America's Gilded Age is also, confusingly, the period of Reconstruction and unfortunately those two histories seldom get discussed together. Gilded Age historians favor stories of the rise of big business, women's suffrage, and the birth of modern labor politics. In those narratives we get conflict, capital formation, and excellent strikes. Reconstruction, meanwhile, is often told as a story of sharecropping, political betrayals, and Klan violence. Richard White shows beautifully how those two storylines constantly overlap. His beautifully written synthesis must break the storyteller's rule of obsessive focus (thank God) while bringing us back to Chekhov's rule: a rifle on the mantelpiece in the first act is sure to be fired later in the play.
Gilded Age shots are just as likely to be fired in Reconstruction. The Panic of 1873, for example, is often used by Gilded Age historians to describe the boom/bust cycle in big business, but as White shows the panic actually started in Europe and served as the pretext for railroad barons’ support for ending Reconstruction in Congress. The Great Strike of 1877, a Gilded Age staple, had everything to do with Southern Democrats’ failure to pass appropriations for the Army because of Reconstruction. Mill towns in the South—usually told as the story of the collapse of Southern agriculture—are, as White shows, southern boosters’ answer to the massive immigration-fueled industrialization of the upper Midwest. Every business history tells the story of Carnegie's coke furnaces, but as White shows it is the other Coke—Atlanta-based Coca-Cola—that better captures the rise of the modern corporation, commercialized leisure, and franchise-based distribution.
Of course, having western historian Richard White as our interlocutor we can be assured that at long last a history of both Reconstruction and the Gilded Age will not slight the West. The war on the Nez Perce, as he shows, partakes of the same violence as the Great Strike. Urbanization, so often told through New York, is better told in his hands through the emergence of San Francisco and Chicago. The Knights of Labor, seemingly at the vanguard of interracial equality everywhere else, look disturbingly xenophobic in California.
What is lovely about this book, too, are the pen portraits of people: Henry Turner of the African Methodist Episcopal Church; the novelist Hamlin Garland; railroad barons Tom Scott and Collis Potter Huntington; Standing Bear of the Poncas; along with Sarah Dudley Pettey, opinion columnist for the AME Zion newspaper. White's novelistic eye for detail turns battles over subsidies and graft in Congress into real stories about the future of the Republic.
Teachers looking for details for lectures, scholars looking for the latest research, and general readers wanting to understand this crucial period in American history will all find this latest Oxford history rewarding. This may be the most comprehensive and readable work ever on the complex period between 1865 and 1896. Thankfully the author disguises that complexity from us with all the tricks of the writers’ trade. White's vignettes, like Chekhov's rifle, seem to begin as clever set pieces, but you can be assured that each vignette serves a purpose in helping us understand the intertwined fates of Reconstruction and the Gilded Age.
