In this book, Craig Arceneaux and David Pion-Berlin examine the impact of international influences on policy change in Latin American countries. As the authors correctly point out, “the scholarship on political change in Latin America provides little direction for those seeking answers to the relative impact of domestic and international forces” (p. 29). This ambitious project seeks to explain the conditions under which international actors influence governmental decisions, as well as the degree to which government policies are or are not shaped by foreign forces. To this end, they advance an “issue-guided analysis” that attempts to identify the important actors, capabilities, and modes of influence associated with policy change. The book offers a stimulating overview of foreign influences in domestic policy decisions, yet its contribution to the literature on policy reform in Latin America is limited.
The authors present their theoretical perspective in the first two chapters and their empirical evidence in five separate case studies. They begin describing an ongoing tension between a government's need for decision-making autonomy and the desire of foreign actors to erode some of that autonomy (p. 9). The issue-oriented approach attempts to highlight how different policy matters represent distinct constellations of opportunities and barriers for prospective participants. Issues belonging to the realm of high politics—where states have vital interests at stake—are differentiated from issues belonging to the realm of low politics—where states have little or no incentive to interfere in the domestic affairs of others. Powerful states, which have overwhelming financial and coercive resources at their disposal, have a greater incentive to intervene in high-politics issues (economics and security) than in low-politics issues (human rights and the environment). Foreign powers are portrayed as being able to successfully exert pressure on most issues, but strategic considerations lead them to concentrate their efforts on high-politics issues. Although “domestic moments” may occur in high politics (when foreign powers lose their motivation to intervene), policy change in those issues is primarily driven by foreign actors (p. 31).
How can we evaluate foreign influence in policy change? The book does not present systematic quantitative analysis or a rigorous comparative investigation of the effects of specific variables, and as a result it is difficult to evaluate the authors' propositions. The case studies that comprise the empirical chapters illustrate the participation of foreign and domestic actors in a variety of policy areas; however, they present only modest support for the propositions advanced in the theoretical chapters.
The principal high-politics issue addressed in the book is “neoliberal reform,” which is analyzed in Chapter 3. The authors claim that market reforms associated with the Washington Consensus belong to the realm of issues where the capacity of international actors to influence domestic politics is massive and where “there are no moments in which the balance of influence unexpectedly tips to the domestic” (p. 42). As a result, the forces of political change can largely be found in the self-interests of powerful outside forces (mainly the United States, multinational corporations, and international financial institutions). Since foreign actors are capable of determining the outcome of these reforms, the decision to provide (costly) international support is determined by their motivations. Political utility explains international support for Chile, and economic importance does the same for Brazil. Argentina, in contrast, lacks both qualities, resulting in the indifference of the U.S. government and the rise of the International Monetary Fund as the lead international actor (p. 77).
Arceneaux and Pion-Berlin present one plausible rationale for the different strategies of foreign actors (market size and political utility), but the chapter is unconvincing on matters central to the authors' theoretical arguments. The origins of these reforms stem from domestic sources, which is something that even the authors concede. And we cannot evaluate the role of foreign actors because the narrative fails to systematically compare the relative influence of the foreign and the domestic in the actual development of these reforms. It is unfortunate that the authors do not engage the vast theoretical and empirical literature on economic reform in Latin American countries that examines the power of those domestic actors that actually struggle to pass and implement these difficult reforms. Institutional characteristics and domestic actors (e.g., political parties, presidents, labor unions, industrialists, and consumers with voting power) play no crucial role in the authors' explanation of market-oriented reforms.
The fourth chapter focuses on democratic defense and democratic deepening, with particular attention to the role of the Organization of American States (OAS). Democratic defense is considered a low-politics issue that has recently moved to the realm of high politics. Democratic deepening, in contrast, continues to be a low-politics issue where foreign actors pay scant attention and domestic actors rule. The authors correctly point out that there has been a strengthening of electoral monitoring missions, but they also make the less substantiated claim that “the OAS had acquired the political will, legal machinery, and institutional wherewithal to rescue democracies under siege and to deter future conspiracies against them” (p. 93). The rest of the chapter examines the role of the OAS in the Peruvian elections of 2000 and the Ecuadorian coup of the same year.
The next two chapters address human rights issues in Chile and regional security arrangements in Central America. The intention is to illustrate deviations from the rule: when low-politics issues (human rights) have “international moments” and high-politics issues (security) have “domestic moments.” The chapter on how Central American nations proceeded to build regional arrangements in the 1990s provides a particularly valuable account of regional cooperation and domestic initiative on an issue generally dominated by U.S. concerns. The last chapter before the conclusion combines short discussions of the environment, immigration, and drug trafficking in order to illustrate how to classify issues that cannot be straightforwardly labeled within the high–low politics framework.
In sum, the book makes a good case for incorporating foreign actors into analyses of political change in Latin America. It illustrates how these foreign actors sometimes become important players that could potentially affect the strategies of national governments. In the end, however, it does not deliver a successful model for systematically assessing the degree of foreign influence in policy change.
