Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:01:41.074Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Objective barriers to the transport of dynamically active vector fields

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 October 2020

George Haller*
Affiliation:
Institute for Mechanical Systems, ETH Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland
Stergios Katsanoulis
Affiliation:
Institute for Mechanical Systems, ETH Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland
Markus Holzner
Affiliation:
WSL Swiss Federal Research Institute, Birmensdorf, Switzerland
Bettina Frohnapfel
Affiliation:
Institute of Fluid Mechanics, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Karlsruhe, Germany
Davide Gatti
Affiliation:
Institute of Fluid Mechanics, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Karlsruhe, Germany
*
†Email address for correspondence: georgehaller@ethz.ch

Abstract

We derive a theory for material surfaces that maximally inhibit the diffusive transport of a dynamically active vector field, such as the linear momentum, the angular momentum or the vorticity, in general fluid flows. These special material surfaces (Lagrangian active barriers) provide physics-based, observer-independent boundaries of dynamically active coherent structures. We find that Lagrangian active barriers evolve from invariant surfaces of an associated steady and incompressible barrier equation, whose right-hand side is the time-averaged pullback of the viscous stress terms in the evolution equation for the dynamically active vector field. Instantaneous limits of these barriers mark objective Eulerian active barriers to the short-term diffusive transport of the dynamically active vector field. We obtain that in unsteady Beltrami flows, Lagrangian and Eulerian active barriers coincide exactly with purely advective transport barriers bounding observed coherent structures. In more general flows, active barriers can be identified by applying Lagrangian coherent structure (LCS) diagnostics, such as the finite-time Lyapunov exponent and the polar rotation angle, to the appropriate active barrier equation. In comparison to their passive counterparts, these active LCS diagnostics require no significant fluid particle separation and hence provide substantially higher-resolved LCS and Eulerian coherent structure boundaries from temporally shorter velocity data sets. We illustrate these results and their physical interpretation on two-dimensional, homogeneous, isotropic turbulence and on a three-dimensional turbulent channel flow.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Vorticity and linear momentum, normalized by their maxima at an arbitrary time instance in a decaying planar channel flow shown in figure 18: (a) normalized vorticity and its observed transport barriers, (b) normalized momentum and its observed transport barriers, (c) prior prediction for vorticity-transport barriers and (d) prior prediction for momentum-transport barriers. These plots remain steady in time, with all horizontal lines (some shown dotted) acting as barriers to the vertical redistribution of the vorticity and linear momentum. Also shown are prior predictions for perfect barriers to vorticity transport in this flow by Haller, Karrasch & Kogelbauer (2019) on the left and for perfect barriers to momentum transport by Meyers & Meneveau (2013) on the right. The latter barrier trajectories are released uniformly across the entry cross-section of the channel. See appendix A for details.

Figure 1

Figure 2.The normal vector field $\boldsymbol {n}_{0}(\boldsymbol {x}_{0})$ of any initial material barrier $\mathcal {M}_{0}$ must be orthogonal to the barrier vector field $\boldsymbol {b}_{t_{0}}^{t_{1}}(\boldsymbol {x}_{0})$. Therefore, $\mathcal {M}_{0}$ must be a 2-D invariant manifold of the vector field $\boldsymbol {b}_{t_{0}}^{t_{1}}=\overline {\det \boldsymbol {\nabla } \boldsymbol {F}_{t_{0}}^{t}(\boldsymbol {F}_{t_{0}}^{t})^{*}\boldsymbol {h}_{vis}}$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Possible geometries of material barriers to diffusive transport: (a) 2-D stable and unstable manifolds of fixed points, (b) 2-D stable and unstable manifolds of periodic orbits and (c) 2-D invariant tori. Curves with arrows indicate qualitative sketches of trajectories of the barrier equation (4.1), for which these barriers are structurally stable, 2-D invariant manifolds.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Three non-objective diagnostics ((a) sectional streamline plots, (b) the vorticity norm and (c) the $Q$-parameter) for the unsteady ABC flow (7.24a,b) with $A=\sqrt {3}$, $B=\sqrt {2}$ and $C=1$, at time $t=0$. All three plots remain the same for all times, because the velocity field is directionally steady. Also shown in (d) are three objective, active Poincaré maps computed for the associated barrier equations. The Lagrangian and Eulerian barrier equations for this flow are given by $\boldsymbol {x}_{0}^{\prime }=\boldsymbol {u}_{0}(\boldsymbol {x}_{0})$ by Theorem 7.5, both for momentum and vorticity. Black dots on the active Poincaré sections indicate repeated return locations of barrier trajectories launched from the same section. Intersections of 2-D, toroidal transport barriers with the three Poincaré sections are visible as invariant curves of these Poincaré maps. Outermost members of these torus families define objective coherent vortex boundaries.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Passive and vorticity-based active versions of the FTLE and PRA diagnostics for the unsteady ABC flow (7.24a,b), computed over the same time interval ($[t_{0},t_{1}]=[0,5]$) and with the same spatial resolution ($300^{3}$ grid points in the spatial domain $[0,2\pi ]^{3}$): (a) $\mathrm {FTLE}_0^{5} (\boldsymbol {x}_0)$, (b) $\mathrm {aFTLE}_{0,5}^{10} (\boldsymbol {x}_0; \boldsymbol {\omega })$, (c) $\mathrm {aFTLE}_{0,5}^{15} (\boldsymbol {x}_0; \boldsymbol {\omega })$, (d) $\mathrm {PRA}_0^{5} (\boldsymbol {x}_0)$, (e) $\mathrm {aPRA}_{0,5}^{15} (\boldsymbol {x}_0; \boldsymbol {\omega })$ and (f) $\mathrm {aPRA}_{0,5}^{50} (\boldsymbol {x}_0; \boldsymbol {\omega })$. Two values for the barrier time $s$ were selected to illustrate the increasing spatial resolution and convergence of hyperbolic barriers by the aFTLE and of elliptic barriers by the aPRA under increasing $s$-times. With the exception of the passive PRA, all diagnostics shown here are objective.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Comparison of the $t=0$ instantaneous limits of the passive FTLE, the aFTLE with respect to $\rho \boldsymbol {u}$ with $s=0.05$ and the aFTLE with respect to $\boldsymbol {{\omega }}$ with $s=0.15$ in our 2-D turbulence example: (a) $\mathrm {FTLE}_0^{0} (\boldsymbol {x})$, (b) $\mathrm {aFTLE}_{0,0}^{0.05} (\boldsymbol {x}; \rho \boldsymbol {u})$ and (c) $\mathrm {aFTLE}_{0,0}^{0.15} (\boldsymbol {x}; \boldsymbol {\omega })$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Comparison between the instantaneous limit of the passive FTLE (PRA) and the instantaneous limit of the momentum-based aFTLE (PRA) fields for $s=0.05$ and for $s=0.15$ in one of the vortical regions of our 2-D turbulence example at $t=0$: (a) $\mathrm {FTLE}_0^{0} (\boldsymbol {x})$, (b) $\mathrm {aFTLE}_{0,0}^{0.05} (\boldsymbol {x}; \rho \boldsymbol {u})$, (c) $\mathrm {aFTLE}_{0,0}^{0.15} (\boldsymbol {x}; \rho \boldsymbol {u})$, (d) $\mathrm {PRA}_{0}^{0} (\boldsymbol {x})$, (e) $\mathrm {aPRA}_{0,0}^{0.1} (\boldsymbol {x}; \rho \boldsymbol {u})$ and (f) $\mathrm {aPRA}_{0,0}^{0.15} (\boldsymbol {x}; \rho \boldsymbol {u})$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Comparison between the passive FTLE (PRA) and the momentum- and vorticity-based aFTLE (aPRA): (a) $\mathrm {FTLE}_0^{25} (\boldsymbol {x}_0)$, (b) $\mathrm {aFTLE}_{0,25}^{0.35} (\boldsymbol {x}_0; \rho \boldsymbol {u})$, (c) $\mathrm {aFTLE}_{0,25}^{0.05} (\boldsymbol {x}_0; \boldsymbol {\omega })$, (d) $\mathrm {PRA}_0^{25} (\boldsymbol {x}_0)$, (e) $\mathrm {aPRA}_{0,25}^{0.35} (\boldsymbol {x}_0; \rho \boldsymbol {u})$ and (f) $\mathrm {aPRA}_{0,25}^{0.05} (\boldsymbol {x}_0; \boldsymbol {\omega })$. All computations were performed over the time interval $[t_{0},t_{1}]=[0,25]$ on the domain $[2.8,4.9]\times [1,3]$.

Figure 8

Algorithm 1Coherent Lagrangian and Eulerian vortex boundaries for two-dimensional flows

Figure 9

Figure 9.Evolution of an extracted active material barrier (red) to the diffusive transport of momentum in (a) the Eulerian and (b) the Lagrangian frame, superimposed on the distribution of the norm of the linear momentum. This barrier was identified as a level curve of the Hamiltonian $H_{t_0}^{t_1}(\boldsymbol {x}_{0})=\nu \rho \, \overline {\omega (\boldsymbol {F}_{t_{0}}^{t}(\boldsymbol {x}_{0}),t)}$. Black curve indicates an elliptic LCS extracted as a level curve of the passive PRA, launched from the highlighted point of the active barrier. (c) The instantaneous viscous forces (normalized by $\rho \nu$) acting on the evolving barrier.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Sketch of the computational molecule utilized for the computation of the active barrier field $\boldsymbol {b}_{t_0}^{t_1}$. The large circle denotes the Lagrangian tracer at the centre of the molecule, where the vector field $\boldsymbol {h}_{vis}$ is computed. The cross denotes the further six tracers utilized to compute $\boldsymbol {\nabla }\boldsymbol {F}_{t_0}^{t_1}$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Comparison between the instantaneous limit of (a,d) the passive FTLE, (b,e) the aFTLE with respect to $\rho \boldsymbol {u}$ and (c,f) the aFTLE with respect to $\boldsymbol {\omega }$ at $t=0$ in a cross-sectional plane at $x/h = 2\pi$. The panels (d–f) magnify the region denoted with a rectangle in panels (a–c). All computations in the figure were performed on the same snapshot of the velocity field at $t=0$.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Comparison between the instantaneous limit of (a,d) the passive PRA (which is identically zero), (b,e) the aPRA with respect to $\rho \boldsymbol {u}$ and (c,f) the aPRA with respect to $\boldsymbol {\omega }$ at $t=0$ in a cross-sectional plane at $x/h = 2\pi$. The panels (d–f) magnify the region denoted with a rectangle in panels (a–c). All computations in the figure were performed on the same snapshot of the velocity field at $t=0$.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Eulerian active barriers of (a) $\rho \boldsymbol {u}$ and (b) $\boldsymbol {\omega }$ at $t=0$ in a cross-sectional plane located at $x/h = 2\pi$. The colour map shows the respective aFTLE fields, the vectors show the cross-sectional components of the underlying active barrier field, while the red lines are level-set curves $\lambda _{2}^{+}(\boldsymbol {x},t)=-0.015$ of the Eulerian vortex identification criterion proposed by Jeong et al. (1997).

Figure 14

Figure 14.Passive backward $\mathrm {FTLE}_0^{-3.75}(\boldsymbol {x}_0 )$ in a cross-sectional plane at $x/h = 2\pi$. The right panel magnifies the region denoted with a rectangle in the left panel.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Comparison between (a,d) the passive FTLE, (b,e) the aFTLE with respect to $\rho \boldsymbol {u}$ and (c,f) the aFTLE with respect to $\boldsymbol {\omega }$ in a cross-sectional plane at $x/h = 2\pi$. The integration interval is for all cases between $t_0=0$ and $t_1=3.75$. The panels (d–f) magnify the region denoted with a rectangle in panels (a–c).

Figure 16

Figure 16.Comparison between (a,d) the passive PRA, (b,e) the aPRA with respect to $\rho \boldsymbol {u}$ and (c,f) the aPRA with respect to $\boldsymbol {\omega }$ in a cross-sectional plane at $x/h = 2\pi$. The integration interval is for all cases between $t_0=0$ and $t_1=3.75$. The panels (d–f) magnify the region denoted with a rectangle in panels (a–c).

Figure 17

Figure 17.Material active barriers of (a) $\rho \boldsymbol {u}$ and (b) $\boldsymbol {\omega }$ at $t=0$ in a cross-sectional plane located at $x/h = 2\pi$ and for an integration interval between $t_0=0$ and $t_1=3.75$. The colormap shows the respective aFTLE fields, the vectors show the cross-sectional components of the underlying active barrier field, while the red lines are level-set curves $\lambda _{2}^{+}(\boldsymbol {x},t)=-0.015$ of the Eulerian vortex identification criterion proposed by Jeong et al. (1997) at the instant $t_0=0$.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Decaying planar Navier–Stokes flow in a channel with no-slip walls at $x_{2}= \pm \frac {1}{4}$.

Haller et al. Supplementary Material

Computation of Eulerian active barriers to momentum transport from aFTLE for under increasing barrier time s in the turbulent channel flow example

Download Haller et al. Supplementary Material(Video)
Video 2.9 MB

Haller et al. Supplementary Material

Computation of Eulerian active barriers to vorticity transport from aFTLE for under increasing barrier time s in the turbulent channel flow example

Download Haller et al. Supplementary Material(Video)
Video 3 MB

Haller et al. Supplementary Material

A moving cross section of Eulerian, momentum-based aFTLE along the channel, with level surfaces of the lambda2 parameter superimposed

Download Haller et al. Supplementary Material(Video)
Video 36 MB

Haller et al. Supplementary Material

A moving cross section of Eulerian, vorticity-based aFTLE along the channel, with level surfaces of the lambda2 parameter superimposed
Download Haller et al. Supplementary Material(Video)
Video 34.5 MB