Introduction
The first case of the new coronavirus, which was associated with severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), was observed in Wuhan, China, on December 31, 2019, and after that, it quickly spread throughout the countries of the world, including Iran.Reference Ghadir, Ebrazeh and Khodadadi1 In Iran, on February 19, 2020, 2 patients in Qom city were confirmed as SARS-CoV-2 positive. Afterward, the disease spread very rapidly in adjacent provinces near Qom, such as Tehran, Markazi, Isfahan, and Semnan provinces, and shortly thereafter in all 31 provinces of the country.Reference Abdi2 The country had 6.7 million cases of COVID-19, the 12th most in the world, with 133 thousand officially confirmed deaths from the disease as of February 11, 2022.Reference Ebrahimoghli, Abbasi-Ghahramanloo and Moradi-Asl3 The prevalence and incidence of various infectious diseases have historically been one of the most serious threats to human health, the most recent of which is the emergence of COVID-19.Reference Rezabakhsh, Ala and Hassanpour Khodaei4 COVID-19 and its prevalence coincided with the onset of psychological symptoms of anxiety, phobia, and depression together.Reference Yao, Chen and Xu5 Psychological problems, or in other words, psychological distress, manifest themselves with a range of stress, anxiety, and depression. In the face of contagious viruses such as COVID-19, constant anxiety, stress, and mental involvement with the disease may weaken a person’s immune system and prepare him or her for infectious diseases.Reference Wu and McGoogan6 In Hong Kong, anxiety and depression were prevalent during the COVID-19 outbreak.Reference Choi, Hui and Wan7 In Argentina, the results of a study showed a significant relationship between COVID-19 anxiety, worry, and functional impairment.Reference Rogers, Bogiaizian and Salazar8 Chronophobia can be explained by general anxiety, and death anxiety is associated with factors such as nervous vulnerability, health anxiety, and reassuring behaviors.Reference Lee, Jobe and Mathis9 In a nationwide cross-sectional study of 5328 Iranians during April 2020, the prevalence of anxiety and depression was found to be 30.1% and 33.4%, respectively. Higher psychological distress was significantly associated with being female, younger, unemployed, having chronic illness, or knowing someone infected or deceased due to COVID-19. Notably, the death of family members or friends from COVID-19 strongly predicted elevated anxiety and depression levels. These findings underscore the need for targeted mental health support during pandemics.Reference Maroufizadeh, Pourshaikhian and Pourramzani10 Almost everyone is experiencing a type of mental health problem, such as anxiety, depression, fear of death and anger, posttraumatic stress disorder,Reference Rezabakhsh, Ala and Hassanpour Khodaei4 and suicide.Reference Ahmadi and Ramezani11
In a study of general Chinese adults, the COVID-19 anxiety model was calculated using a machine learning algorithmic model, and psychological correlations, demographic variables, and other variables involved in COVID-19 anxiety were examined. The results showed that in the algorithmic model, high stress and mental rumination about COVID-19 were directly and strongly related to COVID-19 anxiety. Anxiety is also a strong predictor of perceived death threat due to COVID-19.Reference Elhai, Yang and McKay12 In another model of COVID-19 anxiety disorder conducted in 35 countries, the results showed that COVID-19 anxiety correlated with age, gender, and social status.Reference Chen, Ng and Hui13 In another study, results indicated a model for predicting anxiety and stress related to COVID-19 among students.Reference Rodríguez-Hidalgo, Pantaleón and Dios14 A study in Iraq found that mandatory quarantine due to the outbreak of COVID-19 significantly increased the level of health anxiety in adults.Reference Taha15
In Spain, a meta-analysis conducted from March 2020 to February 6, 2021, demonstrated that 23 anxiety studies were in the literature during the COVID-19 pandemic.Reference Zhang, Chen and Xu16 A systematic review of psychological problems from PubMed in China showed that anxiety and posttraumatic stress disorder were prevalent.Reference Fan, Zhang and Cheng17 In a large meta-analysis with 71 published articles from China, the United States, Japan, India, and Turkey, the prevalence of anxiety symptoms was prominent.Reference Liu, Zhu and Zhang18 A meta-analysis from major English and Chinese literature databases indicated that during the COVID-19 pandemic, anxiety was reported in most mental health articles.Reference Xie, Liu and Xu19 In Iran, a meta-analysis indicated that anxiety was prevalent among health care workers during the COVID-19 pandemic.Reference Sahebi, Nejati-Zarnaqi and Moayedi20 Another study emphasized high anxiety in health care workers and nurses.Reference Rezaei-Hachesu, Naderyan Fe’li and Maajani21 A cross-sectional study demonstrated the relationship between anxiety and depression in health care workers during the COVID-19 outbreak.Reference Motahedi, Aghdam and Khajeh22
Various psychological interventions improve and decrease anxiety, such as cognitive-behavioral therapies, existential therapy, neurofeedback, and so on.Reference Jandaghi, Firoozi and Zia-Tohidi23 Anxiety due to COVID-19 has symptoms similar to many types of anxiety such as general anxiety,Reference Abdalla, Ettman and Cohen24 health anxiety,Reference Jungmann and Witthöft25 and death anxiety.Reference Menzies and Menzies26 Therefore, psychological interventions affecting anxiety can also affect COVID-19 anxiety.Reference Priyamvada, Ranjan and Chaudhury27 For example, an Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy on COVID-19 anxiety in children showed that their anxiety was reduced as a result of this treatment.Reference Shirotsuki, Sugaya and Nakao28 Another study indicated that psychoeducation, relaxation exercises, and activity schedules can improve post-COVID-19 anxiety.Reference Priyamvada, Ranjan and Chaudhury29 A study in China showed that psychological-behavioral intervention (PBI) with psychological support and breathing exercises decreases the anxiety of COVID-19 hospitalized patients.Reference Kong, Kong and Zheng30
COVID-19 threatens physical health, in addition to causing mental health problems. In Iran, to date, many qualitative and quantitative psychological studies have been conducted on the psychological effects of COVID-19. Most of these studies are cross-sectional, and there is no homogeneity between studies. Therefore, the main purpose of this study was to provide comprehensive statistical results and correlates regarding COVID-19 anxiety and psychological interventions in Iran through a meta-analysis of the existing research and to provide an evidence-based reference for the prevention, monitoring, and management of psychological problems, especially COVID-19 anxiety, after this pandemic.
Materials and Methods
Search Strategy
The method of the present study was a systematic review and meta-analysis, which had 2 stages: the first stage was conducted on the correlation data of COVID-19 anxiety, and the second stage was conducted on psychological interventions on COVID-19 anxiety. We systematically searched the literature in PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Science Direct, ISI, and Persian databases as NOORMAGES and SID from January 2020 to April 2022. Noormags (Noor Specialized Magazines Website) and SID (Scientific Information Database) are the largest article databases in Persian language in Iran. These 2 databases can be accessed at the following addresses: https://www.noormags.ir/view/en and https://www.sid.ir/en/. Our search terms were “mental health” and “psychological or/AND psychiatry or mental states or/AND anxiety or/AND COVID-19 anxiety/AND COVID-19 anxiety treatment” and “psychological or psychiatry or mental disorders or anxiety, COVID-19 anxiety, AND anxiety psychological therapy” for “In Iran, Iranian people” for “COVID-19, COVID-19 disease”. Then, data were extracted from each article by 2 authors independently: year of publication; name of the corresponding author; his/her email; check time (time between the end of epidemic and investigation); study method; total number of participants; region; people of study as students, nurses, and so on screened in the survey; the number of male and female participants was determined; assessment scales used and their cut-offs; and the total number and percentage of participants who screened positive for anxiety and so on. If any of this information was not reported, the researchers emailed the corresponding author of the article to provide the required information. Finally, 2 authors independently evaluated the risk of bias in the included cross-sectional studies using a modified form of the Newcastle Ottawa scale. Their potential disagreements were resolved by a third specialist. Finally, the information extracted was entered into an Excel file, and all statistical data were analyzed by CMA software version 2. In the second stage of the study, the methodological quality of assessment in randomized and nonrandomized studies of correlations and interventions was assessed using the Modified Downs and Black checklist and PEDro Scale. Then, consensus ratings were performed by 2 authors.
The inclusion criteria included (1) articles published in peer-reviewed journals, (2) written in English and Farsi, (3) reporting correlations with COVID-19 anxiety and psychological interventions on COVID-19 anxiety, and (4) data that were quantitatively analyzed. The studies were excluded if: (1) the study population consisted of individuals already suffering from psychiatric or mental distress before COVID-19 outbreak; (2) it was not published in English or Farsi; (3) it was under review or unpublished; (4) all articles in the form of letters to the editor, editor’s speech, case reports, review studies, structural equations studies, qualitative studies as well as articles their not available full text were removed; (5) articles that the scales for measuring mental disorders had no validity.
Quality assessment and data extraction
Articles that were related to our purpose were downloaded. Thereafter, we wrote the list of articles with authors and deleted any irrelevant or repetitive articles. We searched the references of the selected articles for any other relevant studies not found in our initial search. Finally, we extracted the main information from the articles and then analyzed them. In the first search, we found 105 articles. Of these articles, 40 were qualitative, while 65 were quantitative. Among quantitative articles, 13 articles predicted COVID-19 anxiety and 14 articles reported psychological interventions for COVID-19 anxiety (figure 1).
Flow chart for the search strategy.
A flowchart of the inclusions of studies in the present meta-analysis.

Results
In the correlational stage, 13 articles and in the psychological intervention stage of meta-analysis, 14 studies were included (the included studies are marked in the reference list). The sample size for the correlational stage of the meta-analysis was 2.757, and exactly 711 persons were assigned to the interventional stage. The mean age for the correlational stage was 41.39, and for the interventional stage was 38.05. A total of 2 studies included women only, 7 studies included men and women, and 1 study included men only. Available samples were selected in 2 stages of the study, but in all interventional studies, participants were randomly assigned to the experimental and control groups. All effect sizes of the articles in this stage of the study are significant at the 0.95 level. The average overall effect size of all 13 articles in each fixed and random model is significant at the level of 0.001. The highest effect size in these 13 articles is the second study (0.696), the twelfth study (0.665), the thirteenth study (0.604), and the ninth study (0.571), respectively (Table 1).
Systematic review and meta-data analysis of variables correlated with COVID-19 anxiety

The mean overall effect size of studies on COVID-19 anxiety correlates was 0.0001 for the fixed effects model. The results of the meta-analyses for psychological correlation with COVID-19 anxiety indicated the pooled effect was based on highly heterogeneous effect size (ES) between the original studies (P = .0001/I2 = 97.27%). These pooled ES for COVID-19 anxiety were based on highly homogeneous results between individual studies. The Q index was used to study the heterogeneity of the studies. The Q index was calculated with a degree of freedom of 12 (Q = 440.988), which is significant at the level of 0.001. Therefore, the null hypothesis is not confirmed, and we conclude that the studies studied are heterogeneous. However, the number of studies is not small. However, the I2 statistic was also calculated to be 97,279, which indicates and proves a lot of heterogeneity in these studies. Thus, the analyzed studies are common in one true effect size, and the differences in effect size are due to sampling error. On the other hand, random effect calculations are also significant. Therefore, the heterogeneity of studies is not due to statistical methods. For this reason, the fixed-effects model was used, and the moderator variables were investigated (Figure 2).
The meta-analysis of variables correlated with COVID-19 anxiety.
The distance between each line in the forest canopy represents the confidence interval for the estimate. The diamond represents the overall estimate, and the dots on its sides represent the confidence intervals for that estimate.

The psychological interventions included cognitive-behavioral therapy,Reference Naserinia and borjali44, Reference Shabahang45, Reference Jani, Mikaeili and Rahimi47–Reference Shokrgozar, nekoonam and Nikkhah50, Reference Shabahang, Bagheri Sheykhangafshe and Dadras53–Reference Dana, Ranjbari and Salehian55 reality therapy,Reference Shomaliahmadabadi and Barkhordari Ahmadabadi48, Reference Mousavi49 emotion-focused therapy,Reference Naserinia and borjali44 neurofeedback,Reference Shokrgozar, nekoonam and Nikkhah50 existential therapy,Reference Alizadeh, Taklavi and Mahmoud Alilou54 and positive thinking skills training.Reference Shokrgozar, nekoonam and Nikkhah50 The total duration of the interventions varied between 1 hour and 90 minutes. The number of sessions was at least 6 sessions,Reference Shomaliahmadabadi and Barkhordari Ahmadabadi48, Reference Shokrgozar, nekoonam and Nikkhah50 8 sessions,Reference Shabahang45–Reference Shomaliahmadabadi and Barkhordari Ahmadabadi48, Reference Shokrgozar, nekoonam and Nikkhah50 9 sessions,Reference Dargahi and Safarzadeh57 10 sessions,Reference Nasiry and Ameli52–Reference Alizadeh, Taklavi and Mahmoud Alilou54 12 sessions,Reference Jani, Mikaeili and Rahimi47, Reference Shomaliahmadabadi and Barkhordari Ahmadabadi48, Reference Dana, Ranjbari and Salehian55, Reference Heyrat, Aghajani fesharaki and Safara56 and a maximum of 15 sessionsReference Naserinia and borjali44 (Table 2). In all studies, the control group received routine information, and they did not receive any interventions.
Systematic review meta-data analysis of psychological intervention on COVID-19 anxiety

C: Control group; Ex: Experimental group; NR: none-reported.
The results of the meta-analyses were assessed for the effect of psychological interventions on COVID-19 anxiety in 14 articles, which indicated the pooled effect was highly heterogeneous between the original studies (P = .00/I2 = 85.67%). These pooled ES for COVID-19 anxiety (ES=38) were based on high homogeneous results among individual studies (Figure 3).
The meta-analysis of psychological interventions on COVID-19 anxiety.
The distance between each line in the forest canopy represents the confidence interval for the estimate. The diamond represents the overall estimate, and the dots on its sides represent the confidence intervals for that estimate.

Discussion
In the first stage of this study, a meta-analysis was performed on COVID-19 anxiety correlates. The purpose of this meta-analysis was to combine the different findings of available studies and the possibility of more accurate conclusions. As the results showed, the mean overall ES of studies on COVID-19 anxiety correlates was 0.0001 and for the fixed effects model was 0.021. In other words, psychological correlates with COVID-19 anxiety were assessed in 13 articles and indicated the pooled effect was based on highly heterogeneous ES between the original studies (P = .0001/I2 = 97.27%). The findings of this study indicated that there are correlations between anxiety due to COVID-19 and various factors including maternal aggression,Reference Shirzadi, Amini Shirazi and Asgharpour Lashkami31 mental health,Reference Alizadehfard and Saffarinia32 anxiety tolerance,Reference Salari, Bakraei, Sharifnejad Nemat Abadi, Alizadeh and Mohseni33 stress,Reference Rezaei, Sameni Toosarvandani and Zebardast34 death anxiety,Reference Ezazi Bojnourdi, Ghadampour and Moradi Shakib35 coping strategies,Reference Abdoli, Mirzaei and Abdoli36 depression,Reference Zolfaghari and Elahi37 nursing care behaviors,Reference Asadi, Salmani and Pourkhajooyi38 perceived social support,Reference Eyni, Ebadi and Hashemi39 helplessness,Reference Farhadi and Gholamnazari40 general mental health,Reference Alizadeh Birjandi, Ghonchei and Hokmabadi41 general anxietyReference Akhlaghifard and Meraji42 and health anxietyReference Shahamatinejad43. All of these relationships demonstrate significant effect sizes. The anxiety induced by the COVID-19 pandemic may have also contributed to the initiation or escalation of alcohol consumption and substance abuse. Studies from Iran reported a notable rise in methanol-related deaths, particularly during the first 3 months of the outbreak—driven largely by misinformation regarding alcohol’s alleged protective effects against COVID-19. On average, there was an increase of 33.8 alcohol-related deaths per month.Reference Behnoush, Bazmi and Forouzesh58 Additionally, a rise in the use of sedatives, including opioids and over-the-counter medications, was observed during the pandemic.Reference Sotoudeh, Khoshnood and Rastegari59
Examination of the effect size separately showed that the largest effect size was related to mental health, general anxiety, health anxiety, perceived social support, maternal aggression, death anxiety, helplessness, and depression. In other words, in some of these studies, COVID-19 anxiety affects others and those around them.Reference Shirzadi, Amini Shirazi and Asgharpour Lashkami31, Reference Alizadehfard and Saffarinia32, Reference Zolfaghari and Elahi37, Reference Asadi, Salmani and Pourkhajooyi38 Some articles have been studied on a specific sample, such as workers in health and treatment centers who were on the front lines of COVID-19 or special patients.Reference Alizadehfard and Saffarinia32, Reference Ezazi Bojnourdi, Ghadampour and Moradi Shakib35, Reference Abdoli, Mirzaei and Abdoli36, Reference Asadi, Salmani and Pourkhajooyi38, Reference Eyni, Ebadi and Hashemi39, Reference Akhlaghifard and Meraji42 Some studies have also been conducted on people in society as a whole.Reference Alizadehfard and Saffarinia32, Reference Alizadeh Birjandi, Ghonchei and Hokmabadi41, Reference Shahamatinejad43 The sizes of effects mentioned are almost consistent with Wu and McGoogan,Reference Wu and McGoogan6 Maroufizadeh et al.,Reference Maroufizadeh, Pourshaikhian and Pourramzani10 Elhai et al.,Reference Elhai, Yang and McKay12 Liu et al.,Reference Liu, Zhu and Zhang18 and Sahebi et al.Reference Sahebi, Nejati-Zarnaqi and Moayedi20 In explaining this finding, it can be said that anxiety is the initial reaction to an unknown situation that can affect all aspects of mental health.Reference Karnbach, Witkowski and Ebrahimi60 Anxiety is associated with a variety of factors, and so anxiety is associated with a variety of psychological variables. In Iran, as in other countries, COVID-19 and the lack of awareness of it caused anxiety to different people with different demographic characteristics. In other words, based on demographic characteristics, COVID-19 anxiety can be related to various psychological factors. A review of the research literature by meta-analysis in foreign studies also showed that several psychological factors are associated with COVID-19 anxiety, and their effect size is moderate to high. As reported in a meta-analytic study of health professionals, high levels of anxiety with moderate effect size were reported in conjunction with other psychological problems.Reference Abdulla, Velladath and Varghese61 Another study reported the high effect of the association between anxiety, depression, and distress in the general population.Reference Necho, Tsehay and Birkie62
The results of the second stage of the meta-analysis of psychological interventions for COVID-19 anxiety indicated the overall efficacy. The results of studies outside Iran, such as the studies of Shirotsuki et al., indicated that Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy reduced COVID-19 anxiety in children.Reference Shirotsuki, Sugaya and Nakao28 Kong et al. showed that psychological-behavioral intervention decreases the anxiety of COVID-19 hospitalized patients.Reference Kong, Kong and Zheng30 The results of the present study showed that there were significant effects of psychological interventions in association with COVID-19 anxiety in Iran. In these studies, general agreement among researchers demonstrated that high levels of COVID-19 anxiety among COVID-19 patients or the general population are psychologically solid reactions to the COVID-19 outbreak. This can lead to a moderate to strong effect on any type of psychological intervention in critical situations such as the COVID-19 pandemic. The high heterogeneity (I2 = 85.67%) of psychological interventions for COVID-19 anxiety might also be explained by emotional or affective adjustment processes with this pandemic, quarantine conditions, characteristics of the studied sample, nonuniform type of interventions, different amount of treatment sessions in each treatment method, different number of samples in each study, and so on. Accordingly, a meta-analysis study found that a variety of psychological interventions were effective on COVID-19-related reactions such as anxiety and depression.Reference Renjun, Ziyun and Xiwu63 Another meta-analysis study showed that selected positive psychology interventions have a highly significant effect on anxiety due to COVID-19.Reference Fischer, Bortolini and Karl64 Based on this, it can be said that in emergencies such as the outbreak of COVID-19, a variety of psychological interventions can be effective on situational anxiety. It seems that at the beginning of the outbreak of COVID-19, researchers used different psychological therapies for anxiety alleviation, but in the end, they used the same cognitive behavioral therapy that is used in the reduction of all types of anxiety, and its effect was significant, and they achieved the same result. As well as the random effect size model used in this study indicated that the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy in COVID-19 anxiety was higher than other psychotherapies.
In the sampling of previous studies, the present meta-analysis was performed to avoid bias in sampling, findings, discussion inside and outside the trash, uniqueness, and lack of independence of effects, over-emphasis on individual effects, and finally, the problem of apples and oranges compositions, as meta-analysis limitations.Reference Tawfik, Dila and Mohamed65 Therefore, in this study, all available research backgrounds were collected without any prejudice in order to observe ethical principles. We did not pay attention to the studies that had ambiguities and problems in terms of methodology and statistical models. In the present study, only 13 articles on COVID-19 anxiety correlation in the first section, and 14 articles in the section on psychological interventions affecting COVID-19 anxiety, met the necessary and appropriate criteria for entering the process of meta-analysis.
One of the limitations of this study was that some databases in Iran were closed, and most of the studies were abstract and could not be accessed. This issue causes the funnel plots to point to possible publication bias. Another limitation was the novelty of the subject, and not many studies have been performed on different types of COVID-19 anxiety correlations or other psychological interventions. Also that in all interventions, individuals were treated in groups and the effects of treatment were evaluated as a group. Therefore, it is one of the limitations of this stage of research and the size of the effect has not been calculated at the individual level. Another limitation was that in the articles that were included in the study, the results were not reported separately for demographic groups such as gender, age, education, and occupation. Therefore, we could not provide a separate report of demographic groups in the research results section.
Conclusions
We have found that COVID-19 anxiety is related to psychological variables such as maternal aggression, mental health, anxiety tolerance, stress, death anxiety, coping strategies, depression, nursing care behaviors, perceived social support, helplessness, general mental health, general anxiety, and health anxiety. In the second stage of the study, we concluded that cognitive behavioral therapy, psychological-behavioral therapy, existential therapy, hope therapy, neurofeedback, and emotion-focused therapy have been effective on COVID-19 anxiety. Therefore, other researchers are expected to consider these considerations in future studies. As discussed in the introduction and examined from various dimensions, COVID-19 anxiety has a significant correlation with many variables, and psychological interventions are effective in it. Unfortunately, the weakness of research conducted in Iran on COVID-19 anxiety, including noncompliance with methodological principles, haste in data collection, and rapid writing of articles during the COVID-19 pandemic period, made it possible to use all research. Hence, a suitable platform was not provided for examining all variables that correlated with COVID-19 anxiety and the determination of mediating variables. Future studies, based on this finding, can elucidate other variables associated with COVID-19 anxiety and examine mitigating variables and other side effects of psychological therapies. On the other hand, it was impossible to access all the raw data, and the data in the articles were only used for the analysis.
Data availability statement
Data are available on reasonable request.
Acknowledgments
We would like to express our deepest gratitude to the authors of the analyzed articles, who provided their study information to the researchers.
Author contribution
FR contributed to conceptualization, analysis, and write-up. KA supervised this work as the corresponding author. All authors read and approved the manuscript before submission.
Funding statement
The authors did not receive any financial support for conducting this research, authoring, and/or publishing this article.
Competing interests
The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest.
Ethical standard
Not required in this study.
Registration
PROSPERO (CRD42022355563).
