In our article entitled “The Political Science 400: A 20-Year Update” (PS, January 2007, 133–45), we presented the names and total citation counts (1960–2005) of political science faculty employed (ca. 2002) in U.S. Ph.D.-granting institutions who were among the 400 most cited in their cohort or subfield. We recognize the very important nature of our data for individual scholars and the institutions at which they teach, and we apologize to those colleagues whose citation counts were misreported, especially to those few whose counts were off by a very large amount. Yet, given that nearly 4,000 political scientists are employed in a Ph.D.-granting institution in the U.S., and given the numerous data limitations associated with using the Web of Science search engine (as we explained in the lengthy methodological appendix to our article), while we worked as hard as we could to prevent errors, having some errors in our data set was virtually unavoidable.
We would like to thank all of our fellow colleagues who sent us substantive feedback on this article and helped us identify errors in our data, either about their own rankings or about those of colleagues: D. Scott Bennett, Paul Brace, Russell Dalton, Morris Fiorina, Melinda Gann Hall, Torben Iversen, Robert Keohane, Rick Lau, Kathryn Lavelle, Matthew McCubbins, Kathleen McGraw, Paul Peterson, Bruce Russett, Norman Schofield, Randolph M. Siverson, and Stephen Wasby. Reported corrections are shown in the revised data set, located at: www.socsci.uci.edu/∼bgrofman/. In this addendum, however, we only list those corrections that affect the actual tables presented in the original article, and those due to errors in our coding. These corrections include scholars whose names and information should have been included but were not originally listed in one or more of the original tables, as well as those scholars whose ranking information was incorrectly presented in our January article.
Corrections to the citation counts for the following scholars affected their placement in the top 400. We would especially like to apologize to these authors (and their departments) for our inadvertent errors. The most egregious errors in our citation counts were due to misspelling/multiple spellings of the scholar's name: usually due to middle initials or hyphenated names.
- Bruce Bueno de Mesquita: Updated citation count is 1,852. Bueno de Mesquita should be ranked as #9 in the 1970–1974 cohort in Table 1, #10 in International Relations in Table 4, and #52 overall.
- Morris Fiorina: Updated citation count is 3,190. Fiorina should be ranked as #3 in the 1970–1974 cohort in Table 1, ranked as #4 in American Politics in Table 4, and ranked as #20 overall.
- Richard Lau: Updated count is 1,655. Lau should be ranked as #7 in the 1975–1979 cohort in Table 1, #6 in Methodology in Table 4, and #67 overall.
- Kathleen McGraw: Updated count is 789. McGraw should be listed as #6 in the 1985–1989 cohort and #18 in the Top 40 women in the PS 400 in Table 5.
- Bruce Russett: Tables 1 and 4 should list the total citation count as 3,668, which puts him at #13 in overall citation counts.
- Randolph M. Siverson: Updated citation count is 762. Siverson is among the PS 400.
- Aaron Wildavsky: Updated count is 4,061. Wildavsky should be ranked as #3 in the 1955–1959 cohort in Table 1, #3 in American Politics in Table 4, and #10 overall.
We should note that corrections about matters not due to our coding errors did not generate re-ranking. In particular, some scholars, by going back and individually hand coding citation data, offered us updated citation counts that included citations for co-authored articles and books that we had not included in our citation counts. In this addendum, we do not report changes in counts based on corrections for underreported citation counts due to secondary or tertiary named co-authorship, since this was a systematic problem associated with the Web of Science search engine and did not reflect coding errors on our part. We believe that, despite the errors introduced by omissions of some co-authored papers and books, it would not have been fair to have corrected for co-authorship for some authors but not for others in recompiling our rankings. Due to the size of the data set, the hand coding of individual c.v.s that would have been required to make co-authorship corrections for all authors was well beyond our abilities. Nonetheless, we are happy to add to the data set posted on our web site citations to co-authored work for any authors who choose to compile such data for themselves or for their colleagues (and we have done so for those who have already offered us a corrected citation count).
Other major citation count errors in the data set included:
- Mathew McCubbins: Table 1 should list the total citation count as 1,277 (this count excludes certain co-authored items).
- Robert Keohane, who received his Ph.D. from Harvard University, but was listed as a Duke University Ph.D.
- Stephen Wasby, who received his Ph.D. in 1962, but was listed as having received it in 1952. Wasby should not be listed in the 1950–1954 cohort in Table 1.
If there are other errors in the data set that we have not yet addressed, please feel free to bring them to our attention at BGrofman@uci.edu. However, please remember that citations are as of 2005 and will remain so in this data base.
