This book aims to show the relevance of social class for understanding and practising community development. On one level, this relevance seems rather obvious: in that community development has traditionally focused on communities that are perceived to need development, and these communities are those that are working class or poor or oppressed in some respect (e.g. on grounds of race or caste or national minority status). On another level, however, an emphasis on community has tended to obscure or downplay the realities of class divisions and inequality within contemporary global society, and to underestimate the barriers that such divisions present to community development generally (however this is understood).
In their introduction, the editors accept that the concept of community is ‘inherently ambivalent and problematic’ (p.11), but do not attempt to solve this problem, and similarly they leave the meaning of development unclear. They seem to support a Marxist interpretation of class (in preference to a Weberian one), but do not explain, for example, how capitalism produces classes of owners and non-owners of the means of production, or how these classes come to be embedded in different types of communities. They refer to feminist critiques of Marxism and to the concept of intersectionality but do not expand on how Marxist feminists and intersectionality theorists have improved our understanding of the nature of class and class struggles. They call for ‘a clear class analysis’ (p.13), but I cannot find one here.
The chapters by Minnite and Piven, and by Craig, do provide some class analysis, describing community development (in the US and UK respectively) as largely a professional practice, with the implication that community development workers are in a different class position from those whom they are typically paid to help. They contrast this professional practice with more politicised practice such as Occupy Wall Street and certain kinds of advocacy work and political education, and social movements such as the US civil rights movement (Minnite and Piven) and the labour movement, the women's movement and the anti-racist movement (Craig). Their understanding of community development, however, is so broad that it could include just about any kind of grassroots collective action. Consequently, they are unable to provide a general assessment of what such work has achieved or can achieve. Although sympathetic to Marxism, they do not engage with current Marxist debates on class and state power.
The other 12 chapters mostly present substantive case studies of grassroots collective action. Many of these highlight the importance of links between workers’ struggles and community action, particularly for improving the environment and working conditions (Barca and Leonardi on action against an environmentally harmful steel plant in Taranto, Italy; Franklin on achieving green jobs programmes in US cities). Mayo, Tucker and Danaher describe two contrasting models of such community unionism in Britain: the UNISON union's model of engaging with communities, to build alliances between providers and users of public services, and the UNITE union's model of extending union membership to wider communities, especially to the disenfranchised and disengaged. In practice, tensions exist between the emphasis on democratic decision-making and accountability within trade unions (and also political parties) and on direct action in community organisations. It is not clear, however, how these tensions have been resolved – if, indeed, they have been resolved. Geddes shows how trade union and indigenous community organising in Bolivia coalesced into a single force that was strong and popular enough to transcend such divisions and take power at a national level. This does not mean that the struggle is over, however, as Bolivia's Movimiento al Socialismo in government exhibits sexist attitudes, chaotic and sometimes counter-productive decision-making, creeping authoritarianism and accommodation to international capital. Geddes, however, does not seem to recognise that class struggle occurs within governmental institutions, tends to reflect class struggle more generally, and its outcomes cannot be predicted with any certainty (for example, he contrasts a ‘fully bourgeois state’ with a ‘hollowed-out shell’, but surely a fully bourgeois state is precisely one that is completely hollowed-out?). Martínez-Torres and Firmiano document the history of the landless workers’ movement in Brazil, which brought together inhabitants of favelas with displaced peasants. Their case study of a land occupation showed that it was successful but only after being evicted many times and after public exposure of the environmental damage that the landowner was inflicting on the area. Lessons could be learned from this about the importance of cooperation (e.g. in agrarian communes) and the balance to be struck between cooperation and confrontation.
Two chapters on India focus on caste: Shahid and Jha's study of the Balmiki community (manual scavengers) and Adhikari and Taylor's three examples of community learning. Community development has a bad reputation in India because of its association with colonialism and its wilful ignorance of the plight of oppressed caste groups. It is not clear, however, how Balmiki women came to be liberated from manual scavenging or how manual scavenging has ceased to be ‘hegemonic’, if indeed it has done so. Adhikari and Taylor show how a dalit community has been mobilised through education volunteers, female participation in schools has been increased through the provision of residential schools, and education has been embedded in wider struggles of an Adivasi community.
Kurantowicz and Noworolnik-Mastalska summarise social changes in Poland since 1945 and identify in particular the growth of inequality in more recent years and the emergence of a new class structure, which they say (but do not show) is different from those in the West. They point to the damaging effects of Polish emigration on exporting communities (p.146). They identify three ‘paradoxes’ of work activation projects, which seem rather to be community development failures, in that work opportunities were lacking, communities were not developed, and the lives of participants were not significantly improved. It is not clear, however, what (if anything) has been or indeed can be learned from such failures – the analysis in terms of Gaventa's three forms of power is superficial and does not sufficiently address the political realities of the neoliberalisation project in Poland.
Newman's case study of ActionAid International is the only one in the book that focuses on an international NGO, the others all being concerned with national and local organisations and movements. It is also the only one that critically examines the class position of the staff involved. From its beginnings in delivering essential services to those in need, ActionAid shifted in 1998 to a rights-based approach, which emphasised working with poor people on a global scale to demand services from their governments. Unfortunately, however, poor people were not able to participate on this scale or to influence their governments to any significant extent. Consequently, ActionAid staff, increasingly out of touch with the grassroots, made decisions on their behalf, which did not necessarily correspond with the needs or wishes of those they intended to help. Ultimately, ActionAid International failed to reflect on the class character of its own organisation and practices, and it is not clear from this chapter what it has achieved politically.
Fung provides a searing indictment of the Hong Kong regime for its neoliberalist failure to take community development seriously. He also criticises community development workers in Hong Kong for ignoring the dynamics of global finance capital in which Hong Kong is a key player – dynamics that have produced worsening social inequality and declining welfare for the poorest communities.
Taylor and Wilson provide an interesting discussion of the UK government's policy on community organising. It is not clear, however, how much has been achieved by this programme. They suggest that its success should be judged on the basis of the 4,500 local leaders who it has recruited and trained (p.224), but surely we need to know something about what these leaders have actually done?
Overall the book succeeds in its aims, with important insights and analyses in some of the case studies, which will be of interest to activists and policy-makers as well as students and community development practitioners.
