Finally, scholars have a comprehensive biography of Mary Putnam Jacobi worthy of the most universally respected female physician of the Gilded Age. Carla Bittel deserves praise for this achievement. Identifying sources and contexts has been arduous, requiring not only time, but the energetic inventiveness of a detective. Much of Putnam Jacobi's and her husband's correspondence was destroyed by a fire that broke out in 1918 at the family's summer cabin in Lake George, New York. Undaunted, Bittel studied every bit of material that remains: “small amounts . . . scattered in archives across the United States and in Europe” (237n31). Listening attentively to the “voices” of Putman Jacobi's contemporaries, Bittel links her subject's “published work” to her “public worlds,” intellectual development, and personal relationships (9). The result is a compelling analysis of Putnam Jacobi's life and achievements that fills many gaps in the historical record. Even more important, Bittel pays such careful attention to context that the book appeals, not just to those interested in Mary Putnam Jacobi's career, but to scholars with a wide range of interests.
Women's, family, and gender historians will find Bittel's account of Putnam Jacobi's childhood and youth an interesting case study of female identity construction. Putnam Jacobi was born in 1842. Her extraordinary intelligence certainly helped facilitate her remarkable career. An enabling family culture—literary, Republican, anti-slavery—also proved significant. The eldest of eleven children, Mary Putnam clashed at an early age with the prevailing social prescriptions for girlhood, first articulating her rebellion when she was only nine. Unalarmed, the adults around her gently tolerated her stubborn independence, nurtured her willingness to voice her opinions, and valued her intellectual gifts. Her father, publisher George Palmer Putnam, introduced her to the world of ideas and to several women writers whose work he published. The family's evangelical Calvinism generated in her a social and spiritual consciousness, one that valued simplicity and righteousness over materialism.
Bittel's account helps delineate the frameworks against which determined young women might push in order to create meaningful lives for themselves in the second half of the nineteenth century. In her girlhood Mary Putnam took religious faith seriously, but her desire to do good often clashed with her fierce resistance to Victorian gender norms. Such contradictions goaded her intellectual interrogation. By her late teens she came to doubt the presence of God. She spent three years conducting mind “experiments upon the power” of the Christian deity and lost her faith by the age of twenty (21). Her father tried to talk her out of becoming a physician, but she eventually gained his support and acceptance. Her conviction that prescribed gender differences held back social progress structured her scientific research for the rest of her life (28).
The book will most certainly appeal to historians of medicine. Educated in the 1860s, Jacobi became a vibrant doctor/scientist who looked forward to modern medical practice rather than backward to the traditions of care that preceded cellular biology, neurology, laboratory medicine, and bacteriology. Had she been a man, it is likely that scholars would have already meticulously detailed her extraordinary career in Paris and New York. By 1866, she had earned two degrees: one in pharmacy from the New York College of Pharmacy and the other in medicine from the Woman's Medical College of Pennsylvania. Not satisfied with the medical education an aspiring medical researcher could receive in the United States, she left for Paris to convince the faculty at the world-renowned École de Médicine that they should admit their first woman student. Bittel offers new details of Putnam Jacobi's strategic, and ultimately successful, campaign, illuminating the French context in fascinating ways. Her triumph was not merely personal; it marked an historic moment on behalf of the rights of women in France. She worked with the students of Claude Bernard, gaining the tools that strengthened her lifetime commitment to the experimentalism and laboratory investigation that represented future directions of medical theory and practice.
Bittel's account of Putnam Jacobi's five-year Paris sojourn should also interest political historians. Until now, the lasting influence on her subsequent participation in social reform of her intellectual contacts among the French Left has not been properly understood. She lived for several years with the family of Elisee Reclus, a well-known anarchist geographer, an experience that profoundly shaped her political and medical philosophy. Through the Reclus family's eyes, she witnessed the end of the Second Empire, the defeat of the Paris Commune, and the founding of the Third Republic. She began to develop a theory of society based on socialist and positivist thought. Her gradual ideological commitment to the power of scientific knowledge achieved by objective empirical means never wavered; indeed, it guided her research and practice when she returned to New York.
For Putnam Jacobi, positivism reinforced scientifically her already powerful conviction that women's equality with men was not just desirable but necessary to the general health of the body politic. Like the human organism, society required all sectors working synchronically on behalf of the collective good. Although many of Putnam Jacobi's political interventions have already been noted by scholars of women, gender, and medicine, Bittel's work not only details the range of her activism more thoroughly, but explains her political and intellectual achievements more holistically. The same ideas drove her as a social reformer, a women's rights activist, a medical scientist, and a woman.
These convictions were shared by her husband, Dr. Abraham Jacobi, a Marxist and German-Jewish 48er, who fled his homeland after a stint in prison for subversion amid the repression following the revolutions of 1848. Abraham Jacobi was known as the “father of modern pediatrics”: He believed that healthy children were the lifeblood of a democratic society and argued that physicians must be responsible for young people's physical, intellectual, and moral care. Both husband and wife were progressive medical reformers, and in some ways their marriage was fascinatingly modern. Little has been known about the relationship; only a fragment of their correspondence survives. Despite this handicap, Bittel has ingeniously put together an extremely plausible narrative of their union, using memoirs and the correspondence of friends and family. Though their marriage was haunted by the death of a son from diphtheria, a tragic event that served to exacerbate other, less heartbreaking tensions, the union enabled real possibilities for intellectual and professional exchange and companionship.
In recent years, biography has enhanced social and cultural history by illuminating within an individual life the various historical contexts that scholars have worked so hard to chronicle with greater accuracy and complexity. Bittel's excellent volume is a fine addition to this effort.
