Albert O. Hirschman was a wide-ranging institutionalist economist. Like John Kenneth Galbraith, but less wordy and more original, he wrote witty and provocative books in political economy that favored relevance over rigor. In Exit, Voice and Loyalty, by far his most cited work, Hirschman criticized perfect competition and other “taut” models for ignoring out-of-equilibrium error-correction processes. Hirschman first conceived of “Exit” and “Voice” as error-correction methods, ways that consumers pressure a firm whose products have fallen below the efficient price-quality frontier. Such firms cannot exist under perfect competition.
In development economics, Hirschman asserted the “inapplicability of orthodox monoeconomics to underdeveloped areas.” He did not offer an alternative body of theory, so much as speculations based on case studies. Accordingly Hirschman's work continues to find readers among social scientists outside of economics, but seldom appears on reading lists in economics Ph.D. courses. While opinions differ on how important Hirschman's work remains, the proof that he merits a lengthy scholarly biography lies in the reading of Jeremy Adelman's interesting and informative work.
Hirschman led a fascinating life—at least until he became a tenured economist—and Adelman's early chapters offer a vivid account reminiscent of Erik Larson's bestsellers. Born in Berlin during World War I (1915), Otto Albert Hirschmann grew up in an assimilated bourgeois Jewish household. (Later he reversed the order of his given names, and a U.S. immigration officer deleted the last letter of his family name.) As a teenager he became fluent in German, French, and English, later adding Italian and Spanish. At 17 he read Lenin and the Austro-Marxist Otto Bauer, but rejected Marxism and became a democratic-socialist activist. He enrolled at the University of Berlin just as the Nazis took power and started suppressing dissenters and Jews. He fled to Paris to study, and as a “Jew by decree” (p. 87) could not return to the University of Berlin. He came under the anti-dogmatic influence of his sister Ursula's new Italian husband, Eugenio Colorni, himself influenced by the classical liberal Benedetto Croce.
In 1935–1936, Hirschman studied at the LSE on a one-year fellowship. He took Abba Lerner's course, and visited Colorni's cousin Piero Sraffa. At a loss for what to do next, he traveled to Barcelona and took up arms to fight the fascists in the Spanish Civil War, acquiring physical and psychological scars. He moved to Italy, joining his sister and brother-in-law and earning a laurea degree from the University of Trieste.
Returning to Paris in 1938, Hirschman worked on an economic bulletin under the well-known economist Charles Rist. He enlisted in the French army just before the German invasion of Paris in May 1939. Obtaining papers identifying him as “Albert Hermant,” he fled into unoccupied southern France. In Marseilles, he joined the Emergency Rescue Committee, using his language skills and underground savvy to help Jews, artists, and dissidents escape France. When Hirschman himself had to flee, he hiked across the Pyrenees with bogus papers, one pair of socks, and a copy of Montaigne's Essais. He sailed from Lisbon to Jersey City with the help of the Rockefeller Foundation. He arrived stateside in January 1941, only 25-years old.
Securing a two-year Rockefeller fellowship at Berkeley, Hirschman met and married Sarah Chapiro, a Francophone Russian-Jewish émigré student. He befriended the Russian émigré economist Alexander Gerschenkron. In 1943 Hirschman enlisted in the U.S. Army. The OSS sent him as an interpreter to Algeria and Italy. In Rome he found and read a copy of Hayek's new work The Road to Serfdom. Adelman credits Hayek's influence for Hirschman's later antipathy toward comprehensive top-down development planning. Yet where Hayek emphasized property rights and rule of law as the foundations of a prosperous economy, Hirschman favored (piecemeal) development projects as the path to improved institutions.
Returning to the United States in late 1945, he was hired by Gerschenkron for the Federal Reserve Board's research staff to work on the Marshall Plan. From then on Hirschman's battles were intellectual, and the narrative downshifts into an academic-career biography. In 1952 Hirschman suddenly moved his family to Bogotá to work on a Colombian government project, where he began writing on development. Four years later he would just as suddenly “leap from utter obscurity … to the heart of the American academic establishment” (p. 327) with a visiting position at Yale University arranged by former Marshall Plan colleague Thomas Schelling. There Hirschman wrote his first important book in 1958, The Strategy of Economic Development. A regular faculty slot at Columbia University followed, where he wrote in 1963 Journeys Toward Progress. Thence to Harvard, where Gerschenkron (again) and Galbraith were keen to hire him, and in 1970 Hirschman produced his most celebrated work, Exit, Voice, and Loyalty. Being a “catastrophically bad teacher” (p. 419), he gladly moved to Princeton's Institute for Advanced Study (no teaching duties), where in 1977 he published The Passions and the Interests and in 1991 The Rhetoric of Reaction. The biography concludes just before Hirschman's death in December 2012.
Adelman shows a flair for biography, especially in the first half of the book, and clearly did remarkable detective work to piece together the details. He sagely tempers his enthusiasm for Hirschman's importance as a social scientist with the recognition that for many economists “there was no Hirschman theory, no model” (p. 654), no identifiable contribution to the normal-science progress of the discipline. As a non-economist, Adelman is less adroit in his exposition and commentary on economic theories, doctrines, and methods, but this is understandable.
