Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T17:05:21.501Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Freely rising or falling of a sphere in a square tube at intermediate Reynolds numbers

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 December 2024

Deming Nie
Affiliation:
College of Metrology Measurement and Instrument, China Jiliang University, Hangzhou 310018, China
Jingwen Wang
Affiliation:
College of Metrology Measurement and Instrument, China Jiliang University, Hangzhou 310018, China
Siwen Li
Affiliation:
College of Metrology Measurement and Instrument, China Jiliang University, Hangzhou 310018, China
Jianzhong Lin*
Affiliation:
Key Laboratory of Impact and Safety Engineering (Ningbo University), Ministry of Education, Ningbo 315201, ChinaInstitute of Fluid Engineering, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, China
*
†Email address for correspondence: mecjzlin@public.zju.edu.cn

Abstract

The motion of a sphere freely rising or falling in a 5d (d is the diameter of the sphere) square tube was numerically studied for the sphere-to-fluid density ratio ranging from 0.1 to 2.3 (0.1 ≤ ρs/ρ ≤ 2.3, ρs is the density of spheres and ρ the fluid density) and Galileo number from 140 to 230 (140 ≤ Ga ≤ 230). We report that Hopf bifurcation occurs at Gacrit ≈ 157, where both the heavy and light spheres lose stability. The helical motion is widely seen for all spheres at Ga > 160 resulting from a double-threaded vortex interacting with the tube walls, which becomes irregular at Ga ≥ 190 where heavy spheres act differently from their counterparts; that is, heavy spheres change their helical directions alternately while light spheres exhibit helical trajectories with jaggedness in connection with the shedding of the double-threaded vortices. This is because of the difference in inertia between the heavy and light spheres. We also checked the oscillation periods for the helical motion of the spheres. They show opposite variations with ρs/ρ for the two types of spheres. Light spheres (ρs/ρ ≤ 0.7) reach a zigzagging regime at Ga ≥ 200 where a vortex loop (hairpin-like vortical structure) is formed which may develop into a vortex ring downstream at small ρs/ρ. This might be the first time a transition from the helical motion to the zigzagging motion for heavy spheres (ρs/ρ ≥ 1.8) has been reported. Finally, we examined the dependence of both the terminal Reynolds number and the drag coefficient of the spheres on the Galileo number.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Discrete velocity vectors of D3Q19 lattice model (e0 ~ e18).

Figure 1

Figure 2.Schematic diagram of the present problem. A heavy sphere (a: ρs/ρ > 1) or a light one (b: ρs/ρ < 1) is freely falling or rising in an infinite square tube which is filled with a fluid with density ρ and kinematic viscosity ν. Note that d and ρs denote the diameter and density of the spheres, respectively. The width of the tube was fixed at 5d, i.e. L = 5d. We used a moving grid scheme to make sure the spheres stay at a vertical position having distances of 12d and 25d from the upstream and the downstream, i.e. Hu = 12d and Hd = 25d, respectively. This results in a total height of the domain of 37d, i.e. H = Hu + Hd = 37d.

Figure 2

Table 1.Terminal velocities of a heavy sphere (ρs/ρ = 1.5) at steady state for two Ga numbers.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Simulation results at (a,b) Ga = 144 and (c,d) Ga = 178, respectively. Note that (a,c) show the iso-surfaces of the vertical fluid velocity where $u_z^\ast=- 0.1$ and (b,c) show the iso-surfaces of the vorticity where λ2 = −0.01. We use the second largest eigenvalue of the tensor S2 + $\boldsymbol{\varOmega}$2 (where S and $\boldsymbol{\varOmega}$ are the symmetrical and anti-symmetrical components of the velocity gradient tensor, i.e. $\boldsymbol{\nabla }\boldsymbol{u}$, respectively), represented by λ2 (Jeong & Hussain 1995), to identify the vortical structures in the wake of a falling or rising sphere (the same below). Note that it seems the heavy sphere is purple in colour because the iso-surface results were made 60% transparent. The sphere is actually red in colour as indicated in figure 2 (the same below).

Figure 4

Figure 4.Motion patterns of the spheres rising or falling in a 5d square tube in the parametric space of (Ga, ρs/ρ) for Ga ranging between 140 and 240, and ρs/ρ from 0.1 to 2.3.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Time history of the velocities for spheres with different densities at Ga = 150: (a) vertical component ($|{U_z^\ast } |$), (b) horizontal component ($U_x^\ast $). The terminal Reynolds number is ReT ≈ 186 for all particle densities considered.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Simulation results for a heavy sphere (a,c) with ρs/ρ = 2 and a light one (b,d) with ρs/ρ = 0.1 at steady state. Note that (a,b) show iso-surfaces of the vorticity (λ2 = −0.01), and (c,d) show iso-surfaces of the vertical fluid velocity where $u_z^\ast = {-}0.1$ for the heavy sphere and $u_z^\ast= 0.1$ for the light sphere, respectively. The light sphere (d) seems to be orange in colour because of the transparent iso-surface of the fluid velocity (the same below).

Figure 7

Figure 7.Trajectories of a heavy sphere with ρs/ρ = 2.3 (a,b) and a light one ρs/ρ = 0.1 (c, d) at Ga = 156 (a,c) and Ga = 157 (b,d), respectively. Note that both spheres are seen to lose steadiness at Ga = 157. The corresponding Reynolds number is ReT ≈ 196. The blue circle in each panel denotes the initial position of the spheres (the same below). In this study we normalized the particle trajectory through x* = x/d, y* = y/d, and z* = (z − z0)/d. Note that $(x_0^\ast ,y_0^\ast ,z_0^\ast ) = ( - 1,0,0)$ for all spheres.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Instantaneous contours of the 2-D vorticity ($\omega _z^\ast $) in the (x, y) plane for the light sphere (ρs/ρ = 0.1) at different Galileo numbers: (a) Ga = 150, (b) Ga = 156, (c) Ga = 157, (d) Ga = 158 and (e) Ga = 160. Note that the 2-D vorticity is given by $\omega _z^\ast= {(\boldsymbol{\nabla } \times \boldsymbol{u})_z}\ast d/{U_g}$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Top views (x–y projections) of particle trajectories for spheres with different densities at Ga = 158: (a) ρs/ρ = 0.1, (b) ρs/ρ = 0.5, (c) ρs/ρ = 1.5 and (d) ρs/ρ = 2.3.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Falling trajectories of a heavy sphere (ρs/ρ = 2) showing RHM at (a) Ga = 165, (b) Ga = 170 and (c) Ga = 185, and AHM at (d) Ga = 195.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Top views of figure 10(a−d). The arrows denote the circling directions of the sphere.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Time history of the rotational angles of the same sphere as in figure 10: (a) rotational angles around the z-axis ($\theta _z^\ast $) at Ga = 185 and 195, (b) rotational angles around the x-($\theta _x^\ast $) and y-axes ($\theta _y^\ast $) at Ga = 185. The angles were normalized through $\theta _x^\ast= {\theta _x}/{\rm \pi}$, $\theta _y^\ast= {\theta _y}/{\rm \pi}$ and $\theta _z^\ast= {\theta _z}/{\rm \pi}$. The initial value of each of θx, θy and θz was zero, i.e. $\theta _x^\ast (0) = 0$, $\theta _y^\ast (0) = 0$ and $\theta _z^\ast (0) = 0$. Note that t1 ~ t3 in (b) correspond to those in figure 11(c).

Figure 13

Figure 13.Time history of the velocities (top: vertical, bottom: horizontal) for the same sphere as in figure 10 at (a) Ga = 165 (RHM), (b) Ga = 185 (RHM) and (c) Ga = 195 (AHM), and (d) instantaneous vortical structures (λ2 = −0.005) in the wake of the sphere at the three Galileo numbers.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Top views of the trajectories for a heavy sphere (ρs/ρ = 2.3) falling at Ga = 205 during two time periods: (a) t* ≈ 1220–1435, and (b) t* ≈ 1614–1714, respectively. The arrows denote the circling direction of the sphere, indicating the AHM.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Instantaneous iso-surfaces of the vorticity (λ2 = −0.005) for the same sphere (AHM) as in figure 14 at different times: (a) t* = t1, (b) t* = t2, (c) t* = t3, (d) t* = t4 and (e) t* = t5. Note that t1 ~ t5 are indicated in figure 14(a).

Figure 16

Figure 16.Instantaneous iso-surfaces of the vorticity (λ2 = −0.01) for a heavy sphere (ρs/ρ = 2.2) at Ga = 230 during one period (T* ≈ 69): (a) t* = 0, (b) t* ≈ 0.25T*, (c) t* ≈ 0.45T* and (d) t* ≈ 0.85T*. Note that the sphere undergoes the RHM.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Rising trajectories of a light sphere (ρs/ρ = 0.2) showing the RHM at (a) Ga = 160, (b) Ga = 170, (c) Ga = 180, and showing the JHM at (d) Ga = 190 and (e) Ga = 195.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Top views of figure 17(a−e).

Figure 19

Figure 19.Instantaneous iso-surfaces of the vorticity (λ2 = −0.01) for the same sphere (ρs/ρ = 0.2) as in figure 17. Each result is chosen at the time when the sphere moves to the rightmost position.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Iso-surfaces of the vertical vorticity ($\omega _y^\ast= \pm 0.5$) corresponding to figure 19(a−e). Note that $\omega _y^\ast= {(\boldsymbol{\nabla } \times \boldsymbol{u})_y}\ast d/{U_g}$.

Figure 21

Figure 21.Rising trajectories of a light sphere with different densities at Ga = 195: (a) ρs/ρ = 0.1 (JHM), (b) ρs/ρ = 0.3 (JHM), (c) ρs/ρ = 0.5 (RHM). (d) Top views of (a) at two specific time periods.

Figure 22

Figure 22.Instantaneous iso-surfaces of the vorticity (λ2 = −0.01) for a light sphere (ρs/ρ = 0.1) at Ga = 195 (JHM): (a) t* = t1, (b) t* = t2, (c) t* = t3 and (d) t* = t4. Note that t1 ~ t4 are indicated in figure 21(d).

Figure 23

Figure 23.Top views of the trajectories for a rising sphere (ρs/ρ = 0.2) at Ga = 180 (RHM): effects of the initial position, i.e. ($x_0^\ast $, $y_0^\ast $). Note that the trajectory resulting from (−1, 0) is equivalent to that in figure 18(c).

Figure 24

Figure 24.Falling trajectories of a heavy sphere with different densities at Ga = 220 showing the ZM for (a) ρs/ρ = 1.9, (b) ρs/ρ = 2, (c) ρs/ρ = 2.2 and (d) ρs/ρ = 2.3.

Figure 25

Figure 25.Top views of the trajectories a falling sphere (ρs/ρ = 2.3) at Ga = 220 (ZM): effects of the initial position. Note that (a) is the top view of figure 24(d).

Figure 26

Figure 26.Instantaneous iso-surfaces of the vorticity (λ2 = −0.01) for a heavy sphere (ρs/ρ = 2.3) at Ga = 220 (ZM) during one period (T* ≈ 69): (a) t* = 0, (b) t* ≈ 0.25T*, (c) t* = 0.5T* and (d) t* = 0.75T*.

Figure 27

Figure 27.Rising trajectories of a light sphere with different densities at Ga = 210 showing the ZM: (a) ρs/ρ = 0.3, (b) ρs/ρ = 0.4, (c) ρs/ρ = 0.5, (d) ρs/ρ = 0.6 and (e) ρs/ρ = 0.7.

Figure 28

Figure 28.Time history of the angles of a light sphere (ρs/ρ = 0.7) exhibiting the ZM at Ga = 210. Note that t1 ~ t3 correspond to those in figure 27(e).

Figure 29

Figure 29.Instantaneous iso-surfaces of the vorticity (λ = −0.01) in the wake of the same light sphere as in figure 27 (Ga = 210).

Figure 30

Figure 30.Trajectories of a light sphere showing irregular ZM: (a) ρs/ρ = 0.1 (Ga = 200), (b) ρs/ρ = 0.2 (Ga = 205), (c) ρs/ρ = 0.3 (Ga = 205) and (d) top views of (a‒c).

Figure 31

Figure 31.Oscillation periods for both heavy (ρs/ρ > 1) and light (ρs/ρ < 1) spheres undergoing: (a) the RHM (Ga = 170 and 190), and (b) ZM (Ga = 210 and 220), respectively.

Figure 32

Figure 32.Oscillation periods ($T_r^\ast $) normalized by the time scale at ρs/ρ = 0.8 (or 1.2) for Ga = 190 depending on (a) ρs/ρ and (b) |ρs/ρ − 1|, respectively.

Figure 33

Figure 33.Top views of helical trajectory for heavy spheres with different densities at Ga = 190: (a) ρs/ρ = 1.2, (b) ρs/ρ = 1.5, (c) ρs/ρ = 1.7 and (d) ρs/ρ = 1.8. The limit cycle is indicated by a thick line for each case (the same below).

Figure 34

Figure 34.Top views of particle trajectory for light spheres with different densities at Ga = 190: (a) ρs/ρ = 0.25, (b) ρs/ρ = 0.5, (c) ρs/ρ = 0.6 and (d) ρs/ρ = 0.8.

Figure 35

Figure 35.Instantaneous contours of the 2-D vorticity ($\omega _z^\ast $) for a light (a,c: ρs/ρ = 0.8) and heavy (b,d: ρs/ρ = 1.2) spheres, respectively. Note that (a,b) represent results when the spheres are closest to the right wall while (c,d) represent those when the spheres are closest to the upper wall.

Figure 36

Figure 36.Dependence of (a) the terminal Reynolds number and (b) drag coefficients on the Galileo number. The relationship between ReT and Ga and that between CD and Ga from Cabrera-Booman et al. (2024) are indicated for reference.