For students of the Seljuq period, this collection of scholarly papers is long overdue. Some pieces such as Bosworth's ‘Barbarian Incursions: The Coming of the Turks into the Islamic World’ which was first published in 1973 are well known and will have long been staples for any course on Seljuq history whereas Peter Golden's ‘Khazar Turkic Ghulâms in Caliphal Service’ is an interesting new addition to this subject. This collection forms a solid bank of knowledge and support for any researcher into or student of the early history of the Turks and their contacts with the Islamic world. Strangely for a book so closely associated with Clifford Bosworth, only one paper, ‘The Turks in the Islamic Lands up to the Mid-11th Century’ considers the Ghaznavids at any length.
Kaare Grønbech's ‘The Steppe Region in World History’ serves as an excellent platform from which to launch the following fifteen essays. The Eurasian nomad could roam “from Harbin in the east to Bucharest in the west” with no major geographical barriers to impede his passage. The grassy steppe lands stretching across Lake Baikal and the Carpathians provided the corridor along which generations of Turks have connected east with west but also provided the links with a variety of other tribes and peoples and different ecological and geological environments and climatic zones. K. de B. Codrington in Chapter Two examines how the region's physical nature is reflected in the movement of its people from the plains of India and the high plateaux of Iran to the steppes of Inner Asia crossing mountain ranges which have never acted as a barrier.
Tadeusz Kowalski introduces what is believed to be the oldest reference to the Turks in Arabic literature though he is quick to point out that the ancient verses in question do not add any dramatic information to the pool of knowledge already amassed over the centuries. Nöldeke has been able to date these verses of lament over the death of a Ghassānid prince to around 600 CE. Another verse is addressed to Qays b. Ma'dīkarib and can be dated between 575–580 CE. This short essay is of interest in itself and demonstrates that the Arabs of the time associated the Turks with people in the east notably in the region of Persia and Afghanistan. The verses mention Turks, Persians, and also Kabul by whom it is presumed Afghans are meant. In the next contribution, Chapter Five, Tadeusz turns to the Persian epic, the Shāhnāma, made famous through the pen of the eleventh century poet, Ferdowsī. It was during Ferdowsī's lifetime that the Turks were becoming associated with the peoples of Turan, arch rivals of their foes south of the Oxus or Amū Daryā, the Iranians. Ferdowsī assumed that the battles and conflicts which were then taking place in the region were merely a continuation of the ancient rivalries which had beset the region for centuries and his choice of various Turkish clan names was quite random and bore no basis on historical truth or relevance. Tadeusz concludes that a Turkologist seeking knowledge of primitive Turkish culture would be disappointed after studying Ferdowsī's Shāhnāma.
The Khazars have attracted a great deal of attention in recent years as the recently published second edition of Kevin Allen Brook's The Jews of Khazaria attests. The Khazar ancestry of European Jewry, the Ashkenazim, has attracted controversy ever since the research of Douglas Dunlop focused on the origins of Eastern European Jews. Peter Golden's paper in the present volume, however, is concerned with their role in the ‘Abbasid capital rather than with their eighth century conversion. With the emergence in the early eighth century of the Bulghar khanate and the Khazar confederation, military clashes with the conquering Arab armies of Islam were inevitable. The Bulghars were centred on the middle Volga, described in detail by the Arab explorer, Ibn Fa'lān, whereas the Khazars occupied lands between their capital, Atil, at the mouth of the Volga and the Black Sea, north of the Caucasus. The years between 642 and 737 which ended with a Khazar defeat by the Omayyad armies, were filled with warfare and armed conflict. The resulting toll was high in not only casualties but in slaves who formed the commercial basis of the emerging peace. The Khazar legacy to the early Islamic world was a human one and even after 737 when trade replaced warfare, a principal component of that trade was slaves harvested from the western Eurasian steppes including south Russia. Peter Golden's paper explores the nature of the services provided by the Khazar ghulāms to the ‘Abbasid court.
R.N. Frye and R.P. Blake introduce a translation of a hitherto unknown part of Ibn Fadlan's Risala. The importance of this tenth century text lies in the light it casts on trade between Khwarazm and the Volga region and commerce in general between Europe and Asia which reached a peak during this period. Claude Cahen also investigates the early years of these northern regions in his investigations into the origins of the Seljuqs as revealed in the pages of the Malik-nāma, an early Seljuq non-extant source utilised by Bar Hebraeus and Ibn al-Athīr among others. The text is mainly concerned with the early history of the Seljuq clan as represented in the entourage of Alp Arslan. The biblical names of the early Seljuqid nobles, Mikhā‘īl, Isrā‘īl, Mūsā, Dā‘ūd, and Yūsuf led to speculation of Nestorian or even Jewish family connections. However Cahen concludes that in the absence of any other evidence there is no reason to doubt the wholly Muslim nature of the early clan. Such biblical names were generally popular and other examples exist of similarly named Turks who were indubitably Muslim. The Malik-nama portrays Dukak, the father of Seljuq, as the ancestor of the dynasty and if not Muslim himself as sympathetic to Muslims and opposed to attacking them. Bar Hebraeus's story of the conflict at the Khazar court between the Queen and Seljuq originated here and the history chronicles Seljuq's subsequent move with 100 horsemen, 15,000 camels, and 5,000 sheep into the border regions of Muslim Transoxiana. The Malik-nama claims that the Seljuq underwent conversion at this point and henceforth directed his energies into fighting the infidels and liberating Muslims from paying tribute. Claude Cahen details the later Ghaznavid, Arab and other historians’ indebtedness to this early chronicle and considers other early sources of early Seljuq history. The paper is not only an important historiographical study but a careful, comparative assessment of the Seljuqs’ origins and rise to power.
Bosworth and Gerard Clauson's study of al-Xwārazmī's writings focuses on Turkish titles and old tribal names which adds to the debate over Turkish penetration of Khurasan and Transoxiana before the establishment of the Samanids as is forcibly argued by Richard Frye and Aydin Sayili in their ‘Turks in the Middle East before the Saljuqs’. Whether the Turkish presence was sporadic or amounted to penetration and what exactly constitutes a Turk are all elements in the argument which is also examined in Bosworth's ‘The Turks in the Islamic Lands up to the Mid-Eleventh Century’ and his ‘Barbaric Incursions . . .’.
It is the Caliph Muta'im (r.833–842) who is frequently credited with the most extensive employment of Turkish slaves in his praetorian guard whom he quartered in his new capital, Samarra. The role which the caliph played in his increasingly Mamluk dominated state is studied by Osman Ismail in his paper on ‘Muta'im and the Turks’ and his ‘Era of Isolation’. With his move to Samarra, the ‘Abbasid caliphate began to resemble more a regional ruler than leader of the hosts of Islam and, isolated among his Mamluks, deprived of outside support he increasingly became a prisoner of his own troops. Ismail adds to the subject of Samarra in a later chapter which examines the city itself and its actual founding. With the caliphate under the domination of the Mamluk soldiery most of the affairs of state fell into the hands of the secretaries, traditional rivals of the men of learning upon whom the caliph would traditionally have sought support.
Continuing the theme of military slaves, the institution which initially opened the door for Turkish domination of the Islamic world, C.I. Beckwith examines the ‘Central Asian guard corps’ which was quickly assimilated into ‘Islamic’ practice and provides an example of the ‘Central-Asianisation’ as opposed to Persianisation of the caliphate. This was a process, begun with the early ‘Abbasids and re-vitalised by al-Ma'mūn, which produced such figures as al-Khwārazmī, al-Farghānī, al-Farābī, Ibn Sīnā, al-Ghazzālī, and al-Bīrūnī.
Claude Cahen closes this absorbing collection of papers with an examination of the other Turkish tribes who moved south and westward at the time of the Seljuq ascendancy. It is the nature and make up of these Turkoman tribes and their role in the eleventh century migration into western Persia and Anatolia that interests Cahen.
Bosworth has put together a comprehensive collection of papers covering a wide time span of scholarship and he has provided a comprehensive introduction which ties in and contextualises all the papers in his compilation. The introduction puts the various essays into a chronological and thematic frame but goes beyond their specific topics and in so doing provides the reader with far more insight into the broader world of the Eurasian steppe lands and the migration of its people into the sedentary world. In addition the in-roads of Islam and its ambassadors among the Turks and the lands of Turan is revealed in its many intricacies. This is a book for the specialist and for the student seeking some insight into the background of the Turks and the Seljuqs in particular. Though some of the papers date back decades their ideas have withstood subsequent scholarship and they are as relevant now as when they first appeared. This book will doubtless become a fixture of any library, public or private, aspiring to cover the history of the Turks.
