I am in full agreement with Alan Audi's basic premise, so
forcefully made in this article, that the legalistic discourse and the
associated “argument-bites,” as he calls them, are an
inadequate and highly problematic lens through which to explore the issues
of restitution of what we call “cultural property,”
another, equally problematic term.1
I would equally concur that any discussion
on the subject that ignores the colonial past (and I would add, the
neocolonial present), and the power inequities associated with it, is not
only hypocritical but it also conceals an undeclared interest, effectively
taking sides in the ongoing cultural and overtly political global
battlegrounds. The issue of the Elgin or Parthenon Marbles is correctly
identified by the author as the omnipresent shadow in all debates of
restitution, the shadow that haunts museum professionals and politicians
alike. It is this shadow that led the current director of the British
Museum to start the initiative on the “Universal Museum,” an
initiative that falls apart only by looking at the list of signatories: 18
major museums, all located in Europe and North America.
2 In his article
in the
Guardian in defence of this thesis (that museums such as
the British Museum or the New York's Metropolitan, tell a universal
story, hence their need to retain objects from all over the world), he
even invoked Edward Said; but the title of this article gave the game
away: “The Whole World in our Hands.”
3 Who has the right to represent the
universal? Why is it that the exhibition of the global story of humanity,
even if such an exercise were possible in supposedly neutral and
depoliticized terms, must be staged in London, New York, or Paris, and not
in Cairo, Sao Paolo, or Delhi? As Homi Bhabha reminded us,
4 the desire to “grasp the
whole,” to represent and stage the universal, has always been at the
core of the colonial imagination; we need only think of the
nineteenth-century Grand Fairs and Universal Expositions, and the role of
antiquities in them.
I argued in 19995
that
examining the Elgin Marbles story through a cultural biography approach
can prove much more interesting than a narrow legalistic perspective on
restitution, and it can perhaps indirectly point to the pitfalls of the
whole restitution discourse. Taking further this angle in a broader study
on antiquity and national imagination in Greece,
6 I put forward a series of suggestions. First,
the specific materiality of these artifacts and their sensory and sensuous
appreciation by humans are central in understanding their immense power.
Second, in Greek national imagination since the nineteenth century,
“the marbles” are often personified, acquire the properties of
human beings, and express feelings and emotions. Interestingly, this
discourse is reflected in both the current official rhetoric, which claim
that it is the marbles themselves that demand their restitution, or rather
their return to the homeland, as well as in the unofficial, popular
discourses, found in newspapers articles, children's stories, and
poetry, which talk of the sorrow and the sadness of the imprisoned
marbles. Finally, based on the analysis of the aforementioned, I claim
that much like the
Taonga Maori objects,
7 these artifacts are not simply
important feats of the ancestors that need to be brought back; they are
rather the ancestors themselves; they are the living and breathing
entities, the members of the national body that long for their
reunification with the broader national family; a family that includes the
living people as well as and the animate, anthropomorphic, or
anthropomorphized antiquities. I call this world view, the
nostalgia
for the whole or the
desire for completeness, which I
identify as being at the center of national imagination.
There is no space here to elaborate on this argument, nor to present
the supporting evidence; yet, this alternative world view, the view that
sees these artifacts as subjects rather than objects, as animate entities
who need to be engaged with as with fellow humans, throws the legal and
mechanistic narratives on restitution into disarray. It forces
confrontation of the reality that the terms of our intellectual engagement
come from a specific, historically and politically situated discourse
within a dominant version of western modernity; their claims to
universality, therefore, are hollow and shaky. In other words it brings
the debates on restitution of artifacts even within Europe much closer to
the debates on reburial, repatriation, and cultural restitution in former
colonial contexts such as the Americas, Australia, and Africa. The
colonial and neocolonial gaze, the staging of an assumed neutral universal
material history in the metropolis, and the associated power dynamics must
be confronted as much in the crypto-colonies in Europe,8
as in the former colonies and neocolonies
beyond it.