Stephen Blake has written an accessible survey of Islamic astronomical sciences that looks well beyond the Islamic world. Astronomy and Astrology in the Islamic World opens with a chapter discussing Mesopotamian, Greek, and Indian precedents, and ends with one describing how Islamic scientific contributions were adopted by early modern European scholars. Chapter 2 covers the entire period from Muhammad to the coming of the Saljūqs, which forces Blake to pass rather rapidly over the major contributions of Khwārizmī, Bīrūnī, and others. The remaining six chapters proceed chronologically, each one discussing the scientists who worked under a major Islamic dynasty, and featuring the major observatories those dynasties funded. Throughout, Blake reviews relevant political events to contextualize the scientific material for readers unfamiliar either with astronomy or with Islamic history. In brief, then, this is a catalog of scientific developments organized around the major Islamic centers of patronage.
It should be noted that this is a survey, and not a contribution of original research. Each of Blake's chapters leans heavily on databases such as the Dictionary of Scientific Biography and on specialized studies such as those of Aydın Sayılı (The Observatory in Islam and its Place in the General History of the Observatory, Türk Tarih Kurumu Basımevi, 1960), Julio Samso (Islamic Astronomy and Medieval Spain, Ashgate, 1994), Sevim Tekeli (The Clocks in Ottoman Empire in 16th Century and Taqi al-Din's “The Brightest Stars for the Construction of the Mechanical Clocks”, Ankara Üniversitesi Basımevi, 1966), and Nirendra Nath Sharma (Sawai Jai Singh and His Astronomy, Motilal Banarsidass, 1995). This does not invalidate the information offered, particularly as some of these specialized works are not widely accessible. By skimming these studies for their scientific information, however, Blake loses sight of the role of astronomy and astrology in the lives of people. The resulting book is a catalog of names, works, discoveries, and refinements, with only passing glimpses of how the view of the heavens informed aesthetics and art, institutions of authority, or the perceived relationship between humans and the supernatural.
The most troubling aspect of this book is its interpretive biases in the treatment of astrology and of the place of Islamic science in world history. Blake makes little effort to hide his disdain for astrology, distinguishing this “pseudoscience” from the “science” of astronomy in his first page of prose (vii–viii). While he acknowledges the perennial popularity of astrology, he treats it only occasionally and dismissively. Of course, Blake is not alone in this. The Metropolitan Museum of Art's recent exhibition and publication of “The Great Age of the Saljuqs” categorized the study of the stars with “magic and the world of beasts,” rather than “science, medicine, and technology.” Post-Enlightenment scientific rationalism makes it easy to dismiss astrology as a superstition, but to deny its role in the lives of historical societies is an egregious act of presentism. Astronomy has been a major motivator of human action, and so it should be considered on the equal grounds that the title of this book suggests, even if the author does not himself read his daily horoscope.
The second major interpretive bias of this book concerns the situation of Islamic astronomy and astrology in the longer history of science. The observable sky is one of those rare things common to all cultures, and so technologies related to astronomy have traveled freely across cultural and political boundaries for as long as we can tell. Blake's introductory chapter makes this fact clear, but his study ultimately accelerates towards the accomplishments of Copernicus, Kepler, and Newton, who star in the book's ninth and final chapter. Blake claims to have discarded a “cartoon version” of history by which Islamic stargazers preserved unchanged the science of the ancients, then handed it over to the rationalists of European modernity. In the end, however, he celebrates the work that Copernicus and his ilk did to overturn the error of geocentrism. In doing this, Blake perpetuates the idea that the encounter of the “Islamic world” with Greek sciences was a temporary (if productive) detour from an essentially Western narrative.
Blake's verdict on the Andalusian scientist al-Zarqālī (who wrote 450 years before Copernicus) illustrates both these biases well: “Whereas Zarqālī and his colleagues were interested in calculating the positions of the heavenly bodies in order to draw up horoscopes, Copernicus was concerned with constructing a model of the real world, creating an astronomical system that reflected physical reality.” (59) Blake here subordinates the work of Zarqālī (alongside that of Abu Maʿshar, Khwārizmī, Ṭūsī, and others) to a grand scientific narrative bookended by Ptolemy and Newton, and dismisses the horoscopic component of astronomic observation as self-evidently detached from reality.
Throughout this book, Blake keeps his eye on the advancements in astronomical observation, instrument design, and planetary theory that paved the way for the heliocentric models of the early modern West. That shift to a heliocentric vision of the universe solved many of the theoretical and mathematical bugbears of astronomy. It also made the human presence in the universe seem insignificant, undermining the idea that stars, planets, or gods might have any concern whatsoever for human affairs. From such a viewpoint, the accomplishments of any pre-modern, non-Western people can never be but quaint and pitiably star-struck efforts.
