No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
The 1990s witnessed the publication of several books that presented useful surveys of the history of Ottoman Jewry. This book, a solid work that relies on a wide array of rabbinc sources and academic studies, focuses on one community during a specific period, which allows the author to present a study that is both comprehensive and rich in detail. Minna Rozen methodically examines every conceivable aspect of Jewish life in Istanbul. The Jewish community of Istanbul was the most important in the Ottoman Empire, and what took place there reflected on Jewish life throughout the realm.
It was also uniquely diverse. The indigenous Greek-speaking Byzantine Jews, the Romaniots, included large numbers forced to resettle in Istanbul as part of Mehmed the Conqueror's policy to repopulate the city. Throughout the late 15th and 16th centuries, large numbers of Jews began arriving from the Iberian peninsula (Sephardim), Italy, the German lands (Ashkenazim), Hungary, and other European countries. These immigrants formed congregations based on the country, or even city, of their origin.
Chapter 1 describes the Ottoman conquest of Constantinople. During the heat of the battle, Ottoman forces did not distinguish between Greeks and Jews, and their fate was alike. Nevertheless, over time a tradition emerged that the Jews, unlike the Greeks, had not resisted and were therefore entitled to certain privileges in accordance with Islamic law. This was the basis for several decrees that permitted Jews to keep their synagogues, repair them, and even construct new ones.
In Chapter 2, Rozen supports the conventional view that the Ottomans were generally flexible and pragmatic in applying traditional restrictions of the Pact of Umar. This chapter contains a lengthy discussion of the various taxes that Jews had to pay and the manner of their collection.
Chapters 3 through 5 discuss related issues of migration, settlement, and demographic trends. While the information is generally solid, Table 1, listing the Jewish population of Istanbul from 1477 to 1688, does not distinguish between official Ottoman counts and estimates. Thus, the figure for 1535, which lists 8,070 Jewish households, is totally inconsistent with later figures that place the number of households between 2,000 and 2,500. Rozen's hypothesis that at the beginning of the 16th century Istanbul “was only a way station for immigrants who subsequently went to other places” (p. 53) does not concur with what we know about patterns of Jewish migration from the Iberian peninsula.
Chapters 6 and 7 discuss the internal structure of the Jewish community and the relations among the different groups. From the mid-15th through the 16th century, the Romaniots were united under one rabbi, whereas the Sephardim had a collective leadership; their distinguished rabbis would meet on an ad hoc basis to decide important issues. In matters pertaining to the entire Jewish population, joint meetings, including Romaniot and Sephardic rabbis, would be held. Over time there was growing integration between Romaniots and Sephardim, especially intermarriage among economic elites, and the defection of individuals to other congregations. This led to a growing Sephardization of the Romaniot population—interesting since the Sephardim were greatly outnumbered by the Romaniots.
Chapter 8 discusses the family, covering a wide range of topics—marriage, divorce, custody and education of children, inheritance, and the different customs practiced by various groups. These differences could be considerable. For example,while Ashkenazi custom absolutely forbade polygamous marriages, Iberian and Romaniot traditions permitted them. Most Jewish families in 16th-century Istanbul were monogamous. However, Iberian and Romaniot men whose first wife could not bear children were inclined to marry second wives. In Istanbul, Ashkenazi men could under special circumstances maintain a polygamous family. A full third of the book's text, this chapter contains much new data and offers numerous examples derived from the rabbinic literature. However, it tends to digress into lengthy discussions of the technicalities of Jewish law in far greater detail than is necessary for a work in social history.
Chapters 9 through 11 deal with issues of social stratification, economic activity, and culture. Among Istanbul Jews, social standing was determined by proximity to the Ottoman court (this could also lead to disaster), wealth, and ancestry. Unlike the Ashkenazi of Central and Eastern Europe, the Jews of Istanbul respected rabbinic scholarship only up to a point. This, argues Rozen, was influenced by the strong entrepreneurial spirit that dominated important segments of society. Nevertheless, the wealthy took pride in supporting schools and charitable institutions, which helped turn Istanbul into a major center of Jewish scholarship and printing. With the help of Ottoman authorities, Jewish merchants attained the pinnacle of economic success in the mid-16th century.
Chapter 12, one of the most interesting, discusses Jewish relations with the general society. Romaniot and European Jews were unaccustomed to the strict segregation of women. However, influenced by dominant Muslim culture, similar behavioral patterns were adopted, although Jewish women continued to enjoy greater of freedom of movement than their Muslim neighbors, which allowed them to engage in a variety of economic activities. But since life revolved around the family, segregation of the sexes strengthened the segregation of society in general by religious and ethnic groups. Nevertheless, the author describes numerous points of contact between individuals across religious and ethnic lines necessitated primarily by economic activity but also by a shared interest in material culture, art, and entertainment.
One would hope to find at the end of such a richly detailed work some discussion of the broader meaning of the information assembled here. In a five-page “Conclusion” Rozen argues that the end of Süleiman the Magnificent's reign marked the end of the “Golden Age” of Ottoman Jewry. This seems rather arbitrary for a work that deals with broad social phenomena, especially since some of the best-known Ottoman Jewish personalities—Joseph Nasi, Solomon ibn Ya'ish, and Solomon Ashkenazi—attained the pinnacle of their careers after Süleiman's death. And despite the title's dates, the main focus of the book is on the entire 16th century, with substantial forays into the 17th century and later.
An appendix of some sixty pages of translated excerpts from several responsa collections is a welcome addition. The responsa literature is a major source for this study, and the excerpts give the reader a flavor of this genre as well as concrete examples of the wealth of subjects with which it is concerned. Although the style of this work tends to be argumentative and not always easy to follow, as a volume intended primarily for specialists it constitutes a major contribution to Jewish and Ottoman social history.