A long-standing empirical finding in the gender and politics literature is that, when women run for political office, they win at rates equal to their male counterparts (Richard Seltzer, Jody Newman, and Melissa Leighton, Sex as a Political Variable: Women as Candidates & Voters in U.S. Elections, 1997). This finding has led to considerable debate about whether gender bias affects voter evaluations of female candidates. Kelly Dittmar’s book, Navigating Gendered Terrain: Stereotypes and Strategy in Political Campaigns, reconsiders the notion of gender neutrality in campaigns and elections by investigating how campaign practitioners address the role of gender in the formulation of campaign strategies. After all, voters decide which candidates to support after exposure to a variety of campaign messages that are often designed to minimize the negative effects of gender bias among voters.
Dittmar unpacks the way campaign strategists consider gender through the lens of a feminist institutionalist framework. The value of this framework is twofold. First, a feminist institutionalist framework recognizes that campaigns are inherently masculine institutions. This means that female candidates must operate within these constraints to gain credibility. However, female candidates are not completely constrained by these masculine institutions; but rather, they can often instigate transformative change by working within these institutions. Second, a feminist institutionalist framework allows Dittmar to move past initial claims that candidate gender does not affect strategic choices to identify the more nuanced ways that gender factors into the decisions made by those on the ground floor of campaigns. Building on this framework, Dittmar meticulously uncovers the subtle ways that gender affects how campaigns navigate an inherently masculine environment.
In 2008 and 2010, increased numbers of women ran for political office at the state, local, and national level, including Hillary Clinton’s presidential primary run and Sarah Palin’s Vice Presidential bid. These are the years Dittmar analyzes. Dittmar conducts surveys and extensive long-form interviews with both Democratic and Republican campaign staffers. Using actual campaign strategists as the sample offers a rare behind the scene peak into the logic and thought that goes into deciding how and when to emphasize gender. Dittmar’s methodological choices allow her to develop valuable insights into the beliefs strategists have about how voters think about gender and associated stereotypes, and how they develop campaign themes that address these beliefs. Overall, the analyses provide a rich and thorough investigation of the many, though not always straightforward, ways that gender affects strategy.
Dittmar’s thorough and timely analyses offer three key insights into how gender affects campaign strategy. These findings have critical implications for campaign scholars as well as campaign practitioners. First, campaign practitioners believe that voters do, in fact, hold beliefs about female candidates that fit with gender stereotypes. For example, both Democratic and Republican consultants report that they believe voters perceive female candidates as emotional and compassionate. This finding is important because recent academic research suggests that voters may not actually hold these beliefs about female candidates (Deborah Jordan Brooks, He Runs, She Runs, 2013; Monica C. Schneider and Angela L. Bos, “Measuring Stereotypes of Female Politicians,” Political Psychology, 2014). Nevertheless, these beliefs certainly shape how strategists develop central themes for a female candidate’s campaign. If strategists believe that an association with emotionality is an obstacle for female candidates then they are more likely to present their candidate in a way that shows she is strong and authoritative. And, these choices made by practitioners certainly affect how voters use, or do not use, gender stereotypes in forming impressions of female candidates.
Second, electoral context affects the navigation of gender during a campaign. Electoral context refers to both the external political climate and the internal dynamics of a specific race. Campaigns do not take place in a vacuum, and contextual factors not only determine candidate strategy but voter receptivity to specific strategies. The analyses about the behavior of a female candidate’s opponent, often male, are particularly insightful sections of the book. Perhaps most interestingly is that opponent gender matters not only in mixed gender races, but in female versus female races as well. The 2010 California Senate race, for example, featured Carly Fiorina challenging Barbara Boxer. Even in the context of a race with a likely incumbent victory, gender still factored into messaging especially as Fiorina tried to cut into Boxer’s advantage with female voters. Gender matters, but the ways in which gender matters and how gender matters, depend on a host of contextual variables that may differ across time and across race.
Third, emphasizing candidate gender can work to either the detriment or benefit of female candidates. Dittmar examines how gender comes into play through issues, traits, appearance, family, qualifications, and negative advertising among other ways. Often the previous literature linking strategy to voter behaviors assumes that all the ways in which feminine stereotypes can come into play have an equal effect. In other words, there is an assumption that the effect of emphasizing feminine traits, such as being warm and compassionate, is equivalent to the effect of emphasizing feminine issues, such as equal pay or reproductive rights. However, the content of these stereotypic messages, and the effects of these messages are not equitable. Identifying how different components of campaign messages reinforce or counter feminine stereotypes offers a new theoretical lens through which to study gender stereotypes.
Dittmar’s book, Navigating Gendered Terrain, is relevant for not only scholars of gender and campaign practitioners but also for scholars of political behavior, political psychology, and public opinion more broadly. Overall, Dittmar challenges the tempting notion among scholars, pundits, and the public that political campaigns and elections are gender neutral. Campaigns are far from gender neutral, but many strategists aim to neutralize or reduce the role of gender in the minds of voters. As Dittmar notes, “gender neutrality in electoral outcomes does not reflect gender neutral campaigns but instead results from gendered decision making well before Election Day (p. 156).” Recognizing that gender equity at the polls is often the product of a carefully constructed campaign process designed to minimize the role of gender in vote choice calculations opens up a host of new empirical questions for future work. Such questions include examining the effectiveness of candidate strategies at neutralizing gender, and the contexts that give rise to strategies that downplay or play up candidate gender. The rich and novel conclusions developed throughout Dittmar’s text will certainly keep campaign scholars busy in the future.
