In this edited volume, Enrique Peruzzotti and Catalina Smulovitz continue to explore the notion of “social accountability” (hereafter SA) in the context of Latin American democracy. The editors define SA (which they have sometimes labeled “societal accountability”), identify key strategies and actors, map the issues that have come to dominate this mode of political mobilization, and place this phenomenon in both historical and theoretical context. The various contributors build on this framework in a diverse and mostly very good set of essays. The chapters range from Andrew Arato's theoretical discussion of the limits of a pure political accountability regime, to Silvio R. Waisbord's account of the media's role in political scandals, to Adam Przeworski's critical analysis of the claim that Latin American democracies suffer from an accountability deficit. They include case studies of a single event of political malfeasance (e.g., the murder of Argentine photojournalist José Luis Cabezas and its cover-up) and more wide-angle analyses of political transformation (e.g., the pro-democracy efforts of civil society groups in Mexico toward the end of the Institutional Revolutionary Party's [PRI] hegemony). Overall, the book provides an interesting and useful window into intraelectoral mobilization as a way to hold politicians accountable.
The two editors have done most of the work of developing the concept of SA in earlier publications (e.g., Smulovitz and Peruzzotti, “Societal and Horizontal Controls: Two Cases of a Fruitful Relationship,” in Scott Mainwaring and Christopher Welna, eds., Democratic Accountability in Latin America, 2003; Smulovitz, “How Can the Rule of Law Rule? Cost Imposition through Decentralized Mechanisms,” in José María Maravall and Adam Przeworski, eds., Democracy and the Rule of Law, 2003; Smulovitz and Peruzzotti, “Social Accountability: The Other Side of Control,” Journal of Democracy 11 [no. 4, 2000]: 147–58), but this volume advances considerably in two related areas. The first, on a descriptive level, is in mapping out the diverse strategies that can be grouped under the label of SA. The second, on a theoretical level, is in beginning to identify the conditions that facilitate attempts to exercise SA. I address each of these in turn, then raise an issue that in my view deserved more attention.
The definition of SA is broad enough to encompass many specific mechanisms, strategies, actors, and goals. The editors define SA as “a nonelectoral yet vertical mechanism of control of political authorities that rests on the actions of an array of citizens' associations and movements and the media. The actions of these groups monitor public officials, expose governmental wrongdoing, and can activate the operation of horizontal agencies [such as courts]” (p. 10). The definition draws attention to episodes of political mobilization centering on perceived wrongdoing or gross failure to perform a duty by public officials. In this way, the editors seek to distinguish SA from episodes of what we might call programmatic mobilization, seeking to change policy.
The various chapters highlight the array of options available even in imperfect democracies to citizens who wish to impose costs on transgressing politicians. In Brazil, for example, the Ministério Público (prosecutor) has become an indispensable ally of social groups who want legal oversight of official actions (chap. 2), while other groups seek to trigger a parliamentary commission of inquiry (chap. 4). In a noticeable contrast with Brazil's reliance on state-based agents, groups in Argentina rely on mass mobilizations (chap. 8) and on a strategic alliance with the media (chaps. 9 and 10), which takes up and amplifies their voices, sometimes on the basis of exceedingly thin investigative reporting. And in another contrast to Argentina's more ad hoc mobilizations, Mexico's pro-democracy SA efforts were led by organized groups such as Alianza Cívica. Some of these modes are an uneasy fit with the definition of SA (e.g., the massive appeal to courts for relief from confiscatory financial measures in Argentina, in chap. 3), but overall, the diversity of experiences is interesting and opens up new lines of inquiry regarding the reasons behind these different choices.
While the authors do not give us a systematic, overarching causal framework, the various contributions identify conditions that facilitate the emergence and success of SA. Necessary conditions appear to be the presence of some basic political freedoms—rights of assembly, movement, and association, freedom of expression, and a free press, in particular (p. 336). SA rests as much on the possibility of imposing an electoral cost as on a legal response, and thus some possibility of meaningful electoral competition appears as a precondition. Formal mechanisms of accountability must, it seems, perform at an intermediate level—not so efficiently that they will respond in the absence of SA, but not so poorly that they cannot respond even if properly motivated. The issues taken up must resonate broadly—SA largely depends on capturing the public imagination, if not on securing an electoral majority—and thus will favor sensationalism. Federalism facilitates SA, as many of the movements target local authorities, capitalizing on segmented political authority and media markets and generating federal interventions into local politics. In general, then, it appears that SA is more likely to be the strategy of choice to address scandalous behavior when there is a reasonable amount of political freedom and at least some degree of political and media diversity, in a context of malfunctioning but not failed institutions.
While this is overall a highly satisfying treatment of an important phenomenon, a deeper analysis of the potentially negative consequences of SA would have been useful, and could have been based on material already in the book. The mood of the volume is largely positive, with caveats only regarding the effectiveness of SA (e.g., chap. 6 on the failure of civil society to monitor the police). But it appears, for example, that many of these movements rely on rumors and gossip as much as on accurate information, a problem enhanced by media tendencies to amplify accusations without investigation. SA acts as judge and jury, and in the context of politically sensitive judiciaries, this can and does lead to an emphasis on results—convictions, firings—rather than process—a fair investigation and trial. Worse, when social groups demand results in a context of political reluctance and weak institutions, the tendency, noticeable in almost all the cases described, is toward token results and scapegoating. Finally, when crowds massing before the capitol are the main impetus for state action, the tendency is to produce a politics of crisis, aimed at symptoms, rather than considered solutions to fundamental problems.
Enforcing the Rule of Law would have been stronger, in my view, if these concerns had been addressed head-on, and balanced against the undeniably positive contributions of SA to state responsiveness. On the other hand, this weakness is itself a tribute to the authors' scholarly contribution, as it is the book itself that raises these questions and concerns, opening up rich new avenues for investigation.
