, in particular, investigated its archaeology. As these two strands of research have thus far remained largely separate, the objective of the volume under review, which results from a conference held in 2014, is to ‘assemble … experts on individual authors who resided and wrote in Antioch … and experts on its topography and archaeology, with the aim of directing focus from different angles onto the city itself’ (4).
After an introduction by Susanna Elm, the volume consists of four parts. Part I focuses on the city's topography. Gunnar Brands offers a survey of the city's history and appearance, zooming in on the period between Diocletian and Theodosius II with special attention to the Forum of Valens and its role in the Christianisation of the city. Catherine Saliou argues that Libanius’ Antiochicus remains deliberately vague on religion so as to allow different readers different interpretations. Johannes Hahn, discussing the Antiochene Olympics in Late Antiquity, likewise focuses on religion: he argues that the extraordinarily long survival of the Antiochene Olympics was due to their secularisation.
Part II shifts the focus to Antioch as an imperial city. Jorit Wintjes offers an overview of the presence of the Roman army as well as of emperors in and around Antioch, and concludes that between 333 and 378, Antioch turned from an administrative and logistic centre into a leading military and imperial city, which must have had important demographic as well as economic implications that were valued differently by different parts of its population. Claudia Tiersch focuses on Julian's difficult relation with Antioch, which she sees as a result of their different understandings of the concept of Hellenism. In one of the volume's most inspiring chapters, Gavin Kelly zooms in on Ammianus’ presentation of Valens’ relationship with Antioch. In doing so, he reassesses prevailing ideas about the focus of Ammianus’ narrative — showing that Ammianus focuses at least as much on Valentinian as he does on Valens — and about chronology — expanding, for example, on Schmidt-Hofner's suggestion that Valens entered Antioch on 10 November 371, and firmly dating the treason trials to 372. In addition, he draws attention to Ammianus’ silences, especially concerning Valens’ activities in Antioch, as well as to narrative parallels between the various books of his history, suggesting that Ammianus constructed his account of Valens’ reign so as to foreshadow his later fate. Susanna Elm shifts the focus to Eutropius and Festus, arguing that their portrayals of Julian and Jovian serve the purpose of advising Valens to choose the middle way between too much and not enough ambition in Persia.
In Part III, which focuses on ‘visions of Antioch painted with words’, Jan Stenger confronts the orations of Libanius and John Chrysostom concerning the destruction of the Temple of Apollo at Daphne in 362. Evading the problem of explaining why the temple burnt down after Julian had removed the remains of Babylas, Libanius emphasised the unity of the Antiocheans in being horrified at the destruction caused by what must be an external enemy. Chrysostom, by contrast, mercilessly pinpointed the weaknesses in Libanius’ discourse, conducting a trial that opposed Chrysostom and his Christian followers to Julian and his fellow pagans. In so doing, both Libanius and Chrysostom tried to shape the way in which the Antiochenes viewed their built environment. An innovative perspective is offered by Edward Watts in the next chapter: he shows how not only ambitious young people, but also elderly people wishing to stay relevant in fourth-century Antioch, had to stake their claims, and demonstrates how Libanius successfully did so through his last collection of letters. After a chapter in which Christine Shepardson draws attention to the evolving body of statues (and, indeed, living ascetics) in late antique Antioch, Blake Leyerle concludes Part III with a chapter that contrasts Libanius’ image of an elite city of plenty with John Chrysostom's vignettes of much more marginal figures.
Part IV, finally, examines the creation of various Antiochene communities. Jaclyn Maxell compares how Libanius and John Chrysostom (re)present the people of Antioch, arguing that both men cared, but also complained, about Antioch's population at large. In doing so, they both gave the people a voice. Rudolf Brändle highlights the multireligious character of Antioch and sketches how John Chrysostom's eight orations against the Jews, for which he proposes a precise order and dating in 386 and 387, should be read against the background of the great popularity of Judaism in fourth-century Antioch. In another very stimulating chapter, Adam Schor explores the socio-cultural agenda of the Apostolic Constitutions, composed in Antioch in the 370s–380s: making use of Collins’ and Evans’ modern sociological concept of expertise, he shows the text to be an attempt to build a ‘“divinely ordained” expert community’ (337) of clerics. The next two chapters zoom in on strategies employed by John Chrysostom. Yannis Papadogiannakis shows how John not only described to his congregation which emotions were or were not fit in which social situations, but also evoked emotions in order to convince his audience and create a community. Wendy Mayer, in turn, discusses John's anti-intellectualism, arguing that he deliberately misrepresents the Second Sophistic as practised, for example, in Antioch's rhetorical schools, so as to picture Christianity as the only true heir of a First Sophistic allegedly sharing Christianity's focus on the care of the soul. In the closing chapter of the volume, Silke-Petra Bergjan revisits the question of the Antiochene schism and its representation in the fifth-century church historians, with particular attention to the Tomus ad Antiochenos.
Overall, the volume offers a rich and multifaceted image of Antioch in the fourth and early fifth centuries a.d., ranging from topography to literature, as promised in the introduction. It should be said, however, that there is a clear (and, given the available source material, to some extent understandable) preponderance of the latter: only one of the volume's four parts focuses on topography. In addition, there is rather little interaction between the volume's various chapters. Ch. 2, for example, whilst offering the map which one would have loved to see in ch. 1, fails to engage with its topographical discussion. Chs 3 and 6 start exactly where chs 2 and 4 left off, but do not refer to them. Or again, the absence of a general conclusion means that no wider conclusions are drawn on the basis of the various comparisons between Libanius and John Chrysostom in chs 7, 10 and 11. Such a lack of interaction between chapters can be seen in many edited volumes, but it is particularly regrettable in a volume explicitly aiming at integrating different approaches. Nevertheless, the volume is definitely worth reading: its often stimulating chapters are invariably written by experts, and by assembling them into one volume, the editors encourage scholars working in different fields to take other approaches into account.
