Uri Ram, an Israeli sociologist on the faculty of Ben Gurion University in Beersheva, is both the author of this study and an active contributor to the intellectual world whose history he is analyzing. The result is an analysis that effectively defines the politics of knowledge that is his subject and raises questions for the future. This combination is aptly illuminated by the author's comments on his own title when he reaches his conclusion. Here he makes a point that is central to the subjects he addresses: “‘Israeli nationalism’ furnishes the book with its title, but it is a moot point whether Israeli nationalism exists” (p. 129). This is not precisely a study of an Israeli nationalism that remains subject to debate but, more accurately, a study of “the itinerary of the discourse over Israeli nationality and society” (p. 83). Ram seeks to put that multidisciplinary discourse into social and political contexts that make it intelligible as well as easily accessible to those who do not specialize in Israeli history or Zionism. Those more familiar with these fields might have read some of this material published in earlier versions, but this book contains new chapters and integrates the analysis.
This is in essence a study of Israeli Jewish academic writing on Israeli history, society, and politics in its various dimensions. Two chapters are devoted to each discipline, with one addressing hegemonic discourse and the other discussing the emergence of alternatives. The result is somewhat uneven with regard to the different disciplines but simultaneously serves to make manifest underlying characteristics of all three. Although the chapters on history have appeared elsewhere and cover material familiar to those in the field, they are necessary to the broader project of this work.
The chapters on sociology and politics develop the author's analysis with regard to the shift from a dominant school of thought to the emergence of alternative perspectives on the nature of Israeli society and polity. As Israeli politics increasingly reflected challenges to earlier Labor dominance, and as new theoretical work became available (poststructural, postmodern, postcolonial), Israeli Jewish scholars and intellectuals actively questioned earlier received frameworks for understanding the nature of Israeli historical as well as social and political dynamics. Chapter 4, which discusses critical sociology and its contributions regarding Israeli identity, society, and nationhood, elaborates the interchange between academic debates and transformations of the contexts (theoretical as well as political) within which they occur. Ram is thus providing not only a very clearly organized and articulate analysis of the subject but also a framework that allows the reader to grasp the complex ways in which this discourse functions to allow Israeli intellectuals to grapple with their own social and political differences. The consideration of institutional differentiation and emerging academic journals enriches the discussion.
Ram's last two chapters address more directly the construction of Israel as a Jewish nation–state formed through specific exclusions and inclusions. While acknowledging that even the newer critical sociologists have failed to adequately research the occupation of Palestinian territories and its implications (p. 87), Ram's consideration of politics goes on to discuss a pattern that may be related to this lacuna, that is, what he terms the “Israeli regime of forgetting” and exclusion, particularly with regard to 1947 and 1948 and the ways in which Israeli statehood was established in a territory largely emptied of its Palestinian Arab inhabitants (p. 93). It is here that he clarifies the implications of these debates as he sees them, particularly with regard to the question of Israeli nationality and citizenship. If today's ideological conflicts can be articulated as between neo-Zionists and post-Zionists, Ram's analysis offers a careful reading of post-Zionism as a term that has been used to label a variety of perspectives with differing implications.
Underlying this entire study is a delineation of the impact on Israeli Jewish analysis of self and nation brought about by recognition, on the part of some scholars, of the degree to which the early years of the state were dominated not only by one party but also by a historical narrative that was linked to state construction and functioned to constrain challenges. As Israeli society and politics changed significantly in the aftermath of 1967 and into the late 1970s, those earlier frameworks could be seen as obscuring crucial realities. By the 1990s, as Ram makes clear, “post-Zionism has become the prism through which the augmenting tensions between the democratic and the Jewish dimensions of the state of Israel are exposed” (p. 126). Far from being a detached intellectual debate, this development comes in the midst of charged, deep divisions between those who demand recognition of Israel as a Jewish state and those who identify themselves with an Israel that is a state of its citizens with unrealized potential. Thus, he concludes that the title of this work refers to a still potential subject. Israeli nationality is not yet recognized by the Israeli state, but this analysis suggests that it remains subject to ongoing, vying constructions of self, community, and boundaries.
This book, with its clear and concise discussions, will be of interest to those who are not scholars in the field but have an interest in learning more about the development of Israeli Jewish definitions of their own history, society, and polity. For those more familiar with these, Ram's work offers an interesting analysis that places various disciplinary and historical discourses in conversation with one another and in relation to theoretical as well as political developments.
It should be pointed out that inevitably this is also a work bounded by its own time and place. In a country that is small (although, as Ram points out, much more diverse than its formative ideology recognized), in many ways intellectually intimate, and in which academic work is often viewed as having immediate political ramifications, the discourse here studied focuses on the inside of Israeli identity. As a project that began with the illusion of being fully formed at birth (i.e., Zionism as the Israeli state ideology presumed the existence of a Jewish nation creating a state), Israel has become increasingly an entity in which the relationships between state and nationhood cannot be assumed but rather are very much in flux. It is to understanding this reality that Ram's work makes its contribution. It is to be hoped that with time the saliency of these dilemmas within the broader regional context will become part of a more extensive discussion.
