The aims of John D. Ciorciari and Anne Heindel’s new book, which explores the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC), are twofold. First, the book seeks to “contribute to a better understanding of the transitional justice (TJ) process in Cambodia by providing a detailed account of why the ECCC was endowed with unique institutional features and how the Court has advanced, or sometimes failed to advance, its stated objectives” of providing (criminal) justice but also other aspects of social healing and development. Second, by examining the Cambodian case in comparative perspective, the book seeks to shed light “on the types of institutional features and personnel choices that help tribunals meet their mandates or impair their functional effectiveness—lessons that can help guide the reform of existing courts and design new ones” (p. 5).
The book is divided into ten chapters that deal with the negotiation for the Court, its hybrid character (including the difficulty of reconciling objectives, the mix of civil- and common-law features, national and international staff, and the application of international as well as national law); Cases 001, 002, 003, and 004; civil party participation, outreach, and legacy. It gives a coherent overview of the ECCC, why the Court was designed as it was, as well as the ways it works and, for that matter, does not work. Although the quality of the chapters varies slightly, the book constitutes a well-written and important empirical contribution to mainstream scholarly literature on TJ in general and international criminal law (ICL) in particular.
The main argument of the book is that, due to various design flaws, the ECCC is not a role model to be followed in the future. The authors conclude that: “Given the state of Cambodia’s judiciary, the ECCC’s greatest built-in weakness is that the United Nations has too much involvement to escape responsibility for the Court but too little authority to run it” (p. 10). The lesson learned from the ECCC is that “the United Nations should resist arrangements in which it plays junior partner to a national judicial system with dubious capacity and independence” (p. 263). Beyond this significant lesson, however, the authors argue that it is also possible to learn from the ECCC proceedings in relation to the procedural rules, independence of the bench, unnecessary duplication, and oversight mechanisms, the importance of outreach, engaging victims, capacity-building and the strengthening of the rule of law. All of this may be interesting, but it is basically about effectiveness and the strengthening of existing structures. This limitation obscures more important and fundamental questions about the ECCC and ICL.
What is largely missing from this book is a deep critical engagement with the complicities of the ECCC—including questions about power, resistance, the struggle over memory, injustices, exclusions, and biases—that are created and kept alive through particular modes of thought that are, more or less, taken for granted within mainstream TJ and ICL. Such a discussion would have considerably enhanced the value of the book.
