Much of the recent reevaluation of Mexico's turn-of-the-century economic history has been done piecemeal and within the accepted chronology of presidencies and revolutionary moments. Mark Wasserman's Pesos and Politics works to overcome this periodization, presenting an argument for continuity despite political turmoil and civil war. Through the lens of business history, Wasserman advances an emergent historical narrative that restores control of the Mexican economy to Mexicans and demonstrates that the participation of foreigners within that economy was always both sought out and constrained. Wasserman draws on recent historiography as well as archival research to argue for an ongoing equilibrium among a large number of economic players through what he calls the elite-foreign enterprise system. Checks and balances facilitated by differentiated access to resources and political power kept any one group from dominating the economy. The Mexican Revolution introduced new participants and new challenges, particularly in the form of peasant- and labor-led expropriation and violence, but did not interrupt the combative and collaborative means by which political and economic elites—both foreign and national—worked to advance the Mexican economy.
As Wasserman demonstrates, most who invested in this economy came out the worse for wear. This in itself is a valuable contribution to our understanding of elite and foreign participation in the development of national economies in this era. While Mexican historiography has generally divided the period of Wasserman's study into three epochs—the Porfiriato (1876 to 1910), the Revolution (1910 to the early 1920s), and the consolidation of the single-party state (mid-1920s to 1940)—these were also the years of the export boom in Latin America and the first globalized economy. Wasserman does not explicitly make this connection, caught up instead in the important work of overcoming entrenched Mexican periodization, but his book provides valuable insights into how investors and companies, both national and foreign, coped with the unstable and insecure legal and economic institutions of the era. For the most part, they did not do so successfully. Though, as Wasserman admits, losers were more prone to enter the archival record through their complaints and bankruptcies, the overall picture he paints is one of slow overall economic growth built on individual economic failure. Rather than the railroad barons and banana kings who have long dominated our imagination of the export era, extracting massive wealth from Latin America's fertile countryside and leaving it dry, Wasserman's case studies mostly feature failed adventurers, overly optimistic speculators, and skilled entrepreneurs unable to overcome instability and interelite conflicts.
These case studies make up the meat of the book, organized into chapters that sweep across the entirety of the period in question. Because comprehensive data on investment and returns are unavailable, the book relies on anecdotal rather than systematic evidence to demonstrate how—even with careful negotiation, good capitalization, and a favorable government—financial success was difficult to achieve. Chapters alternate between generalized examinations of particular groups—Mexican entrepreneurs, foreign landholders, and foreign mining entrepreneurs—and close readings of individual companies or investors within those groups. The two chapters on Mexican participants use the exceptional—the richest clans in northern Mexico, the national takeover of the railroads—as a means to illustrate the checks and balances that the national government and regional elite could wield against foreign entrants and each other. The chapters on foreign participants each begin with a soon-repetitive reminder of the six factors Wasserman argues were necessary for success: capital, capable management, a steady market, a reliable workforce, adequate transportation, and good relations with authorities at all levels. Wasserman's reliance on anecdote and determination to cover a huge amount of ground leads at times to a laundry-list feeling in the generalized chapters. In contrast, the in-depth case studies of chapters 5 (the Corralitos Company) and 7 (the American Smelting and Refining Company) provide valuable insight into how even the most successful foreign enterprises were constrained by both active and circumstantial limits on their economic might.
While Wasserman covers the major drivers of the Mexican economy—transportation, mining, and agriculture—he does so almost exclusively in the north of the country. This leads to the predominance of American investors and companies in his analysis of foreigner investors, as well as the overemphasis of the region that provided the majority of post-Revolutionary national leaders. In so doing, he elides the national government's courting of European capital during the late nineteenth century and the diversity of agricultural endeavors in the south of the country. Wasserman's decision to end the study in 1940 goes mostly unexplained. He gestures to how the Revolution's introduction of new players shored up a more powerful central state, bringing about the end of the elite-foreign enterprise system. Yet the coincidence between this ending and that of the series of northern-origin presidents who ruled from the Revolution through the late 1920s remains unexplored.
In his need to overcome an entrenched narrative of exploitation by foreign investors, and subsequent vengeance against them, Wasserman at times becomes hyperbolic in his insistence that foreigners were not so bad and often lost out. This overemphasis is understandable, though, in the face of the historical narrative as it stands. Wasserman does important work to demonstrate the constraints inherent in the institutional weakness of the Mexican state as well as the opportunities these could create for national and foreign investors. He ends the book with a vital question for future scholars to answer: If we cannot blame foreigners for Mexico's underdevelopment, who, then, should accept that responsibility?
