Soyica Diggs Colbert's The African American Theatrical Body: Reception, Performance, and the Stage offers a historical and literary examination of black performance and the possibilities of resistance therein. Beginning by broadening the definition of reparations to include not just monetary compensation but also the remaking of history and the making of subjectivity, Colbert argues that her reading of African American drama through this lens puts her in dialogue with Saidiya V. Hartman and Fred Moten, two formidably towering names in black cultural studies. What she contributes to this discussion is her argument that “Black performance not only perpetrates a radical tradition, it intervenes in the past not to undo or override it but to actively engage and abide with it in the present” (11). Colbert states that it is not recuperation (or remuneration) that she seeks from African American drama, but rather performance's potential for repair in examining the trauma and loss that accompany both the enactment and institution of slavery and its aftermath (11). Her methodology of reading black performance—which she utilizes as an umbrella term to encapsulate sermons, the blues, and the cakewalk, as well as plays both staged and unstaged—is aided by what she calls the “repetition/reproduction dyad” (14), in which “the repetition of performances may find fitting space to reproduce a scene and rework that scene's history” (13).
With the exception of its first chapter, The African American Theatrical Body is organized chronologically around the publication and production of African American dramatic texts. Entitled “Repetition/Reproduction: The DNA of Black Expressive Culture—Lorraine Hansberry's A Raisin in the Sun,” Chapter 1 posits Hansberry's 1959 play as answering the question, “What happens to a dream deferred?” with a question of its own: What happens if we create from the point of that deferment? In other words, by “[b]eginning from a position of disentitlement, displacement, and alienation,” Colbert contextualizes the play within the Great Migration and argues that it provides a means of imagining a future that hinges not upon domesticity and home, but rather upon a solidarity that is international in its scope (24).
Her second chapter, “Recuperating Black Diasporic History—W. E. B. Du Bois’ The Star of Ethiopia,” continues the work done in the first, examining the 1913 pageant and the figure of the lynched female body. Colbert contends that Du Bois seeks to correct the problematic idea that the black world lacks modernity. In the figure of Ethiopia, who is lynched and resurrected, Colbert sees Du Bois's symbolic attempt to “reproduce the black revolutionary spirit through resistance to the psychic, social, and physical death instantiated by the trans-Atlantic slave trade and the practices (e.g., lynching) that emerge in its wake” (56). What is precipitated in this play is the role of the audience, which is not to identify with Ethiopia but rather with the collective that she spearheads. In both of these early chapters, Colbert astutely addresses how Hansberry and Du Bois utilize theatrical space to address matters of collective identity and action.
The next two chapters concern texts by two eminent authors of the Harlem Renaissance. In “Reenacting the Harlem Renaissance—Zora Neale Hurston's Color Struck,” Colbert utilizes the figure of the mulatto and the cakewalk dance to read Hurston's still-unstaged 1925 play as a critique of the so-called progress being made in the name of the New Negro (97). Although the cakewalk offers a space of resistance, Colbert argues that Hurston's play also reveals the breaking down of the collective Du Bois attempted to articulate as a liberatory ideal. In “Resisting Shame and Offering Praise and Worship—Langston Hughes’ Tambourines to Glory,” we are moved roughly thirty years forward to 1956. Hughes's play is controversial in that it employs the sermon, the vernacular, and critiques of the black church during the civil rights movement, of which the institution was a fundamental element, and when integration was seen as a desirable goal. Colbert examines how Tambourines may offer strategies for speaking to the feelings of shame associated with the economic violation and dispossession that often accompanied black private life being made public.
The specter of lynching returns in Chapter 5, “Resisting Death: The Blues Bravado of a Ghost—James Baldwin's Blues for Mister Charlie.” Here, Colbert resists the impulse to read lynching as visually arresting/arrested, since reliance on visuality prevents us noticing or recognizing the acoustic trajectory of lynching. In Baldwin's 1964 play, Colbert locates the persistence of the lynching victim, and the theatre's capacity to “conjure and, as importantly, name the dead” (161). In Chapter 6, “Rituals of Repair: Amiri Baraka's Slave Ship and August Wilson's Joe Turner's Come and Gone,” Colbert examines the Black Arts movement generally and these two plays specifically to propose the collaborative nature of racial repair. She writes that rather than thinking of these two playwrights in succession, it is far more useful to examine how both “[p]ast and future productions of [their work] generate a past that serves as a legacy of black theater” (202). Colbert's final chapter, “Reconstitution—Suzan-Lori Parks’ Topdog/Underdog,” examines the familial narrative as a method through which the audience is led to look away “long enough to change history”—to be given what is presumed to be known, only to have that knowledge called into question (234).
Throughout, Colbert's arguments are buttressed by close readings of psychoanalytic theory, theatre history, and performance studies. What is both remarkable and, at times, slightly distracting about The African American Theatrical Body is the exacting precision with which Colbert brings other texts into conversation with her primary ones. This is done with particular brilliance in her chapter on James Baldwin, where she reads Blues for Mister Charlie alongside Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man; the skill with which she analyzes the eviction scenes from both narratives is supplemented by her equally prescient utilization of Kaja Silverman's and Freud's theoretical works. However, the same attention to intertextual detail proves a bit unwieldy in her chapter on Amiri Baraka and August Wilson, where she reads Toni Morrison's Beloved in her discussion on the geographic and psychic space of the home.
The African American Theatrical Body contends that “the fact that identity is constituted through performances and mediated by regulatory structures . . . creates a stranglehold on black bodies” (126). In her close readings of black dramatic texts spanning roughly a century, Colbert considers both the aesthetic and political stakes of this stranglehold, which propels history forward within and through the black actor's body. While Colbert's book is admittedly more accessible to scholars conversant in black cultural, performance, and literary studies, her historical overview and close readings also provide an up-to-date starting point for those beginning their forays into these fields. Colbert ends her book stating that she is indebted to the works of Hartman and Moten; The African American Theatrical Body, however, adds its own voice to their ongoing conversation, as well as to the larger and continuously challenging dialogue on the possibilities of self-fashioning in black performance.
