Anyone who is involved in arts education, research or is a practising artist will probably have considered what it means to be a ‘reflective practitioner’. This book, aimed at people working in the arts as teachers, practitioners or researchers, invites deeper thought about reflective practice and its role within the current context of accountability in education. The book has three main sections. Section 1 provides a rationale for examining reflection from cognitive, phenomenological, cultural and sociological perspectives. Section 2 offers examples of tools or instruments facilitating reflection in specific situations where these tools are central to the enquiry. Section 3 provides further illustration through the presentation of case studies employing reflective activity. The contributors are artists, teachers and researchers from the UK, North and South America, Canada, Hong Kong and Australia. The book is generally very well organised and is written in an authoritative but approachable style. It will, without doubt, appeal to teachers, artists and researchers who want to explore the concept of reflection in detail.
In Section 1, the chapter that aroused my interest was ‘Teaching Performing Arts to Muslims’ by Diana Harris. Many of us now work in increasingly multi-ethnic and multi-cultural situations which are often very rewarding and informative while at the same time being potentially challenging from a cross-cultural perspective. The chapter begins with an overview of the importance of tolerance, sensitivity and understanding of other races and cultures, giving an account of the pressures felt by Muslims in the UK as a result of increased ‘Islamophobia’ experienced since 9/11 and the Bali, Madrid and London bombings. Western media, in particular the ‘populist newspapers’, are presented as instigators and perpetuators of this negative phenomenon. However, one newspaper, The Guardian, is praised for allowing 100 young British Muslims the opportunity to express ‘rarely heard voices’ through discussion in the newspaper. Harris suggests that involvement with the performing arts could give Muslims the opportunity to express their personalities and cultures but warns that first we must understand that the words ‘performing’, ‘music’, ‘dance’ and ‘drama’ are anathema to many Muslims (p. 25). The chapter presents interesting examples illustrating Muslims' multi-faceted perception of the arts, including the view expressed by some that ‘performing is not seen as a serious or honourable way of spending one's time’ (p. 26). The author elaborates: ‘Taking this a stage further we come to the already familiar view held by many parents that there is “no point in teaching something unless it can lead to a profession”’ (p. 26). At this point in the chapter, it is not absolutely clear whether the author believes that this view is one held by Muslim parents alone or parents in general. In either case, the advice offered is to ‘make explicit the reasons for engaging in the performing arts’ (p. 26) by outlining the educational importance of extending imagination and self-expression and by emphasising links with other disciplines regarded as ‘more academically acceptable’ (p. 26). I would concur with the two former points but have reservations about the latter. Many arts educators would argue that performance is academically valid in its own right and does not need to rely on links with other disciplines for its validity.
The focus in Section 2 of the book is on tools and instruments that facilitate the reflective process. I was drawn to the chapter on ‘Reflective use of Digital Technologies in the Arts’ by Jane Cheung and Eton Kung, which reports a project with pre-service music students in Hong Kong as they employ music technology and Blackboard e-learning platform to enhance reflective practices during the process and product of music composition. This chapter begins with a well-written, succinct literature review outlining the rationale behind reflective practice and the use of technology. This project is particularly interesting as it describes the use of technology to support the composition process of student music teachers with limited prior experience of composition in a cultural and educational environment that only recently initiated the integrating of performing, creating and listening activities in schools. The chapter consists of relatively short and approachable sections which are well illustrated through supporting images. Quotes from the participant students help to give the reader a clear understanding of the research. The chapter concludes with a section dedicated to ‘Reflective use of Digital Technologies’ containing paragraphs on technologies as ‘Facilitators’, ‘Catalysts’, ‘Enhancers’ and ‘Role Reverser’. This highlights the positive qualities technology can bring to music composition in collaborative e-learning environments, encouraging peer evaluation using technologies that form part of young peoples' daily lives. Also highlighted is the potential for change in the role of the teacher from instructor to facilitator.
Section Three reports four case studies from a reflective position and concludes with a chapter by one of the editors that draws together the issues and themes emerging from the book. This section of the book really epitomises the essence of how reflective practice informs and develops arts education and will be of interest to anyone involved in these activities. All the chapters in this section were interesting, but I have chosen to focus here on ‘Cross- and Intercultural Engagement: A Case Study in Self-reflection and Finding Meaning’ by Dawn Joseph. The author begins by explaining her motivation for teaching African music to Australian, non-music specialist, trainee primary teachers at Deakin University, Australia. Joseph is an Indian woman, trained as a western classical music educator, who lived for 35 years in South Africa during the apartheid period. She explains that this combination of ethnicity and experience resulted in her having an ‘endogenous rather than an indigenous perspective’ (p. 149) on her teaching in Australia. The chapter unfolds presenting ‘Theoretical Perspectives’ and ‘African Music and Culture’ before outlining the ‘Deakin University African Music Project’ which is a case study involving 31 students in 2002 and 35 students in 2003. Prior to this project no Aboriginal music or music from other cultures had been taught as part of the Primary Arts Education course, and the author concludes that ‘African music at Deakin University is a step in my personal odyssey to transmit “the other” in Australia’ (p. 157). This outlook would be beneficial in many music education environments worldwide.
This review would be incomplete without commending the ultimate chapter ‘The Conditions and Consequences of Reflective Practices in Arts Education’ by Sarah Hennessey. This excellent summation of the book adeptly draws together the many and varied issues raised in the preceding chapters. It is incisive, confident and resounds with the veracity of someone who really understands and believes in what she is writing about. Anyone who is involved with arts education would find something enlightening and informative in this book. I shall give the last word to the editors: ‘There are many references in chapters in this book to the democratising role of reflective experience towards greater self-awareness, self-worth and confidence, autonomy and responsibility. If this is to be realised, not only for young people but also for teachers and other professionals then, as I and others have alluded to, there are bound to be some problems ahead when centralised control of education becomes an unbearable straight jacket’ (p. 191).
