Regional theatres have become a mainstay of U.S. theatre culture, but little scholarship has been devoted to them until recently. In the past decade, some scholars have conducted thorough studies of theatre in particular cities or states, for example, Richard Christiansen in A Theater of Our Own: A History and a Memoir of 1,001 Nights in Chicago (Northwestern University Press, 2004), and Felicia Hardison Londré in The Enchanted Years of the Stage: Kansas City at the Crossroads of American Theater 1870–1930 (University of Missouri, 2007). In America's Longest Run: A History of the Walnut Street Theatre, Andrew Davis contributes to the field by surveying the 200-plus-year history of the Walnut Street Theatre in Philadelphia. The Walnut has the distinction of being the oldest theatre in the United States, and of having the largest subscriber base of any current nonprofit regional theatre. Davis argues that the Walnut's success largely has to do with its position as a populist theatre.
In the book's Prologue, Davis summarizes important events in the Walnut Street Theatre's history; in its subsequent sixteen chapters, he methodically covers the famous plays, performers, and managers of the theatre. Aside from the first, each chapter spans approximately ten years and has a title evocative of that period. In Chapter 1, “The Beginnings of Theatre in Philadelphia, 1682–1809,” Davis illustrates how Philadelphia became a theatrical center. He discusses the construction, in the 1790s, of the Chestnut Street Theatre, which catered to elite audiences. The Walnut, on the other hand, was built in 1809 to showcase circus acts, pantomimes, farces, hippodramas, and melodramas. According to Davis, such productions, combined with the Walnut's lower admission prices, established the theatre as a site for popular entertainments and common audiences. The distinction Davis draws between the Chestnut and Walnut audiences is central to his argument throughout the first half of his book.
Although he classifies the Chestnut as elite and the Walnut as populist, though, Davis also records similarities between the two establishments. In the 1820s, for example, both theatres presented operas, plays by Shakespeare, and Restoration comedies and tragedies; both featured on their stages visiting English stars; and both employed the same managers and acting company (a situation made possible by their being open at different times of the year). It seems the theatres were not that dissimilar, and that they engaged not only in competition but also in collaboration. Greater specificity and recognition of the Walnut's mixed repertoire may have been helpful in Davis's study to explore how audiences, critics, and producers negotiated the terms of the popular and the highbrow in nineteenth-century Philadelphia.
On a larger historical level, Davis shows how the Walnut mediated U.S. theatre trends, including U.S.–England cultural transactions, acting practices, and architecture. For example, in Chapter 2, “Circus and Spectacle at the Walnut Street Theatre, 1809–1820,” he contextualizes the American repertory within historical events, citing patriotic spectacles staged during the War of 1812. In Chapter 3, “The Era of the English Star, 1820–1829,” Davis notes that many famous British actors appeared at the Walnut and documents their acting styles; he devotes significant attention as well in this chapter to Edwin Forrest. Born in Philadelphia, Forrest made his Walnut Street Theatre debut in 1820 at the age of fourteen. He returned to its stage intermittently, famously competing with Charles Macready, who performed the same parts at the nearby Arch Street Theatre in 1848, a year before the Astor Place Riot. Today, a statue of Forrest as Coriolanus graces the Walnut's lobby. In Chapters 3–9, Davis explains historical theatrical transitions—made possible by the development of the railroads—from stock companies to the star system and then to combination companies. Several of these chapters contain sections detailing the many architectural modifications made to the Walnut's facade and house that accompanied concurrent changes in spectatorship behavior. In the brief Chapter 6 section, “Transforming the Theatre,” for instance, Davis observes that in 1852 box seats were cushioned, sightlines improved, and orchestra tickets made more expensive so that “[t]he pit, with its riotous behavior, became a thing of the past. Poorer people were now relegated to the upper balcony” (105).
By keeping up with audiences’ tastes, the Walnut remained one of the top professional theatres in Philadelphia. Meanwhile, the Chestnut and the Arch, among other theatres, burned down or were razed in the mid-to-late nineteenth century. In Chapters 10–13, Davis describes how the Walnut Street Theatre became a Syndicate house at the turn of the twentieth century and then, in the 1940s through the 1960s, a Shubert house for Broadway tryouts. At this point, Davis's account turns into a year-by-year catalog of well-known actors who graced the Walnut's stage (such as members of the Philadelphia Barrymore family), and American plays that premiered there (such as A Streetcar Named Desire).
Davis's final three chapters represent particularly valuable contributions to contemporary regional theatre studies because they recount the Walnut's transformation into a nonprofit cultural institution. In 1970, civic and business leaders in Philadelphia purchased the theatre from the Shuberts and converted it into a performing arts center for the presentation of classical music, dance, and theatre. Twelve years later, Bernard Havard, who had been managing director of the Alliance Theatre in Atlanta, was named the executive director of the Walnut Street Theatre. He shaped the organization into a subscription-based producing theatre with a popular repertory consisting mostly of musicals, comedies, solo acts, and children's theatre. To demonstrate that the Walnut continues to be a populist theatre today, Davis points to this repertory, to the theatre's education initiatives and its practice of casting local actors, and to its high earned to unearned income ratio. He also provides an insider's look into season planning issues. Moreover, he attempts to trouble the too widely held view that nonprofit theatres should not produce popular—deemed commercial—work.
This clothbound book will be useful to scholars of popular U.S. performance and history as an exhaustive chronicle. But it is equally meant for a general readership, especially for Walnut patrons. Davis uses plentiful subheadings, several images of the theatre and the actors who performed there, and few footnotes to make his narrative accessible. He fills his account with anecdotes and clarifies terms such as limelight and burlesque. Ultimately, America's Longest Run: A History of the Walnut Street Theatre is important for recording that run and for relating the Walnut to American theatre over the past two centuries.
